Social Profile: 
✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Stuff by SJ creates hand-made, unique custom cakes, cupcakes, chocolate treats, gifts baskets, and more that taste as good as they look. Everything is baked from scratch & made using the highest quality ingredients. We also offer a high level experience to include a creative consultation, custom packaging, free delivery, and more. Additional services at the SJ bake shop will include DIY party hosting & retail sales Stuff by SJ serves all of Essex County & Northern NJ and is located on Bloomfield Ave in Montclair. We strive to connect with the community providing homemade, artisan baked goods specifically designed for each client.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 342 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042
Phone: (973) 771-6907
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Custom Cakes for Special Occasions | Stuff by SJ
✨ Handcrafted Custom Cakes & Sweet Celebrations … Made from scratch in our Montclair, NJ bakery — custom cakes, dessert tables, chocolate treats, and more for …
Stuff by SJ (@stuffbysj) · Montclair, NJ – Instagram
Custom cakes, sweets & treats made with love in Montclair, NJ. Pre-orders, camps & classes. ✨ #StuffBySJ #supportsmallbusiness #supportlocal
Stuff By SJ | Montclair NJ – Facebook
Built this one brick by brick From the custom LEGO-inspired cake to the cupcakes, cakesicles, chocolate-dipped pretzels, and full dessert table setup… every …
Reviews
Yuliya Gungor
Drew and SJ Bakery truly stands out for its phenomenal service, quality taste, and stunning presentation. I recently had the pleasure of using their services for my husband’s birthday cake and our wedding ceremony, and I couldn’t have been more impressed. The team was incredibly prompt in responding to my inquiries and worked closely with me to create a cake that perfectly matched our vision. The flavors were divine, and the presentation was nothing short of exquisite, making our special moments even more memorable.
I highly recommend Drew and SJ Bakery to anyone looking for a reliable and talented bakery. Their ability to create anything you can imagine is truly remarkable, and their dedication to customer satisfaction is evident in every aspect of their work. Whether it’s a birthday, wedding, or any other celebration, I will definitely be using their services again in the future. If you’re seeking a bakery that excels in both taste and aesthetics, look no further than Drew and SJ Bakery!
… moreI highly recommend Drew and SJ Bakery to anyone looking for a reliable and talented bakery. Their ability to create anything you can imagine is truly remarkable, and their dedication to customer satisfaction is evident in every aspect of their work. Whether it’s a birthday, wedding, or any other celebration, I will definitely be using their services again in the future. If you’re seeking a bakery that excels in both taste and aesthetics, look no further than Drew and SJ Bakery!
Crystal Weaver
Could not be any more sick to my stomach over the results of my cupcake order from this bakery and the insane amount of money I spent on them. I was very clear with them what I wanted, cupcakes with realistic looking flowers, for my daughter’s 21st birthday. I provided photos as examples, and was told they could absolutely do them. They did not even come close. I’m 14 hours away so this was incredibly important to me, and when my daughter picked them up and showed me I was so upset with the quality that it was obvious and completely ruined what I had been looking forward to for weeks. She took the cupcakes because her party was in half an hour and had no idea what else to do, but said they ended up throwing them out because the frosting tasted like eating butter and the cake was bleh. I called to tell them how disappointed I was and was treated so nastily that I want everyone to be sure they do not trust their dream vision with this place. Days later and still makes me cry to see what they provided compared to the photos I supplied. They made an effort but did not have the skill to come anywhere close to “realistic”. First photo is what I got, other photos are what I asked for.
… moreSable alvarez
literally amazing the cake not only was beautiful but tastes amazing we got vanilla with vanilla custard and it was the best freshest cake ever! it was super cheap to i ordered about 2 weeks in advance and they let me put a deposit and pay the rest when i could amazing service and an amazing cake! would definitely recommend
… moreKayla Lauricella
I placed an order relatively last minute for a 10th birthday and it came out EXACTLY like I imagined. They are sooo talented and were so accommodating with the short turnaround time (never made me feel like a burden or like I was making a crazy request). The pricing was fair. I would absolutely order with them again!!
… moreDana Carrasco
Ordered a $200 custom cake through Instragram for my daughter’s 2nd birthday party. I messaged the company and I believe SJ took the order. She was highly recommended from an acquaintence. The theme was “2 sweet” I had sent her 2 photos for inspiration for an idea of what I wanted. I felt like I was an easy customer. I picked up the cake and at first look, I liked it. I left it out in the shade, it was an outside party. When I looked at the cake, my daughter’s name looked like it was slapped on by a child and the top fondant swirl on top was uneven. No big deal… When I finally cut into the cake, it was very hard and seemed very dry right away. Not a typical moist cake. I honestly had no desire to even taste it and felt bad distributing it out. I had asked a few people how they liked it and they even said it was dry but the icing and everything else was good. I think they tried to be nice.
I messaged SJ telling her I was not happy with it and even my guests felt the same. She was speechless and her feelings were hurt that I didn’t like the cake. When she asked what she can do, I told her I wanted 50% off. Since most of it went in the garbage too.
She eventually became very defensive and blamed me and saying something about the butter and how it didn’t melt in the shade or how I should’ve left it out longer..? Which I never heard of and also saying she uses fresh ingredients and all her cakes are fresh and she puts in a lot of time into each of her cakes. I do believe her so I don’t understand why I felt my cake was so hard and dry. Her husband even messaged me too. I even showed her screen shots of what my guests said and how they agreed that the cake was very dry. She didn’t like that I sent her what my guests said.
Eventually I got my $100, this was 2 years ago so I will never order from here again.
… moreI messaged SJ telling her I was not happy with it and even my guests felt the same. She was speechless and her feelings were hurt that I didn’t like the cake. When she asked what she can do, I told her I wanted 50% off. Since most of it went in the garbage too.
She eventually became very defensive and blamed me and saying something about the butter and how it didn’t melt in the shade or how I should’ve left it out longer..? Which I never heard of and also saying she uses fresh ingredients and all her cakes are fresh and she puts in a lot of time into each of her cakes. I do believe her so I don’t understand why I felt my cake was so hard and dry. Her husband even messaged me too. I even showed her screen shots of what my guests said and how they agreed that the cake was very dry. She didn’t like that I sent her what my guests said.
Eventually I got my $100, this was 2 years ago so I will never order from here again.
Kara Shepard
Incredible cake and cupcakes for our two year old’s birthday! Service and communication outstanding, and they delivered something even better than we could have imagined. Rave reviews from party guests!
… moreTera Tarulli
I have been going to Stuff by SJ for the past four years and they are the absolute best place in the area for custom cakes and baked goods! I have ordered so many specialty themed cakes for my kids’ birthdays and special events over the years and they always turn out better than I hoped. Their cakes are also delicious (my crew is particular about their cakes so this is a big deal) and Drew couldn’t be more accommodating or easy to work with. Highly, highly recommend for whatever event you have coming up!
… moreMegan Lane
We got a gorgeous and delicious cake for Christmas from Stuff by SJ. It was the center of our dessert table. It was chocolate cake with cookies and creme filling.
… moreMeg Eremita
I had a great experience with “Stuff by SJ” ordering a custom cake for my client’s moving away party. I spoke with Drew on a Saturday for a following Wednesday AM pickup – so the turnaround time was very fast. Drew was quick, detail oriented, and walked me through some helpful recommendations. The cake itself was incredible. Everything was fresh and delicious and not overly sweet. It was also perfectly designed to mimic the inspo pic I shared. Definitely recommend SJ & Drew for your custom cake needs!
… moreDanielle Vranek
Literally the most delicious and the cutest cakes ever!! I ordered a Mario Kart sheet cake and smash cake and everyone raved about them. 10/10 customer service as well! I cannot recommend enough!
… more