John Rodriguez
Stopped in for the first time ever for a late-night treat and was blown away by the desserts and flavors. It was great to meet Shane himself and hear more about how they got started. Despite being late, they gave awesome recommendations and the cookies were fresh and tasty. You can tell Shane and his team put their heart into what they do and it definitely comes through in their desserts. An incredible small business that I’d recommend to everyone! Y’all have a new fan!
… moreJustin Gumbs
Second visit to Sugar Shane’s Cookies and they are absolutely amazing. The Oatmeal Cream Pie cookie is out of this world. Shout out to Saeed, who is always super nice whenever I come in. This place is definitely a cookie staple for me. I’ll gladly drive from Sandy Springs to Dunwoody just to grab one of their cookies. They’re that good. Honestly, they make Crumbl Cookies taste like a cardboard box.
… moreAlesha Lane
Big Dipper was super good but I’m really writing to give kudos to Erika. She was welcoming, patient, helpful & kind. In real life she’s probably the most friendly person. Perfect personality for customer service.
… moreAnjali Guli
Love Love Love..!! absolutely love the desserts here. recommend trying out the virgin bar, smores pie and dubai pie. Virgin bar is the best it is so moist and has perfect amount of sweetness in it. Heat it up 15 seconds and eat it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.. yummmm!!
… moreExplorer
Idk what to write. All their desserts are amazing. Sometimes I think of eating it during the days I don’t have them. They are dangerously good!
… moreAkshat
5/5 for this Sugar Shane’s location in Sandy Springs north of Atlanta—we were looking for something to satisfy our sweet tooth after a busy day of touristing in Atlanta and Sugar Shane came to the rescue.
We got the s’more and the pistachio cookie, and both tasted divine. The milk chocolate in s’more really hit the spot. The server also gave us a complimentary chocolate chip cookie, which was a wonderful gesture. She was kind and polite and answered all our questions.
They also have ice cream made from their cookie flavours. They specialize in cookies but have other delectable items too.
It’s a 15 minute walk from the Dunwoody Marta station, and it wasn’t busy on the Saturday afternoon that we visited. They offer discounts if you purchase half dozen or dozen items.
Overall, it’s a great place to satisfy your sweet tooth craving.
… moreCassandra Lumpkin
I’ve been eating cookies from Sugar Shane’s for years. Lately the s’mores have been my favorite. When I heard that they were now serving cinnamon rolls with a cream cheese icing I was so excited to indulge. Their instagram page advertised them to be available at 11am when they first open. As any bakery, I’m expecting to be able to purchase fresh pastries once they open. To my surprise upon arrival at 11:05am, the vanilla cinnamon roll was not available and would not be available until an hour later. Highly disappointed!! It’s a day later and I’m still messed up about it. The biscoff was available so I purchased two of those since I had planned a coffee and cinnamon roll date with my bestie and couldn’t meet her empty handed. After our first bite we could immediately tell that they had been sitting out for a long time and were not fluffy and soft as we expected. I hate to say this but it tasted stale.
… moreJohnathin Harris
Hailey at Sugar Shane (1110 Hammond Dr, Unit 30, Atlanta, GA 30328) absolutely deserves a shoutout.
I walked in and she was literally on her knees cleaning—top notch. When I say I ain’t never wanted to eat off the floor so bad in my life… that’s how spotless she had it. And on top of that, her customer service was out of this world. Even though I was only there picking up a DoorDash order, she still treated me with respect, moved with urgency, and had such a positive attitude that it stood out immediately.
Sugar Shane needs to give Hailey a raise and do what they have to do to keep her, because she’s a real asset to the company—and the company is lucky to have her.
… moreBrooke Ford
I really wanted to love these cookies because I’ve heard nothing but good things about Sugar Shane’s, but I wasn’t super impressed. My husband and I LOVE dessert and trying new places, but this was sadly a bust for us. The service here was GREAT and the atmosphere was good for the little shop. The cookies we got were lemon, biscoff, and strawberry. Strawberry just tasted like a plain cookie with really thick icing and didn’t have much strawberry flavor. The biscoff cookie also tasted like a plain cookie with biscoff sprinkled on top. The lemon cookie was good and had a decent lemon flavor, but none of these cookies were super soft/gooey or had a lot of flavor. I’d go back and try different flavors to give it another chance AND I was told the Dubai brownie was as delicious, so I’d try that also. But if I try them again and feel the same then unfortunately I wouldn’t be going back.
… moreMike N
Very nice in flavor, texture, and appearance. VERY sweet/sugary—as you’d expect. 🙂
Ordered the Bulldog and the Nana’s Puddin’, and enjoyed both—though neither knocked my socks off.
Great service (friendly and helpful)!
… more