Unassuming eatery with kitschy decor offering thick-crust pies, simple pastas & sandwiches.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 147 Cedar Hill Rd, Lancaster, OH 43130
Phone: (740) 689-1717
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sugar Bears Pizzeria | Lancaster OH – Facebook
Attention Sugar Bears Pizzeria Customers We are not permanently closed. We were closed for our yearly Christmas vacation, but are open to normal hours!!!
Sugar Bears Pizzeria – Visit Fairfield County
Stop by Sugar Bears Pizza in Lancaster, Ohio for some delicious slices, pasta, and sandwiches at a delightful pizzeria! Dine-in or delivery available.
Menus for Sugar Bears Pizzeria – Lancaster – SinglePlatform
Toppings: Patrick Cudahy Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage, Bacon, Hamburger, Salami, Chicken, 100% Provolone Cheese, Cheddar Cheese, Hot Pepper Cheese, Mushrooms, …
Reviews
Bryan Wing
Still my favorite pizza, period! I consider myself a pizza connoisseur for sure. My second favorite is an Italian restaurant with true Italian owners up in Dublin. Both have a thin, crispy crust and a sweet sauce but Sugar Bears wins out by a nudge. We had pepperoni pizza, Chef Salad, garlic bread with cheese tonight and it was just as good as I remembered. Everyone has a different opinion especially when it comes to pizza. The employees I spoke with and dealt with were very friendly. We haven’t been here for several years now, they were having staffing issues several years back after Covid. Their for a long time their hours were so sporadic and when they were open you couldn’t get through. I felt like a kid again in the 80’s when you would try to call the radio station to win concert tickets. You know back when you had to camp out outside of Buzzards Nest for a week to get a few seats. Haha! I highly recommend if you like quality ingredients, thin and crispy crust with a sweet sauce you will be a fan too. Can’t wait to go back, see you soon Sugar Bears!
… moreAlie Holley
The pizza was okay, I’ve had better I’ve had worse. We were excited to try something new and local but was met with attitude on the phone and when walking in to pick up our order the entire place was packed full of things everywhere just disorganized and run down and not clean which is not how i want to feel picking up something to eat.. 2 stars because it was affordable
… moreNick Huffman
Second time getting pizza from Sugar Bears and it was even better than the first..this pizza was slightly crispier and I’m a fan of that. The pizza is thin crust and cut patty style for anyone interested. The garlic bread and sauce is also really good, the sauce reminds me of Pizza Hut from back in the day. I’ve had the same cashier both times and she has always been really friendly. Definitely going to be going here more in the future.
… moreDawn Bininger (Dawnie72)
It’s been years since I’ve been here. My schedule never seemed to align to their hours. Finally got to pick up today. Every bit as good as I remembered. Excellent friendly service. Piping hot pizza! And SUPER affordable.
… moreA M
LOVE this pizza! My favorite things are the sauce, pepperoni, and the onions! Only down side is there was no delivery. Other than that, Sugar Bears is one of my top 3 pizza places in Lancaster!
… moreLynette Feliciano-Justice
First time there. Always heard good things about it. It wasn’t anything I’d go out of my way to get again. The lasagna was drowning in sauce. Not much in the way of meat, noodles, or ricotta. However, the pizza was good.
… moreStacey Bentley
We found this place when we were looking for some good pizza and another local spot had over an hour wait. We had the meatzza pizza and garlic bread with cheese and sauce. Truly one of the top 3 pizzas I have ever had! The pizza had a ton of toppings and came out super hot and fresh. 10/10 recommend!!
… moreAndrea Robinson
One of the best pizza places in town! Always consistent taste! We’re late eaters do to sports & dance so they’re often closed in the evening when we are craving pizza. I do always try to order during the day when I have a day off of work though! Yum!
… moreJeremy Jones
Sugar Bears is by far the best pizza I have ever had the pleasure of eating. I recommend it to everyone I know.
… moreKeith Brown
Great pizza. Best in Lancaster by far. Pretty much every single person is kind and friendly in there, but there is one lady that is extremely rude, on the phone and when you pick up. Everything is done with an attitude. She clearly hates working there and i think sugar bears should find someone to replace her.
… more