Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1583 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509
Phone: (845) 278-9632
Website: http://www.sinapispizzeria.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home – Sinapis Pizzeria | Pizza Delivery Brewster NY | Italian …
THE BEST ITALIAN RESTAURANT IN BREWSTER. Serving the areas best Italian cuisine, pizza, pasta & more! Sinapi’s is committed to providing a warm and friendly …
Sinapi’s Pizzeria & Restaurant | Brewster NY – Facebook
Due to impending storm Sinapis will be closing early today. We are working with a limited menu. Sorry but we have no garlic knots today.
Sinapi’s Pizzeria – 1583 Route 22, Brewster, NY 10509 – Slice
Sinapi’s Stuffed Pizzas · Meat & Vegetable Pizza. Two large layers of dough stuffed with meatballs, fresh peppers, sausages, ham, spinach, mozzarella & tomato …
Reviews
Robert M Ferrieri III
I had the buffalo chicken slice. It was fantastic. Reasonably priced, conveniently located right off of Main Road
… moreJoanne Acocella
I’ve been coming here for years, and they never disappoint. The quality is consistent, as are the friendly faces. The high quality and friendly service keep me coming back.
So delicious even for takeout. The flavors remained vibrant, and everything tasted fresh. I am so happy now I don’t need to worry when I need to cater food for large parties this is the place to go!!! Everyone loves how tasty it is!!! Thank you so very much!!!
… moreSo delicious even for takeout. The flavors remained vibrant, and everything tasted fresh. I am so happy now I don’t need to worry when I need to cater food for large parties this is the place to go!!! Everyone loves how tasty it is!!! Thank you so very much!!!
Mike Marz55
We like to come here and enjoy some of the fine dishes they have. Fettuccine Alfredo, chicken marsala, meatball Parmigiana, to name a few. We live close by, so it’s always nice to have a great pizzeria and restaurant to go to and enjoy great slices and entrées, while watching sports on the tv and having some wine as well. The staff is very friendly and the service is as well. There is plenty of seating inside. While a lot of reviews here complain about the prices, it’s well worth it. Things are not cheap these days, especially during inflation, and they have a business to run and employees to pay. We will gladly pay for the delicious food they serve. We are repeat customers here and come often. Slices are big and will fill you up. The meatballs are delicious as well, on a hero or as an entrée.
… moreCynthia M
Good NY style pizza. Huge slices and Sharon (owner) is delightful. Great portions.
… moreClegg Furgenson
First time by, popped in for a slice. Completely empty house, one older lady behind the counter, head down on her cellphone. It’s about 15 paces from the door to the counter, i walk to the counter, sus out the slices, and stand patiently as this woman’s attention has not shifted from her phone once since I walked in, no greeting, no i’ll be with you in a minute, NOTHING. I stood there waiting for her attention, and after she ignored me for however long, i turned and walked out. I made it all the way to the door, actually had my hand on the bar to push before she said a word. I don’t often leave reviews but this woman was so rude and condescending that i felt there was no other choice. Physically chased me out into the parking lot to tell me I was wrong and that treating customers as if they are invisible is completely normal and NOT rude. NEEDLESS to say, i’ll never go back. They might treat the townies well, but if you are not a local yokel and they don’t know your name. Don’t expect to be welcomed.
… moreGlenn B_ _ _ _
Pizza here is always on point ! Been a regular for many many years while I use to live in the area. Have now been living in Florida for the past 10 years, however whenever I come back to NY to visit family I always make it a point to stop here for my NY pizza fix … and I’m always glad that I did. I’m now back in FL and already looking forward to coming back for my pizza. UPDATE : of course I’m back in town and stopped here 11/8/23 … ahhhhh just my go to pizza shop. I miss this so much, just can’t get that good NY pizza down in Florida.
… moreLizette Fonseca
Beware! Just picked up an order from here and witnessed the pizza guy lifting the pizza and blowing underneath it while seeing spit come out his mouth all over the pizza while placing it in the oven! Disgusting
… moreMelissa Gibilaro
Stopped in for a late lunch while driving back to the city from the Albany area. Ordered their Old Country special pie. Cooked well done to order. (Glad we ordered “well done” because the moisture from the fresh tomatoes and mushrooms could have made the crust a little soggy at the center).
Sauce, cheese, crust – everything was great!
Glad we made the stop!
… moreSauce, cheese, crust – everything was great!
Glad we made the stop!
John Blanar
Sicallin pizza and BBQ wings are both amazing. I live 45 minutes away and will drive back without hesitation.
… moreJoe Mama
Very fine restaurant. Heard good things about it for years from slews of others. I pass it during work. I made a special trip after work to visit and was richly rewarded. You will be too. I gave a 25% tip because they deserved it. I will be a regular.
… more