Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sidney Joe’s Pizzeria – Facebook
Sidney Joe’s Pizzeria. 1454 likes · 166 talking about this. Pizza place.
Sidney Joe’s Pizzeria – Great Western Catskills
Sidney Joe’s Pizzeria · 59 Main St, Sidney NY 13838 USA · (607) 563-8368 · Website · What’s Around Here?
Sidney Joe’s Pizzeria – Facebook
Sidney Joe’s Pizzeria is your go-to pizza place in Sidney, NY, serving mouthwatering slices, pies, bold Sicilian-style pizzas, and fresh salads. Whether you’re …
Reviews
Bree Gelina
You’re craving a real Italian pizza then come to Joe’s because they do not disappoint. I had a very simple white sauce cheese pizza and topped with garlic absolutely to die for. Not to mention the people that work here are super nice. Can eat in there’s a dining room in the back sometimes there’s a waitress sometimes there’s not no big deal The pie is worth it all.
… moreKimberly Wright
To the 3 young man working up front at the counter today around 1:30 -1: 40 pm You 3 where doing a great job. Great communication,, working well with each other , calm. Great flow doing your guys thing. Wasn’t sure why someone else had to come in and upset your guys flow. . THANK YOU GENTLEMAN FOR LUNCH, enjoy your guys work atmosphere as we waited . Keep up the great work.
… moreTaylor Reed
I’m really disappointed. We spent $40 on a large and a small pizza, which we expected, asking for the pizza to be cooked well done. It was not even close to well done, the dough was rawer than raw. The pizza was extremely flimsy, and I had to cook the pizza so I wasn’t eating raw dough. If we’re going to spend $40, please cook the pizza all the way. I shouldn’t have to put it in the oven to finish cooking it.
… moreJessica Jewell
The pizza was decent but the service was above and beyond for the fact that they did not have any servers on staff.
… moreL. Fredella
Usually I go here if I want a quick, nicely priced. Been going here for years. However, please hire people who can take an order on a phone. I repeated “One small pepperoni and garlic pizza and a side of mozzarella sticks” four times before I had to hang up. He repeated the order wrong back four times. He sounded stoned. Don’t blame this on the phone- it was perfectly clear with no noise in the background. Is he messing up with orders so he doesn’t have to work? If you can’t take an order properly it’s virtually guaranteed that my order will be wrong when I pick it up.
… moreMarsha Kellesvig
Huge Calzone! Delicious, and exactly what I wanted. I have leftovers – more than enough for 2 meals.
… moreJustin Case
Buffalo ain’t got nothing on these wings. Meaty, cooked to perfection and smothered in their signature wing sauce. If you like wings, it’s definitely worth the trip.
… moreCindy Wood
The food is acceptable usually pretty good.
I just want to say that our deliveries have been tough.
But last night (Monday) we had a wonderful delivery driver she was very honest. I wish I knew her name so I could mention it. But again we appreciate it!
We hope she sees this..
… moreI just want to say that our deliveries have been tough.
But last night (Monday) we had a wonderful delivery driver she was very honest. I wish I knew her name so I could mention it. But again we appreciate it!
We hope she sees this..
Madison Banks
As a lifetime resident of Sidney, Joe’s Pizzeria (formerly Joe and Vinny’s) is THE place to go for pizza. There have always been many options in Sidney for pizza, but no one does New York style pizza like Joe’s. They also have delicious subs, salads, and hot dinners, and their wings are meaty, crispy, and the house-made sauce is so good.
The staff is friendly and helpful. If there is ever any issue with an order, it is promptly fixed. They go above and beyond for their customers. Five stars all around. This family owned restaurant has made a lifer out of me!
… moreThe staff is friendly and helpful. If there is ever any issue with an order, it is promptly fixed. They go above and beyond for their customers. Five stars all around. This family owned restaurant has made a lifer out of me!
Ariel
The first pizza was terribly made the cheese and pepperoni are everywhere. The second pizza was beautiful. So,I’ll meet you in the middle with this review.
… more