Social Profile: 
![]()
… View more
A family-owned ice cream shop and café featuring homemade ice cream, homemade focaccia, fresh-baked bread, and house-made dressings! South Street Creamery is home to Morristown’s oldest ice cream shop and the family behind the vibrant Red Sea Café, offering authentic Eritrean cuisine!
Relaxed parlor dishing ice cream & gelato, plus a cafe menu of crepes, sandwiches & panini.
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–6:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 1–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 146 South St, Morristown, NJ 07960
Phone: (973) 267-8887
Website: https://www.southstreetcreamery.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
southstreetcreamery.hrpos.heartland.us
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Red Sea Café & South Street Creamery – Order Online
Red Sea Café & South Street Creamery. 146 South St, Morristown NJ 07960-4139, United StatesOnline ordering hours: 11:00 AM – 6:40 PM.
South Street Creamery & Red Sea Café (@southstreetcreamerycafe)
Homemade ice cream, baked goods and so much more. Proud owners of @redseacafenj, also offering Eritrean & Ethiopian cuisine all day, every day!
South Street Creamery & Cafe | Morristown NJ – Facebook
Have you tried our brand new MANGO SORBET ? It’s sweet, refreshing, and PERFECT for a hot day like today! We’re open until 10:00 tonight, so don’t hesitate to …
Reviews
Jonathan Lotz
The ice cream was excellent. You should go and try the food also.
Very comfortable atmosphere, you will enjoy your experience.
… moreVery comfortable atmosphere, you will enjoy your experience.
Rachel Masilamani
I love the surprising combination of Eritrean food and classic American treats! When you love Ethiopian/Eritrean food, but you have a picky kid, there is no better spot to dine. My son was happy with his mac & cheese and ready to finish every last bite so he could have some ice cream.
Whenever I spot goat on a menu, I am there! I didn’t need any coaxing to pretty much lick the plate clean. The owner was so kind and gave me extra injera – though my mom can confirm that I had already eaten more than my fair share. This was a perfectly prepared East African meal. I felt like I was being welcomed to a home table. The injera was made only with teff – which means it is gluten free and super nutritious.
Unexpected combinations of food are what makes life worth living. If you have a chance to eat here, do it!
… moreWhenever I spot goat on a menu, I am there! I didn’t need any coaxing to pretty much lick the plate clean. The owner was so kind and gave me extra injera – though my mom can confirm that I had already eaten more than my fair share. This was a perfectly prepared East African meal. I felt like I was being welcomed to a home table. The injera was made only with teff – which means it is gluten free and super nutritious.
Unexpected combinations of food are what makes life worth living. If you have a chance to eat here, do it!
Dina
Went hiking near by and our tradition is to try a new ice cream shop after hiking a new trail so we stopped in here because I read that the ice cream was homemade. Sunday afternoon and they were jammin, we waited about 20 minutes to be served, they could up the employee count during peak hours. Our server was cheerful and professional, she mistakenly gave my son a waffle cone instead of a wafer cone, him being profoundly autistic immediately was irritable, she quickly redid his cone and all was right in his world. The ice cream was delicious, service perfection, and the vibe is super cute.
… moreMarino Hernandez
Delicious vanilla ice cream.
Loved hearing that they make their ice cream homemade in their kitchen.
I’m seeking and reviewing the best local businesses for Localverse (from Bethlehem, PA). Now adding South Street Creamery to the list!
You may freely reuse all photos and text in reviews contributed by Localverse, and make them better. License: CC-BY
… moreLoved hearing that they make their ice cream homemade in their kitchen.
I’m seeking and reviewing the best local businesses for Localverse (from Bethlehem, PA). Now adding South Street Creamery to the list!
You may freely reuse all photos and text in reviews contributed by Localverse, and make them better. License: CC-BY
Cathy M
Red Sea Cafe! Pop up restaurant in the south street creamery, there’s no sign for the cafe outside so look for the creamery. The food is incredible, just the right amount of spice level in the dishes and sooooo flavorful. Highly recommend to anyone that loves Eritrean food or that would like trying it. Staff was so friendly and helpful answering any questions.
… moreFiredrake Nemmy
We tried the recent Ethiopian dinner menu they are offering and it was all wonderfully delicious and authentic.
You have to call a reservation for it because it literally is just one friendly lady making it as a passion project but it’s just like the places we remember in the city, grabbing that flavorful food in pieces of the injera pancake, absolutely should give it a try.
… moreYou have to call a reservation for it because it literally is just one friendly lady making it as a passion project but it’s just like the places we remember in the city, grabbing that flavorful food in pieces of the injera pancake, absolutely should give it a try.
Kyle Fierravanti
South Street Creamery has EXCELLENT employees and AWESOME ice cream! They offer an array of different flavors; many are unique! I had 3 scoops. One was made with Kahlua and one with Bailey’s
The Creamery is also connected to a restaurant called Red Sea that serves Eritrean/Ethiopian cuisine. I, as a foodie and long time restaurant worker, was intrigued to view their menu and learn about this type of cuisine. I love seeing different restaurant ideas! To me it shows a huge sense of creativity and innovation.
Support South Street Creamery and Local Morristown businesses!!!
10/10
… moreThe Creamery is also connected to a restaurant called Red Sea that serves Eritrean/Ethiopian cuisine. I, as a foodie and long time restaurant worker, was intrigued to view their menu and learn about this type of cuisine. I love seeing different restaurant ideas! To me it shows a huge sense of creativity and innovation.
Support South Street Creamery and Local Morristown businesses!!!
10/10
Michele Cheng
This Eritrean dinner was delicious!! This is the sharing platter with lentils and chicken and each bite was so flavorful and a must try!! It’s a hidden gem that you need to bring your family and friends to. The owner was so nice and I highly recommend this place to anyone who loves a good hearty meal.
… moreA Yun
I had the most amazing meal at Red Sea Cafe a couple weeks back, and am still thinking about it! My friend and I did the Traditional Sharing Plate and were blown away by the quality of the ingredients, balance of flavors and textures, and heart and thought put into creating our meal.
We met Amleset, who shared how happy it makes her to serve Eritrean food that she would be proud to share with her family, friends, and the community in Morristown.
She’s definitely earned a new customer in me! Thank you for an amazing meal and sharing your passion for this amazing food, Amleset.
** the Teff is gluten free, has a great texture and tang, and is so fun to eat! I loved the experience of eating my plate
… moreWe met Amleset, who shared how happy it makes her to serve Eritrean food that she would be proud to share with her family, friends, and the community in Morristown.
She’s definitely earned a new customer in me! Thank you for an amazing meal and sharing your passion for this amazing food, Amleset.
** the Teff is gluten free, has a great texture and tang, and is so fun to eat! I loved the experience of eating my plate
Lina Balaska
The food is amazing! I never new about this cuisine and I’m glad I found about it! The staff is really friendly and you can tell how excited they are for everyone to try this new dinner menu! We will be going back again!
… more