Social Profile: 
![]()
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Your local Hayward Subway® Restaurant at 10453 Hwy 27 brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6 sandwiches, wraps, and salads, ordered quickly in the app or online, through convenient delivery, in-restaurant dining, or curbside pickup. We’re proud to offer a fresh alternative to typical fast food with fresh-cut veggies, tasty proteins, fresh-baked bread, and delicious cookies. We’re also here for your catering needs. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ talented Sandwich Artists™.
Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
SUBWAY at 10453 Hwy 27 Hayward WI – Subway Locations
Your local Hayward Subway® Restaurant at 10453 Hwy 27 brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6″ …
Subway Locations in Hayward, WI| Subs, Sandwiches, Salads
10453 Hwy 27We’re Open – Closes at 12:00 AM. 10453 Hwy 27. Hayward , WI 54843. US · 13855 W. County Hwy BWe’re Open – Closes at 10:00 PM. 13855 W. County Hwy B.
Subway, 10453 State Road 27, Hayward, WI 54843, US – MapQuest
Your local Hayward Subway® Restaurant, located at 10453 Hwy 27 brings new bold flavors along with old favorites to satisfied guests every day.
Reviews
Doug Ahmann
Rolled in at 11:00 PM on a Saturday night. A gentleman named Chuck did a great job. Clearly cared about what he was doing, and happy to accommodate my requests. He sorted through the bread and found me a fresh loaf. Chuck is a credit to the organization. The world needs more Chucks.
… moreMariah Meyer
When I got there, the guy started to help me with my order. The younger lady was more worried about her and her boyfriend’s plans at 8pm (the guy that was helping me). She took his phone out of his pocket and was talking with her boyfriend about what she needed to text someone and was communicating with the other lady about if she could work late so they could leave since they had plans. And was keeping him side tracked instead of seeing if I had anything else to order after the sandwich, I had to say something. I asked for a wrap and the other lady that was there grabbed the flatbread and I asked if that’s what they really use for wraps and she said yes they just roll it? But didn’t make sense since the show actual wraps on the board and I have gotten wraps before. After I paid, I noticed the price of the honey mustard wrap was $11.39 on the board (if I’m remember right, I know it’s almost a dollar difference) and they charged me $12.29 for the roll up flatbread( they called it a wrap).
… moreJonathan Bonney
Don’t EVER order online from this restaurant. I swear to God 9 out of 10 times your order will be wrong. Missing items. Missing ingredients. Pay for extra but don’t get it. Ask for toasted, not toasted. It’s an absolute joke!
… moreJayden Sapik
Whatever you do. DO NOT use the mobile app. They will mess something up 100% of the time. This is the 3rd time in a row that they messed something up. The order strictly says Italian and this is the asiago bread, and they forgot the provolone on the sub only put the parmesan cheese on. Not only that but did somebody eat my veggies on the flatbread? It’s the smallest amount ever. Never ever have been reimbursed for their mistakes and will never ever make a mobile order again.
… moreDrew Bialecki
Came in with my family and Grandparents. It was small but a nice location. It was shaped like Log cabin. And my mom enjoyed her Happy Gilmore 2 cup.
… morebill shumway
Advertised open at 7, but arrived at 8 only to told they were going to pen on a Saturday
Bread was day old.
… moreBread was day old.
Kate Metheny
I was that person that showed up 10 minutes to closed. I apologized because we had just got in to town and were starving. I kept our order simple because I’m not a dbag. I tipped well. Food was great.
… moreBryan Gary
Horrible experience. Worst Subway in Northern Wisconsin! Ordered on app. Said food was ready. It was not. The workers had the printout on counter. Pickup was 5:40. Did not receive burnt subs until 6:15. Avoid this Subway!!!
… moreNathan Gall
****Updated from one star to 4****
Owner contacted me right away and made things right. The delivery system is still goofy, and I recommend not using it until Door Dash becomes more reliable in Hayward.
ORIGINAL REVIEW:
Do not order delivery! It won’t show up and they won’t refund you unless you want to jump through hoops and come into the store when a manager is working. Should be able to handle a simple refund right away over the phone. Very disappointed in the managers passing the blame.
… moreOwner contacted me right away and made things right. The delivery system is still goofy, and I recommend not using it until Door Dash becomes more reliable in Hayward.
ORIGINAL REVIEW:
Do not order delivery! It won’t show up and they won’t refund you unless you want to jump through hoops and come into the store when a manager is working. Should be able to handle a simple refund right away over the phone. Very disappointed in the managers passing the blame.
Wesley Wolf
I ordered twice through the app.
The first time, the app told me that my order was ready. When I arrived; the two workers were sitting down while my order ticket was sitting by the counter; where they started the orders so THEY DID receive it. They apologized though. But .. common… they received it, pulled the ticket and just didn’t start it.
The second time they called me that they didn’t have any meatballs (that’s fine), gave me a second option, but didn’t put what I had requested on the sandwich. They both seemed really high on both occasions.
Not worth it.
… moreThe first time, the app told me that my order was ready. When I arrived; the two workers were sitting down while my order ticket was sitting by the counter; where they started the orders so THEY DID receive it. They apologized though. But .. common… they received it, pulled the ticket and just didn’t start it.
The second time they called me that they didn’t have any meatballs (that’s fine), gave me a second option, but didn’t put what I had requested on the sandwich. They both seemed really high on both occasions.
Not worth it.