Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 921 E Johnstown Rd, Columbus, OH 43230
Website: https://www.sextonsburgerbar.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sexton’s Burger bar
FIND US. 921 E Johnstown Rd, Columbus, OH 43230. To navigate the map with touch gestures double-tap and hold your finger on the map, then drag the map.
sextonsburgerbar · Gahanna, OH – Instagram
Burgers • Chicken Sandwiches • Sides & Bar @sextonspizza @braxtonmiller. MONDAY – SATURDAY: 11:30-9pm. SUNDAY: 12-8pm 921 e Johnstown rd gahanna, OH …
Menu — Sexton’s Burger bar
“BURGERS”. Local Ohio Proud Beef On A Martin Potato Roll. Try it DELUXE! +Lettuce / Tomato. Classic. Cheese / Onion / Pickles … Columbus, OH 43230. BESbswy.
Reviews
Coretta
My husband and I stopped in for lunch and were not disappointed at all. From the moment we walked in, everything was top-notch. The food was absolutely delicious—fresh, hot, and made to order. You could truly taste the quality.
Our server was amazing and gave us great recommendations that we ended up going with. We ordered the Oklahoma Onion Burger with Bacon and added the Burger Bar Sauce, which took it to another level. The flavor was incredible. We also ordered the fries with a side of cheese—honestly, the burgers were so good we almost forgot about the fries!
Before leaving, we decided to grab a pizza from Sexton Pizza, just a few doors down, to take home for dinner later—and it was just as impressive. We ordered the thick crust, and it was absolutely delicious. The crust was perfectly cooked, and the toppings were plentiful and flavorful.
Great food, amazing service, and a fantastic overall experience. We will definitely be recommending this place to family and friends and will absolutely be back again.
… moreOur server was amazing and gave us great recommendations that we ended up going with. We ordered the Oklahoma Onion Burger with Bacon and added the Burger Bar Sauce, which took it to another level. The flavor was incredible. We also ordered the fries with a side of cheese—honestly, the burgers were so good we almost forgot about the fries!
Before leaving, we decided to grab a pizza from Sexton Pizza, just a few doors down, to take home for dinner later—and it was just as impressive. We ordered the thick crust, and it was absolutely delicious. The crust was perfectly cooked, and the toppings were plentiful and flavorful.
Great food, amazing service, and a fantastic overall experience. We will definitely be recommending this place to family and friends and will absolutely be back again.
Rob Parsley
Sexton’s was put on our radar but local social media food influencers. It did not disappoint. The food was hot and fresh. Served on a fresh potato roll. The cheese fries where absolutely delicious. Local soda over the big name sodas hit the spot. I don’t give the 5 stars ✨️ unless it hits… this definitely hit. Highly recommend
… moreCameron F
Fries made me gag. A couple of the fries had a really bad burnt oil cardboardy taste, never had that anywhere before. They also weren’t crispy, they were very soft.
The burger was okay but nothing like the pictures. In the pictures its a seared, crispy, smashburger. My burger tasted very similar to a wendys daves single. There was no sear or crisp on my burger. Way too much sauce.
… moreThe burger was okay but nothing like the pictures. In the pictures its a seared, crispy, smashburger. My burger tasted very similar to a wendys daves single. There was no sear or crisp on my burger. Way too much sauce.
JJ Crisostomo
Excellent smash burgers in the Gahanna area. Thin, crispy and flavorful. Their plain fries ain’t bad either. No waiting on an early Thursday evening. Friendly and quick service. Sexton’s also has a pizza place just around the corner from this burger place. Will definitely try that likewise. Highly recommended burger joint.
… moreNoah Brudapast
Nice little burger bar with a good selection of libations. Had the Bacon BBQ smash burger that hit the spot with crispy bacon and that grilled burger taste. Fries are hand cut and thin…and everything came out hot and fresh! Service was attentive and quick with a diner style setup! It’s a definite go-to if you are in the area and craving a burger!!!
… morebryan rooth
We are a big fan of the pizza place, so we figured we would try their burgers. Nice little place, and the burgers had good flavor. They are a smash burger and not a patty like other places. Fries were good, and you get a lot. Took off 1 star cause they don’t have bacon for the burgers. Enjoyed the selection of soda that had, and we will be back to try them again. I hope to get bacon and possibly an egg on my burger next time.
… moreChristopher Brown
Update: The “team” has posted an absolutely laughable response. No restaurant worth anyone’s time or money would claim that waiting 45 minutes after stated pick up times is reasonable. On top of that they claim it was a “busy” period. There was one person dining in, and one other person waiting to pick up, and since they just claimed everything is made fresh to order there is no way it was “busy”. To make things worse once we did get our food it was terrible. Burgers were cold, and the fries had clearly been made in week old fryer oil, that’s a taste that is unmistakable. Either get your team together and learn to put food out and change fryer oil or get out. This community deserves better.
What’s the point in letting people order pick up if you literally never start making the food until after people arrive. Multiple times now, and not just myself but friends as well, have ordered then walked in to see everyone standing around doing nothing. “Ten more minutes.” After a 30 minute call ahead is wild. You know what’s worse? Actually taking twenty minutes to make two mediocre smash burgers.
This place is a joke, being run by someone who isn’t paying attention to their staff, who are obviously just lazily collecting their checks while doing as little actual work as they can. Save yourself the time and the money.
… moreWhat’s the point in letting people order pick up if you literally never start making the food until after people arrive. Multiple times now, and not just myself but friends as well, have ordered then walked in to see everyone standing around doing nothing. “Ten more minutes.” After a 30 minute call ahead is wild. You know what’s worse? Actually taking twenty minutes to make two mediocre smash burgers.
This place is a joke, being run by someone who isn’t paying attention to their staff, who are obviously just lazily collecting their checks while doing as little actual work as they can. Save yourself the time and the money.
Taylor Matthews
So I was so stoked to try this place and I ordered off DoorDash, so I can’t speak on in house experience. However, my order was missing my drink, I ordered a side of bacon and some of it was too burnt to eat, my chicken was super burnt, the burgers and fries were okay but all in all I probably won’t be returning. And there’s no way to call them either as there’s no phone number listed online.
… moreK-Cee Williams
I saw this place in the 614 magazine and I knew I had to try it immediately!!
This was the best burger I have ever had!
Fries too!! Food is PHENOMENAL, staff was fantastic, the place was clean and music was great. I highly recommend going. It is 100% worth the $.
I went on a Saturday about 5pm I ordered almost right after i sat down and 10 mins later i had my food.
I ordered a regular deluxe no mustard or mayo cause I wanted to try the 2 sauces and fries. The burger sauce is good but the ranch is very very good. Amazing!! I will be going back and taking friends with me.
… moreThis was the best burger I have ever had!
Fries too!! Food is PHENOMENAL, staff was fantastic, the place was clean and music was great. I highly recommend going. It is 100% worth the $.
I went on a Saturday about 5pm I ordered almost right after i sat down and 10 mins later i had my food.
I ordered a regular deluxe no mustard or mayo cause I wanted to try the 2 sauces and fries. The burger sauce is good but the ranch is very very good. Amazing!! I will be going back and taking friends with me.
Kaylee Luke
Shewww these burgers are GOOD. Perfectly cooked, crispy around the edges and soft throughout the burger itself. All of the sauces are great. The Serrano ranch has a great kick to it. Service was so great, never had to ask for drink refills and the food took less than 15 minutes to come out despite it being fairly crowded. We sat outside but the vibe of the inside of the restaurant seemed great. The staff were all very friendly and attentive. We will certainly be back.
… more