Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 228 Lincoln Way E, New Oxford, PA 17350
Phone: (717) 624-3221
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sub Stop | New Oxford PA – Facebook
Sub Stop, New Oxford. 2836 likes · 243 talking about this · 561 were here. Family Owed for more than 50+ years. Subs Pizza Salads and much more.
New Menu, Same Great Taste! We’ve updated our menu … – Facebook
I will support the Sub Stop until I can no longer chew food. It’s always fun going in there and I love all the people there. 28w · 4 likes.
Sub Stop, 228 Lincoln Way E, New Oxford, PA 17350, US – MapQuest
Sub Stop in New Oxford, PA, is not your average pizza joint. Nestled in the heart of this charming town, this eatery is a hidden gem waiting to be …
Reviews
Robert Ebersole
What can I say? Am I living in the past and expecting too much?
After seeing videos of local spots showcasing their subs, I was craving a good sub. I was never at Sub Stop. I figured with a name like that, they must be great.
I walked in to see the giant metal stop sign. Was greeted by the staff. I had high hopes. So far, so good. Charming place. Prices seemed good. $8 for a sub.
Then I get it. It was so much smaller than I expected. The bread was the softer type. It’s probably from an eight pack of Walmart rolls. The turkey? Eh. I was expecting deli flat thick. This also seemed like Walmart variety. Looking at the shape of the cheese, it looked like kraft singles. I think there might have been only one slice at that.
I guess I expected too much. I expected better than subway. This wasn’t better than the prepackaged convince store. Myers meat market has waaaay better subs already pre made. I get them all the time.
My son got a cheese steak and said it was more onions than steak. Also disappointed.
Large sign read that refills are .75 due to rising cost. I guess that’s what happened to the subs. Rising costs.
The staff was excellent. Saddens me to leave a bad, honest review. And if you look at my reviews, I am rarely disappointed.
… moreAfter seeing videos of local spots showcasing their subs, I was craving a good sub. I was never at Sub Stop. I figured with a name like that, they must be great.
I walked in to see the giant metal stop sign. Was greeted by the staff. I had high hopes. So far, so good. Charming place. Prices seemed good. $8 for a sub.
Then I get it. It was so much smaller than I expected. The bread was the softer type. It’s probably from an eight pack of Walmart rolls. The turkey? Eh. I was expecting deli flat thick. This also seemed like Walmart variety. Looking at the shape of the cheese, it looked like kraft singles. I think there might have been only one slice at that.
I guess I expected too much. I expected better than subway. This wasn’t better than the prepackaged convince store. Myers meat market has waaaay better subs already pre made. I get them all the time.
My son got a cheese steak and said it was more onions than steak. Also disappointed.
Large sign read that refills are .75 due to rising cost. I guess that’s what happened to the subs. Rising costs.
The staff was excellent. Saddens me to leave a bad, honest review. And if you look at my reviews, I am rarely disappointed.
Stan Wickline
The food is great! We have had their Cheeseburger subs and there Fish subs. Very delicious along with fries which are also very good! Always very friendly!
… moreCarissa Cole
I have been going to Sub Stop since I was in high school (over 25 years ago lol) they’ve always been amazing! Great food. Great staff. Great atmosphere. If you want a “hometown spot”, this is it! I was there the other day and was taken back to my high school days when I saw that they still take good care of the Colonials football team! It was awesome! I will ALWAYS be a patron to Sub Stop!! Love you guys!! Oh, and if you have little ones, I highly recommend the hot dog! My 2 year old granddaughter LOVES to come here for hot dogs!
… moreChris Krichten
Always love to come here. The ladies are the greatest and treat us like family. This is our daughter Sophia’s favorite place to go.
… moreMark Morrow
Super fresh and the “softest melt in your mouth” sub roll ever !!! Fantastic sandwich and wonderful polite ladies running the operation !
… moreZach Kelly
What a hidden gem! Family owned business with attention to high quality, locally produced ingredients. I had the walking tacos, and was blown away by the quality and flavor! Beef was from a local bucher, and the seasoning made my taste buds dance. This is a must-go place!
… moreGwendal Mazuay
I broke down next to Sub-stop, but what I found wasn’t just a bite to eat. It was warmth, kindness, and one of the best subs I’ve ever had. They didn’t just serve food; they offered help, a smile, and a space that felt like a hug. Unexpected moments make the best memories. I’ll be back! Not just for the sub, but for the soul of this place
… moreNortheast Regional Commander Emergency Towing
Very Amazing people here. The ladies greeted me as soon as I came in. Treated like they were my second mom. Food was tasty! I had been working the area and was exhausted, and this definitely helped! I got blessed by the one worker with an oversized milkshake, and this shake was amazing!
Would definitely recommend!
… moreWould definitely recommend!
Mark B
We stopped for a quick lunch. We found a staff that made us feel like we were at home. The Pizza Burger Sub was awesome. I also enjoyed the peanut butter shake.
… more