Casual spot for thin-crust pizzas cooked in a brick oven accompanied by salad & gelato.
Cameron Garber, DPT
Love this place! It’s our favorite go to date night restaurant. We love the Involtini salad! It’s amazing! I love how they use real, fresh ingredients and make more of an authentic wood fired pizza. Service is usually good to great and I love that they actually have Diet Doctor Pepper. It’s the small things sometimes. They have me addicted to balsamic reduction for salads now. Such a great flavor for those Mediterranean dishes. We keep going back because of their great flavors!
… moreCharisse Morrell
I’ve eaten here about 10 times. I want to like it but it’s just not going to happen. Extremely over priced for hit and miss quality and service. Pizza and focaccia come out burnt on the bottom 7 times out of 10. The pizzas are decent but not worth 15 bucks a pop, especially when they don’t put enough ingredients on them and they overcook them.
There are plenty of delicious restaurants at Station Park – this is not one of them.
… moreJ
Overpriced for only decent pizza. The menu is very small and has no pictures. The toppings were good but the crust was very floppy and soggy on the bottom. The gelato was very good though. Aside from the food, our server Josh was amazing. Probably my favorite server I’ve ever had!
… moreMr Avery
Went with my wife and loved the pizza.
If you’re looking for something that’s traditional American – super cheesy and gluttonous – try The Pie Pizzeria, one of my favorites when I’m in the mood. If you want authentic Italian, try this place. (See Andy Wariner’s review. It’s spot on.)
Those complaining about serving sizes eat a lot more than I do. One pizza does, however, feed only one person. I ate 2/3 of a pizza and I don’t have a huge appetite. This isn’t a problem for me. It’s a price I’ll pay for quality ingredients and tasty pizza.
… moreMike
This Settebello’s is awful. It was my first visit to this location because I have always gone to the one in Salt Lake. First, the waiter never checked on us from the moment we sat down. The hostess came to our table 15-20 minutes after we sat down and was unaware that anyone had come take our orders. Once the orders were given we never had anyone come back to our table for refills and information on our food. That was about 30-40 minutes from the time we ordered. We had somewhere to be, so someone in our group grabbed the hostess to see what the hold up was and if they were coming with our food. She said, “I’m not sure, let me see what’s going on.” She never came back with that information. It had been just over an hour with zero information so we decided to walk out and as we were standing up to leave they started bring our pizza. They didn’t apologize and only brought 2 of the 3 pizza’s because they never put in the order for the last pizza. I was very disappointed in this place and I don’t plan on returning to this location and it may even ruin my experience for the Salt Lake location…
… moreMadison Olsen
Do not choose this location for lunch unless you are able to spend several hours waiting for service!! 4 of my coworkers and myself recently ate lunch at the Farmington location and I doubt any of us will eat there again. The reasons are:
1. after being seated for at least 15 minutes the hostess came to our table and asked if the waiter has been out to help us. When we stated no she quickly informed us she would get us water and walked away without asking if we wanted anything other than water to drink. When she finally returned with the water she once again quickly walked away.
2. Several minutes after the hostess left water she returned and once again asked if the waiter had been to our table, when we once again said no she took our orders walked away.
3. I had ordered a salad while my coworkers each ordered pizza. My salad came out about 10 minutes after the order was placed.
4. 45 minutes after my salad had come out my coworkers still had not received their pizza nor had any Settebello employee been to our table since my salad arrived.
5. After one of my coworkers had gone to ask the hostess how long it would be until the pizza’s and it had been over an hour since we placed our orders we made the decision to leave. When we went to stand up two of the four pizzas arrived.
6. Once the third pizza arrived they informed us that the fourth pizza was just being placed in the oven.
during the entire time we were at Setebello’s I saw only two employees who both seemed more interested in talking to each other or to people wanting gelato than to customers who were seated in the restaurant. When looking at the multitude of reviews that are very similar to mine it is clear that management is aware of this issue yet hasn’t seemed to care enough to do anything about it. I would highly recommend avoiding this location especially during lunch.
… moreQuinton Bangerter
I’ve been here twice now and enjoyed it both times. The pizza is really tasty but it’s definitely not your typical pizza. Really thin almost flatbread like dough. My favorite part is the olive oil and balsamic vinegar that is an excellent addition to the pizza. I also like the appetizers more then the salads personally. I’d go back again sometime or take some friends to try something different.
… morepatricia tanis
Traditional Italian style pizzas. They get very close to authentic pizzas we have had in Rome. The menu is fairly limited and has not changed, except for a daily special. Try the foccatia appetizer but have them add cheese… yummy. Settebello pizza is our favorite. Not a fan of the salad but they are also very authentic, just like Italy, no dressing options. Service can be good or bad depending on the server. We really like the pizzas so we keep going back.
… moreKaden Killpack
5 star Pizza, 3 star service. Usually if I don’t absolutely love the customer service I don’t go back except a few exceptions. This is one of them. I absolutely hate pizza, yet I love the true Napoletano style here. Bringing in buffalo mozzarella, great touch! I’ve traveled the majority of Italy and would say if you want the pizza don’t worry about buying a plane ticket. I love the simple margarita. Most people generally eat there own pie however in a group of two an appetizer, salad and single pie is sufficient. The service isn’t terrible however servers can on occasion be very unattentive or distracted. Few to little contact or slow to bring a check however i guess that makes it more akin to Italy where patrons aren’t usually as rushed through dinner. If you want both the good pizza and great service there is a salt lake location (I believe it’s the original) and it meets a 5 star criteria. There is a review headlined “not much sauce or cheese” it’s not Chicago deep dish people it’s true to origin Italian thin crust. ‘The good stuff’ haha it’s not your cheap factory line American dominoes made from packaged ingredients. Worth every dollar.
… moreMatt Bullock
I am very disappointed after buying a gift card for a family member. It was requested to be left at the restaurant for them to pick up when they came.
These people I’d bought the gift card for had just lost a child. It was two days after the funeral. The dinner was my way of trying to give them a special evening of distraction from their heartbreak. Except the gift card was lost — the staff member had not properly set it aside — so the couple was forced to pay.
I was horrified when I heard of it afterwards. I immediately called back and requested a refund. I have made a total of six calls now for the whole boondoggle. Still no refund.
I love their pizza but am so disappointed. I have eaten at Settebello now consistently for almost 10 years with family, friends, and coworkers.
No gift card, no refund, no calls back, no response.
… more