Amber Bates
My first time here, service was incredibly friendly, atmosphere was warming and the pizza we ordered was amazing. The presentation was spot on. Their pepperoni, hot honey and basil pizza was absolutely delicious. We added banana peppers but it didn’t need it. Highly recommend this place, will definitely be back.
… moreRon Rice
We found this spot after the ND vs Syracuse game. The pizza and the warm, friendly service from the owner and the staff were unparalleled! We can’t recommend Starlite enough and look forward to making it part of our annual Notre Dame football ☘️ ☘️ ☘️ trips!
… moreDaneile Frydrych
Just got carry out for the first time in a while and it Didn’t disappoint!!! The crust was so crispy and the onions were so sweet !!! The sausage pizza didn’t disappoint either !! They were completely slammed and it still didn’t take long to get our order.. The prices are amazing as well. Keep it up Starlite!!!
… moreDawson Bane
I’m helping the owner out with his roof at home, and he said I should check out his pizza shop. It was great service, very friendly, and fantastic food. If you want great pizza, appetizers, and desserts. I highly recommend giving this place a try.
Gold medal Roofing approves and I will be back.
… moreBritnee Colleen (BeeSquared)
Easily one of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had. Super sweet sauce, the toppings all slid off the crust. Didn’t get the right sides or the sauces I ordered. The wings were pretty mid. On the other hand, the meat on the French dip was so good and the au jus was pretty good; I’d eat a whole bowl of just that.
… moreAna Rivera
Worst pizza ever the crust was so thin it was like eating a cracker the sauce was horrible it taste like rotten tomatoes the cheese on the pizza tasted like rubber it did not even have enough cheese on the pizza it look like a cracker and sauce it taste horrible. 1 st and last time eating at this place!!
… moreChris Perez
We had Pizza, bread, and their fried cheesecake. Everything was great. Especially the double pepperoni hot honey pizza!
… moreCookie Valentine
The pizza was amazing as always. The service was ok, we did get there right after opening but overall I like the place, the recipe for the sauce is the same it was when I was a kid and I still love it.
… moremann jaye
Food is good. The meatball sub is one of the better I’ve tried in Michiana. Ask for the spaghetti sauce on your pizza and subs. It’s homemade. bon appétit
… moreMichael
Sad to say that after more than 40 years of enjoying Starlite. The last 3 times the sauce was not the same. It tasted like any other sauce around town. And that is very disappointing. Had been our go to restaurant since the kids were little. Hopefully things change back. The 1st bite always flooded me with memories. Not so the last 3 times. And 5 different family members said it didn’t taste like Starlite sauce.
… more