Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
At Suprema, we’re all about fresh, high-quality ingredients and delicious, made-to-order Italian dishes that bring people together. Our warm, friendly staff treats every guest like family, creating a welcoming atmosphere where you’ll always feel at home. We love keeping things exciting with fun specials, unique menu creations, and seasonal dishes that give you something new to look forward to. Whether you’re stopping by for a casual meal or a special occasion, we’re here to make every visit memorable. Conveniently located in Rutherford, less than 10 minutes from MetLife Stadium, we’re a perfect spot for pre-game and post-game dining during events and matches. Come experience great food, great service, and a great time!
Rustic-chic cafe & gourmet market for organic Italian sandwiches, pastas and packaged goods.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 92 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070
Phone: (201) 531-1190
Website: http://supremaitalian.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Suprema | Gourmet Lunch and Dinner Restaurant Rutherford, NJ
Rustic-chic cafe & gourmet market for organic Italian sandwiches, pastas and packaged goods. 92 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070.
Suprema | Rutherford NJ – Facebook
Suprema, Rutherford. 2132 likes · 102 talking about this · 2226 were here. Experience elevated Italian American cuisine Open for lunch Monday &…
Suprema (@supremaitalian) • Instagram photos and videos
… suprema #foodie #rutherfordnj #nj #njeats. Photo by Suprema in Suprema … #suprema #italian #rutherford #newjersey #njeats #pasta. Photo by Suprema in …
Last Updates
Reviews
Alyssa RH Gattoni
I had my baby shower here and it was a dream!!! The food is truly unbelievably good and the staff went so above and beyond to make sure we had a great experience. I could rave about this place for hours and hours. Chicken parm is unreal, artichoke salad is incredible, the meatballs are amazing, their vodka sauce is delicious, cheesy garlic bread is divine, etc. etc. The food was so good that some people ordered dishes to go to have for dinner that night!!! Shout out to Sara who was an amazing host to us!
… moreBeverly Schmidt
Suprema was always good, however they have more recently elevated their food to a 5 star level. Lunch for 2 consisted of 2 of the specials: gnocchi suprema and spicy monique sandwich.
Both were outstanding! And our darling waitress had the kitchen spilt the order!
Very delicious! ( and I love that the specials are offered for lunch and dinner).
… moreBoth were outstanding! And our darling waitress had the kitchen spilt the order!
Very delicious! ( and I love that the specials are offered for lunch and dinner).
Eddie Grand
Loved this place! BYOB with a liquor store right across the street and they gave us an ice bucket for our drinks. The vibes and music were on point that’s the first thing I noticed. Great service, friendly staff, and the food was good. Would definitely recommend this place.
… moreChristian Bonilla
BYOB! Went for a birthday celebration, ten plus table. Off-street meter parking only, so parking can be a hassle. Reservations were made so seated immediately. Appetizers were tasteful and came on time. Im always skeptical with Italian restaurants having tried so many, but interesting enough the dish my wife and I selected were not heavy in the sauce. I had no acid reflux at night which even solidified this review. Would come back again! APPROVED!
… moreJean Perez
I’ve visited Suprema multiple times and the quality is always consistent and delicious. Just had an amazing lunch with rice balls, meatballs, and two sandwiches: the roast beef and the chicken parm with vodka sauce. The bread had the perfect softness and crunch, and everything tasted as phenomenal as it looked. I’ve tried their pasta before too and it’s always so fresh and flavorful. Finished with pistachio gelato and coffees. Definitely visiting again very soon!
… moreKelly W
Myself and my husband are Rutherford locals and this has been our favorite restaurant since we moved. It was our first lunch spot when we closed on our house and this past Sunday we hosted our baby shower at Suprema.
I can’t say enough about how wonderful the experience was. The owners are wonderful, accommodating and responsive working with us to make sure our experience was great.
We hosted in the side room which fit 30 people perfectly. The family style menu worked amazingly and everyone raved about the food.
The servers were incredible and friendly. We were given access to the space well in advance to decorate and get everything ready.
At no point did I feel rushed. It was just such a beautiful day.
Will be back here for our usual dinner dates and girls nights as always!
… moreI can’t say enough about how wonderful the experience was. The owners are wonderful, accommodating and responsive working with us to make sure our experience was great.
We hosted in the side room which fit 30 people perfectly. The family style menu worked amazingly and everyone raved about the food.
The servers were incredible and friendly. We were given access to the space well in advance to decorate and get everything ready.
At no point did I feel rushed. It was just such a beautiful day.
Will be back here for our usual dinner dates and girls nights as always!
Anna Scala (DOG CAKES FOR DOGS)
I took my friend out to lunch for her birthday at Suprema. The food was excellent. The server, Maggie was confident, sweet, competent and pleasant. Even putting a candle in my friend’s gelato. We will b back. Thank you for making it a pleasant experience ❤️
… moreJuanita G
Hello my Foodies! So I was at this place for my friends Birthday. They have real food meaning made fresh and organic. I could tell it tasted so Different from the processed food I am used to I guess. Everything tasted fresh, and it did take me a minute to get into this food, but after a bit, I really did like my pasta. The chocolate dessert we got after was absolutely delicious. The pasta I had tasted great the next day. Also, that Steaz drink was delicious! Order it! Our server was excellent and took great care of our party. I did hear another server tell a young couple who came in around 8pm that they couldn’t seat them because the kitchen closed at 730pm. I thought that was kinda early, especially since their operating hours say until 9 pm. But maybe because it was a Wednesday? I’m not sure. They don’t have parking so you need to find parking in the street, but it was really good food. I recommend checking this place out.
… moresal saccone
It’s a nice place.The food is pretty good.The portions are a little small, and the prices are very high.Would have given five stars if the portions were bigger and the prices were a little lower
… moreOkang McBride
You can’t go wrong with this small authentic BYOB —- Italian restaurant in Rutherford, NJ. The food was fresh and I love food made to order. You can tell that it wasn’t made in advance which is a huge advantage over other restaurants when eating out. Service was great but the restaurant is a little bit loud because you can hear all of the conversation happening around you. Definitely give this place a try this summer because I’ll be going back.
… more