Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 308 Front St 2nd Floor, Key West, FL 33040
Phone: (305) 741-7397
Website: https://surlysirensaloon.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Surly Siren Saloon | Bar | 308 Front Street, Key West, FL, USA
Bar and restaurant with Live music 7 days a week at the Surly Siren Saloon.
Surly Siren Saloon, 308 Front St, Key West, FL 33040, US – MapQuest
Reviews · Best margaritas – great staff and a place that accepts everyone would strongly recommend to Key West visitors · We stopped by Surely Siren Saloon for …
Surly Siren Saloon | Florida Keys & Key West
Surly Siren Saloon in Key West is the go-to spot for craft cocktails, ice-cold beers, and a vibrant nightlife experience. With its energetic atmosphere and …
Reviews
Mayra Tirado
We stopped by Surely Siren Saloon for dinner and were blown away. The drinks were amazing, the musicians were so talented (we stayed so long we listened to two artists!), the staff was SO fun and friendly, but the real cherry on top was how great the food was!! I wish we took more photos, but the smashburger was some of the best we’ve ever had (this is coming from a Chicagoan), the pig wings were amazing and came clean off the bone! And the umami fish sliders were so so tasty. Again, we were blown away and highly recommend! You won’t be disappointed
… moreKristy D
This lil place ROCKS. Came here on a hunt for wings and they were exactly what I was looking for. Deliciously crispy and juicy inside! Good pricing and It’s a great vibe. service was on point. Amy took great care of us. Looking forward to being their next regulars! P.s, yes their mermaritas are fabulous.
… moreCoCo Valer
Best Smash Burger in town! Had to come try the award winning burger and it does not disappoint. Jordan, Kyle and Holly were amazing and cant forget Adam for making my Burger. Overall will definitely recommend and come back for 2nds,3rds etc.
… moreHashtag Key West
Great afternoon drinking and eating in the Heart of Key West. Right near Mallory Square and the Sunset Celebration. They have an award winning Mermarita and Smashburger. Perfect cruise ship destination. Phoebe was the best bartender.
… morePaul McLellan
Trust the other popular reviews here, this place has the best burger around. In fact, I am from Minnesota and this might be the best burger I’ve ever had.
I ordered the original burger with sweet tots and a side of pickled fries. Everything was absolutely amazing. The burger literally melts in your mouth.
… moreI ordered the original burger with sweet tots and a side of pickled fries. Everything was absolutely amazing. The burger literally melts in your mouth.
Timo Gätzschmann
Great atmosphere, food was fantastic. The live music on stage was surprisingly good, which I hadn’t expected in a bar. The prices and portions were surprisingly reasonable for Key West. All in all, a very enjoyable stay.
… moreLauren Ogren
The staff was super nice. We had the pulled pork tater tots and the smashburgers. They were so delicious – I have no notes! Their margaritas are also deeeeelicious. I definitely recommend stopping here if you’re in key west.
… moreBrian Mattingly
Ok I wasn’t expecting this to be the best food I’ve had in Key West but here’s we are… holy cow the food is the best! Other restaurants need to take notes!
… moreKathy Bromley
Locally woman owned bar upstairs in Key West. Tons of variety and crazy good service. We didn’t eat but the drinks were a good price and super cold.
… moreLogan Boesch
THE SMASH FILES — Surly Siren Saloon, Key West FL
Score: 8.4/10
This one came with a trophy in the shot and deserved it. Surly Siren brought a super flavorful, non-traditional Smashie with their own spin on the classic.
Breakdown:
✔️ Patty: extra delicious thanks to a garlic-butter glaze they marinate it in before grilling
✔️ Cheese: two kinds — cheddar underneath + a mozzarella-style melt on top, both fused perfectly
✔️ Crisp: solid edge sear, great texture
✔️ Veggies: fresh, balanced, clean bite
✔️ Sauces: classic ketchup + mustard combo
⚠️ Docked points because it was a single smash, not a traditional double
Overall: A unique, flavorful take on a Smashburger with big Key West personality. Definitely worth trying — and they’ve got another version with grilled onions + chipotle aioli if you want to mix it up. Hard to argue with an award-winning burger by the water.
Where should I go next in the Keys? Drop your recs
#SmashFiles #SmashburgerSearch #CertifiedSmashie #BurgerReview
… moreScore: 8.4/10
This one came with a trophy in the shot and deserved it. Surly Siren brought a super flavorful, non-traditional Smashie with their own spin on the classic.
Breakdown:
✔️ Patty: extra delicious thanks to a garlic-butter glaze they marinate it in before grilling
✔️ Cheese: two kinds — cheddar underneath + a mozzarella-style melt on top, both fused perfectly
✔️ Crisp: solid edge sear, great texture
✔️ Veggies: fresh, balanced, clean bite
✔️ Sauces: classic ketchup + mustard combo
⚠️ Docked points because it was a single smash, not a traditional double
Overall: A unique, flavorful take on a Smashburger with big Key West personality. Definitely worth trying — and they’ve got another version with grilled onions + chipotle aioli if you want to mix it up. Hard to argue with an award-winning burger by the water.
Where should I go next in the Keys? Drop your recs
#SmashFiles #SmashburgerSearch #CertifiedSmashie #BurgerReview