Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Cape Cod go-to for New Haven-style thin-crust pies & slices, plus sandwiches, subs & burritos.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 461 Station Ave, South Yarmouth, MA 02664
Phone: (508) 394-6054
Website: http://www.sweettomatoescapecod.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sweet Tomatoes Pizza – Yarmouth
New Haven-Style pizza shop that sells by the slice or whole PIzzas. Thin and Crispy.
Sweet Tomatoes Pizza (South Yarmouth, MA) presented by Kraken
Barstool Pizza Review – Sweet Tomatoes Pizza (South Yarmouth, MA) presented by Kraken. 176K views · 7 months ago …more. One Bite Pizza Reviews.
Sweet Tomatoes Pizza Restaurant in South Yarmouth Cape Cod
I tried Sweet Tomatoes when I was home a couple months ago. It was ok. When I was a kid growing up in South Yarmouth in the 70’s and 80’s …
Reviews
Chris Kolacz
Came here for Caesar Wrap and Buffalo wings. Was not disappointed. The service was quick and the price was reasonable. I loved the decor around the restaurant.
… moreMichaela D.
For the last 3 years, my family’s first stop on the Cape has been Sweet Tomatoes! There is something for everyone but the pizza cannot be beat. Thin crust, sweet sauce, and always made fresh. If you don’t have time to wait, they have slices available. Definitely recommend checking out if you’re looking for pizza on the cape!
… moreRobert Cape
I’m hoping we caught an off day because we’ve enjoyed excellent food and atmosphere here for a long time. Pizza on our most recent visit was pretty good, though not great. Bigger issue was general cleanliness of the bathrooms and floors throughout the restaurant. Really hoping it was just a blip and not a bad sign.
… moreAnn P
5 stars for the super cool dudes who serve pretty tasty food. The pizza is really good and they have some tasty treats too. It’s best for take out but there are seats for eat in.
… moreEvan Olf
Best pizza around by miles. Having been going out of my way to stop just for a slice. Absolutely never disappoints
… moreAllyssa Randall
My absolute favorite pizza. I have been coming here for 10+ish years and they have remained consistent. Always delicious, always reasonable wait times, i have never been disappointed. Even after moving away its always my first stop when I go home
… morePerri Sanborn
We get takeout here with some regularity, and the food is hit and miss. A while ago, I ordered a veggie garden pizza, and it had almost no cheese on it at all, like they ran out and put the tiny bit that was left on my pizza. But even worse was yesterday. I got a veggie calzone, and the marinara that came with it appears to have had hamburger in it. If hamburger is a always in their red sauce, they need to let customers know. The calzone was delicious tho. I will probably keep getting food here because sometimes it’s great and sometimes it’s not. Maybe it depends on how busy they are.
… moreD B
I live down the street and have tried 80% of the menu. Pizzas are great, I always ask for them well done to get them crispy. Don’t sleep on their meatball grinder either! Unfortunately they recently took off my favorite menu item, a cheeseburger pizza inspired by a Big Mac. I hope they bring it back!
… moreSteve Mower
I was excited when I saw new haven style pizza and some good sounding sandwiches. Unfortunately, the pizza was missing “it”. I’m not sure if it was the dough or the sauce, but it didn’t have a ton of flavor. Toppings were generous and it was well done, which I prefer, but it was close to being overcooked. We also got a prosciutto sandwich, which comes on focaccia and similar to the pizza, the bread was borderline overcooked. The ingredients of the sandwich were tasty and so was our mozzarella sticks appetizer. The place itself has great pizzeria vibes, but I would probably look elsewhere next time we get pizza around here. The guy at the register wasn’t too friendly either.
… moreSumayyah Rawashdeh
We got the street corn pizza and it was exceptional! Everyone loved it and devoured it Highly recommend
… more