Brad Witt
My friend and I visit a different restaurant every Friday for lunch. Sullys has took over the lead from Schimtyy’s Oar House.
Both of our meals were absolutely delicious! This was the first time we’ve been to Sully’s because we’re too old for the bar scene. The bartender was extremely friendly as well. We will definitely return!!!!! 10++++
… moreGeorge Henze
Nice place. A little on the small side, but it seems to have been recently updated. Food was good with large portions. I got the Irish nachos. They were good. A bit heavy but you certainly feel like you got your money’s worth after eating them.
… moreGREY DAKKO
5 stars across the board!! The atmosphere was welcoming and very calm. We sat at the bar and ordered some drinks and a food menu. We got the Cowboy Burger and Crispy Chicken Sandwich. Both came out freshly made and the fries were seasoned well! The bartender was friendly and make sure we always had something to drink. Thanks Sully’s! We will be back if we are in the area.
… moreMark Jolin
First time in. Really great place all around. Nice little location. Food was amazing! Atmosphere was really cozy feeling! The music ended up a little louder but overall nice place!
… moreGordon Duer
The first time here had the Sullys burger. Cooked med with fried onions. The burger was pretty good. This time went with fish and chips, the fish was like out of a box, looked really good but taste was not there. Try it for yourself but I would not recommend. The Pub itself is great since remodel. Looks great, they keep it clean.
… moreDoug
Stopped in and had some pizza. It was pretty good. And half off on Mondays
… moreRachel
Updated in December: We got some food here and had drinks while watching the Bucks game. The food was awesome! Irish nachos are a MUST! Hubby liked the wings, too!
We didn’t eat here but had bloody Mary’s and really enjoyed our time here! The bartender Candace was super friendly!
… more
I noticed nearly 50 people mention the burger in their reviews. 90% rated them great, best burger in FDL, etc. Well, put me in the great burger column. It’s easily one of the best I’ve had, and I have had a LOT. I asked for “some pink,” and as you can see in the picture, it was more than a little pink, but based on the reviews, I decided to give it a try. OMG, I’m glad I did. It was excellent. So was the service, I didn’t catch the bartenders name but she was definitely an asset to the team.
… moreKevin K
Drove past this place thousands of times, finally decided to try it, kind of wish I didn’t. Ordered a western burger for carryout and decided I’d have a pint while I waited, which was estimated to be 45 mins. No big deal, it was new years eve at noon, maybe a few extra people in the bar. Got there and bar had most seats occupied but place was not packed, yet it took a good 15 minutes just to get a beer, bartender was nice and checked in often but had a bad habit of asking questions and then just walking away. Beer was very good. Cold and fresh, tap domestic. Food showed up, by then I was ready to pay tab and that took another 10 minutes because bartender again disappeared, but before she took care of that she was ready to handle refills for some regulars that had been served numerous times already ignoring me standing there with my card in the process.
Food was lackluster. Large portions, but the bacon on the burger was undercooked, and unrendered. I picked it off and tried the burger that didn’t come with any produce on the side or even a pickle. Not great, like a home cooked burger with some seasoning salt. Ordered medium, definitely rare rare. Whatever, that’s not a big deal, and the fries were okay….but the whole experience kind of sucked having now taken an hour and a half to get a subpar burger from start to finish. Felt pushed to the side from the moment I walked in as well. There are definitely better burgers and beer in town.
… moreNick Plahn
Kitchen is open til 10pm, good menu selection. The burger was great, patty was seasoned well. Shepard’s pie was okay, it was topped with chili powder which was odd.
… more