Linda Nguyen
This restaurant was an absolute lifesaver. After traveling for over 12 hours, we arrived in Fairbanks around 3 a.m., and they were one of the only places still open. Their online ordering system was a bit buggy and would not process my card, but I called instead, and the person who answered was very friendly and helpful.
The hot wings were baked and had a great kick to them. The baked chicken Alfredo was perfectly al dente, rich, cheesy, and creamy. The garlic bread was really buttery and crisp! We finished with tiramisu for a sweet treat, which was a great way to end the meal. Highly recommend if y’all don’t want to settle for McDonald’s when coming in so late.
… moreKim Lopez
Thoroughly enjoyed Sicily’s Pizza! Ordering online for pick up was easy- they also offer dine in and delivery options. We ordered a medium pepperoni- more than enough for two- the crust is a delicious fluffy crust (they do have a thin option), the sauce was sweet and tangy with plenty of cheese and pepperoni, we absolutely LOVED the garlic bread- so crispy and buttery! We also had the buffalo wings- they’re sauceless but with a little kick. Would most definitely try Sicily’s again!
… moreClayton & Cindy Putnam
August 31, 2023 – Sitting on a jet for 10 hours I hope provides Context !
Sometimes folks need the background facts to understand a review, so here goes. . .
My wife & I we’re exhausted from 3,500 miles in the air, from MAINE ! Unfortunately our last leg, the Captain announced air turbulence, so beverages & food service was curtailed.
Arriving in Fairbanks at 10:30 pm few places are open that serve food. Our hotel clerks recommended walking a few blocks to Sicily’s Pizza. By now it’s 11:30 pm, we’re starving !
Normally my reviews are lengthy, well researched, and have a lot of photos to back up my points about the food, service, decor, and dining atmosphere . . . Sorry folks!
It’s simple , we’re in Alaska , not New York City, or the “ North End” in Boston! It’s a small pizza establishment close to midnight, with 2 or 3 people doing the work. . . for the customers that call in, text in, or walk in !
Their pizza is freshly made, looking at the stacks of 5 lb bags of flour. The pizza is not a Neapolitan thin crust style, rather a 3/4 inch soft pretzel style, very different from the common styles of pizza in the lower 48 states. But we liked it! We were hungry!
We’re thankful for those who are working late at night, and serve pretty good food to those traveling great distances to your home! ❤️
Can’t wait to see more of Alaska these next 10 days! But your hospitality is greatly appreciated late at night upon arrival at your airport with an empty stomach! ( context)
… moreSean Marquand
Pizza tasted like the dough was made by a 5 year old in an easy bake oven. If you’re blacked out at 2am and can’t get food anywhere else, good luck scarfing this down at 5 am when they get the order out. Terribly MID. Pizza is 2/10. Calzone is literally disgusting. This place is really gross until you lower your standards when you are belligerently drunk early in the morning after railing lines and sending a 2/10 home once you got off. Don’t waste your money
… moreGrace Gilbert
I ordered food and never received it. I called and asked about it and they told me the driver went to the wrong location. I confirmed through my email verification that I had provided the correct address, and asked if I could have a refund as I never received anything- they told me no.
… moreKallie Reid
Really friendly employees! I’ve only had the pizza and wings. Wings aren’t bad, a little too much breading. Pizza tastes so similar to dominoes which I’m not a fan of.
… moreTrinity Yates
Ever since Sicily’s got new management they have just been fantastic in our experience, excellent quality, friendly staff and they take real pride in their product. We stopped coming here for the longest time due to an unfortunate hire but started coming back about a year ago, now we won’t go to anyone else on our cheat nights. Thank you Sicily’s for sparing me from cooking tonight and for a job VERY well done!
… moredavid purdom
After being awake and traveling for 27 hours, we ordered sicilys upon arrival. It was one of the few things that was still open and would deliver. We did wait 1.5 hours, but when we opened the box we knew it was worth the wait. The pizza looked perfect and tasted even better!
… moreMcKenna O’Keefe
Have ordered pizza from Sicily’s over 5 times. Always a stuffed crust pepperoni pizza for pickup. So good. Everyone is very polite. Quick service.
… moreOmar Baig
Visiting Alaska for the first time from Atlanta. Decor needs work but the pizza was fantastic! The sauce, the crust, the cheese, all was great quality. And on top of that the gyro and chicken is halal. Would totally come here next time. Ordered 5 xlarge for dine and was ready to eat in 20 minutes.
… more