Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5460 Franklin St, Hilliard, OH 43026
Website: http://www.sextonspizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sexton’s Pizza – The Best Pizza in Columbus
Experience the best pizza in Columbus, and see why Dave Portnoy of Barstool Sports score Sexton’s an 8.1 on OneBite. Well Done & Crispy!
Sexton’s Pizza – Hilliard 5460 Franklin St – Order Online
Sexton’s Pizza – Hilliard 5460 Franklin St. 5460 Franklin St, Hilliard, OH. Delivery. Pickup. Pickup from 5460 Franklin St, Hilliard, OH. ASAP•Pickup in 30 – 35 …
Barstool Pizza Review Throwback – Sexton’s Pizza (Hilliard, OH)
A throwback to Dave’s favorite pizza in Ohio. Download The One Bite App to see more and review your favorite pizza joints: …
Reviews
Vincent Lam
Sexton’s NY style pizza could be the best pizza in Columbus. I left at my first time visit because they said there was only one big size and I was not hungry.
I came here at my second time on game day. I was a little disappointed cuz there were no people inside. However, the margarita pizza impressed me. The thin crust was perfectly baked. The tomato sauce was adorable with decent mozzarella cheese.
The dining room was lovely with a great bar and game machines. The lake view at the patio was beautiful. Service was excellent and WiFi was fast. I hope they will make small size pizza.
… moreI came here at my second time on game day. I was a little disappointed cuz there were no people inside. However, the margarita pizza impressed me. The thin crust was perfectly baked. The tomato sauce was adorable with decent mozzarella cheese.
The dining room was lovely with a great bar and game machines. The lake view at the patio was beautiful. Service was excellent and WiFi was fast. I hope they will make small size pizza.
Van S. (MzV2uuz)
Ordered online the pizza is usually absolutely amazing but a few times they’ve dropped the ball You know when you send a pizza out burnt you’re wrong playing wrong No one wants to pay all that money for a burnt pizza. The top look amazing The pizza was actually good but we literally had to cut the bottom of the crust off because it made the experience so bitter I guess it’s back to ordering Domino’s
… moreJay Four
We stopped in a Friday afternoon, easy to get to, plenty of parking. We ordered the New York style with pepperoni and hot honey, this did not disappoint, very tasty!! Great crispy crust, nice undercarriage, and minimal flop. If you’re traveling with your four legged friend, they have a pet friendly patio to eat on.
… moreJohnny Burtnett
Flavors were great, I made the mistake of ordering with a garlic base, which I think meant the pizza came without sauce, but that’s my fault. Otherwise it was good, not amazing, but definitely will try again (WITH sauce, and maybe additional toppings for more flavor and textures).
… moreElena Wright
Ordered a Cauliflower crust pizza tonight with Chicken and other Toppings. It took a full hour to be ready. That place is a madhouse. It’s hard to locate where the pickup space is and servers are so incredibly busy you probably can’t snag one to ask. Shoulder to shoulder standing room in there. I finally got the pizza and the chicken is breaded. There’s nothing online that indicates this (it’s just listed as chicken) and since I’m gluten free I can’t eat it. It would be helpful to list ingredients correctly, especially since they offer allergy-friendly ingredients like vegan cheese, so it seems like someone with an allergy can eat there safely. Thankfully, I’m not severely sensitive so I picked off the chicken and ate it. The rest of the pizza was good, hence the 3rd star.
I was hoping to call, but there’s no number to be found online. The one on my receipt is a disconnected number.
A little effort in customer service and care in listing ingredients would make this place much better!
… moreI was hoping to call, but there’s no number to be found online. The one on my receipt is a disconnected number.
A little effort in customer service and care in listing ingredients would make this place much better!
Jade Lowrey
This really is top tier pizza. The crust is flat out amazing. Light, crunchy and chewy all at the same time. The Ezzo Pepperoni adds just the right amount of zip. The sauce is fresh, and made from quality ingredients. Not too sweet, not to acidic…. Just right! Perfect amount of cheese that doesn’t drown out the other flavors. All in All, this is some of the very best pizza I’ve ever eaten. The place could use some acoustic treatment in the dining area, as it get’s extremely loud, and echoey…. Difficult to carry on a conversation on a busy night. But that’s my only complaint.
… moreEric Biehl
Pizza was delicious. A nice crisp to the crust and the Ezzo pepperoni was very good. Zero leftovers.
… moreJosh Duncan
Place is amazing, over and over again. Constantly the best pizza in Columbus.
… moreR K
Easily the best pizza I’ve ever had. That’s crazy to write.
Had the NY style Kevin Bacon. Wow. Just. Wow. Nice crispy crust, excellent sauce, unreal toppings. Not only would I happily eat here again, this is a place I’d happily bring people to enjoy top-notch pizza. Yum.
… moreHad the NY style Kevin Bacon. Wow. Just. Wow. Nice crispy crust, excellent sauce, unreal toppings. Not only would I happily eat here again, this is a place I’d happily bring people to enjoy top-notch pizza. Yum.
Tara Bebinger
Listen, this was probably the best pizza we’ve ever had. It was charred perfectly, with a lightness to it that made it so unique. Then you get this burst of flavor. We ordered a “Mike” NY style and a “Kevin Bacon” Motown style. This deep dish motown style was my absolute favorite. The salad was vig enough for three people to share. And the garlic parm fries were delish. Great atmosphere here too. Get there early as they do sell out of pizza.
… more