Eva Jay
First time ordering take out from here! We were at the fireworks last week & someone let me have left over pizza, so I had to come back. The pizza is light & airy with good flavor. We ordered a margarita, pepperoni, & a salad. The salad was fresh with delicious veggies. We very much enjoyed it all and plan to return to eat at the restaurant. Customer service was great as well.
July 31st – we returned to eat here and it was a good experience. They were giving out fried spaghetti, it was strangely good!
… moreJordan Cooper
Fantastic. Both the normal pie and the Detroit style were both great in different ways. Wonderful people who work here too, and the only high quality pizza place in the area open past 8pm on a Monday (another place turned us away.) Reasonably priced too. Offered me a free dessert for my birthday! Made it very special. Will definitely go here again! And again and again…
… moreMarkeitta
Personally would not recommend. I looked at others photos in this review section and none of theirs is nearly as burnt as the two pies we received this evening. The pizza was so burnt and not appetizing. The chicken still has feathers and I could not taste any “hot honey”. Nothing special I may give this place one more shot but for $100 idk. We ordered two large pies , Motts sticks, & wings. I’ve had better pizza.
… moreRogerio Esteves
Food was alright. Got a Detroit pizza and a buffalo chicken pizza. The Detroit pizza was very small for $27 and the buffalo chicken pizza always super thin and dry. Also tasted a bit odd. This was a one and done for me. We also got 2 orders of chicken tenders and the total bill was $87. Ridiculous!
… moreJessica Culver
Well I ordered a small $13. With sausage $5. And caramelized onions $3 and I’m sorry definitely not worth it couldn’t even put the right amount of cheese let alone 5$ worth of sausage and $3 worth of onions
… moreAlfio Russotto
Do not place an delivery order with them. I received my pizza very cold like the delivery driver drove with the pizza on top of the roof. Got a small size pizza, on the menu it says 12 inches 6 slices for a small. Robbery. Do not recommend at all. Pizza wasn’t good either.
… moreFood of CT
It’s so nice to have a new Square Peg location that’s even closer to us now! The restaurant is beautiful inside and it was the same menu we’re familiar with from their other locations. They had some awesome specials for the month of May, and one of our favorite parts of the meal was the chicken bacon cacciatore pizza. I also really appreciated that they were able to make me a mocktail version of one of their drinks. We were in and out in just a little over an hour!
… moreTiffany’s Good Eats
Finally tried Square Peg’s new Shelton location and it did not disappoint!
We ordered a little bit of everything and were impressed across the board. The Red, White & Green pizza was so fresh — creamy burrata, arugula, cherry tomatoes made it light but flavorful. The Smashed Potato Pie was a standout — I swapped the sausage for bacon and highly recommend doing the same.
We also tried their garlic parm wings (perfectly crispy), meatballs, pasta alla vodka, and the chicken parm sandwich, which came with a side salad.
They’ve got a full bar with cocktails and beer, and the cookie gelato sandwiches for dessert were incredible.
Service was great, the space was clean and welcoming. Definitely coming back!
… moreEd Randall
The side salad was cute….built well. The small was almost as big as the large. Chris was our server. He kept asking me questions but i was just hanging out. I wasnt really planning on eating ya know. I ended up getting oil on my marriage contract. Chris said i was free to leave. Would recommend to my buddies
… moreMarisol Ortega
Pizza is wood fired pizza and delicious! Wings were also perfectly crispy and sauce was flavorful. Highly recommend, I had never been before to a Square Peg Pizzeria but will definitely be returning.
… more