Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4082 Nesconset Hwy, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733
Phone: (631) 476-8600
Website: http://www.setauketpastaria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Setauket Pastaria | For the Love of Pizza
Setauket Pastaria is about delicious Italian food served in abundant portions. … Owner Vincent Milano created this restaurant as a place to celebrate family and …
Dining Menu – Setauket Pastaria
Setauket Pastaria is about delicious Italian food served in abundant portions. Owner Vincent Milano created this restaurant as a place to celebrate family …
Setauket Pastaria – Setauket-East Setauket, NY – 4082 Nesconset …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Setauket Pastaria in Setauket-East Setauket, NY. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Reviews
Lisa Molinelli
The food was absolutely delicious! We ordered Penne Broccoli Rabe w/Sausage & Sun Dried Tomatoes, Gorgonzola Cavatelli and Rigatoni Bolognese. ALL of the were absolutely delicious! The staff was super friendly and attentive including our server Frankie. Will definitely be back!
… moreAdam S
The boxes the pizzas were in smelled like they were stored in a basement,they were all musty, just a strange smell, and I was able to taste it in the food. They made me return the food and instead of apologizing, the owner told me to never order from his restaurant again. I wasn’t making a scene, just returning the food. He said he was offended and doesn’t like getting ripped off. Not sure how I was ripping him off when I didn’t eat the food and was returning it. I have never been treated so poorly. That was the worst customer service I have ever seen. 0 stars, do not recommend.
… moreKristin Battaglia
My 6 year old daughter decided that after her doctor’s appointment, she wanted to have lunch with Mommy. We were pleasantly surprised to find Setauket Pastaria close by. We were greeted promptly, and were advised that it would be a little wait for fresh pizza. We waited patiently, and picked up the food to eat at the restaurant, (as my darling child requested! ), enjoyed it and then refueled, and went to leave. I made sure my daughter shared her positive review with the owner and young lady at the register. I shared that my father was a SCPO and we connected instantly when she said “Really?! Mine, too!” Bluebloods! Needless to say, it was a great first experience and we’ll certainly be back!
… moreRichard Papp
The food has been delicious. The pizza is very good. But the service is terrible. They’ve messed up my order at least 10 times over the last three years we’ve been going to this place including today. I’m not sure what the deal is, maybe poor management or lack of training. Or staff that are underpaid and just don’t care. Now I get in the habit of checking the order each time because there’s a good chance it’ll be messed up. I don’t seem to have this problem at other pizza places nearby.
… moreBryan Cain
My go to place for delicious pizza and rolls! The spinach roll is hands down my favorite on the island! The slices are made the way pizza should be made, good size with plenty of toppings.
Definitely Recommended on any pizza night!
Sadly, I don’t live close enough to enjoy their restaurant… I only get to enjoy when I drive up to drop my kid off at art class.
… moreDefinitely Recommended on any pizza night!
Sadly, I don’t live close enough to enjoy their restaurant… I only get to enjoy when I drive up to drop my kid off at art class.
K K
Disappointed. First time customer via Door Dash. Order was incorrect. The order ticket appeared to have been transferred incorrectly from Door Dash to the kitchen. My name was correct on the kitchen ticket as were two of the three items. My child received a two piece meatball side (ticket said 3 piece meatball side) when I ordered a Pasta with 2 Piece Meatballs . Needless to say there was a young child looking for pasta and crying at dinner tonight. Door Dash offered an easy refund for the error.
Red tomato based sauces are hit or miss for me. The Gnocchi itself was well done and the fresh mozzarella melted on top of it was really good. I didn’t personally care for the taste of the sauce. Others may really like it.
The 12” Margarita Pie wasn’t what I expected. Mine arrived with cheese that didn’t appear to be the usual fresh mozzarella like was on the gnocchi dinner. It was much more yellow and solid across the pie and had a considerable amount of oregano sprinkled all over the cheese. With so many other great options around I likely won’t return.
… moreRed tomato based sauces are hit or miss for me. The Gnocchi itself was well done and the fresh mozzarella melted on top of it was really good. I didn’t personally care for the taste of the sauce. Others may really like it.
The 12” Margarita Pie wasn’t what I expected. Mine arrived with cheese that didn’t appear to be the usual fresh mozzarella like was on the gnocchi dinner. It was much more yellow and solid across the pie and had a considerable amount of oregano sprinkled all over the cheese. With so many other great options around I likely won’t return.
Gisella Craig
This place is awasome, great food great service, people are very friendly.
They have incredible prices for their lunch specials. Parking is not a problem here.
Place is clean and food is delicious every plate is prepared as we order them. The food is freshly cooked.
I had once Italian friends that came to visit us from Maryland and they love the food.
#brokerGCraig #lovetoeathere
… moreThey have incredible prices for their lunch specials. Parking is not a problem here.
Place is clean and food is delicious every plate is prepared as we order them. The food is freshly cooked.
I had once Italian friends that came to visit us from Maryland and they love the food.
#brokerGCraig #lovetoeathere
Donna Dina
Food is delicious. We usually do take out but decided to eat there. Friendly waitstaff but a bit slow. Atmosphere a little dated.
… moreCourtney Rose
The food is great, and I like how they are catering to people that are celiac/gluten free. That is very appreciated! My only complaint is that portions are just a bit small. I paid $40 for a pasta dish And there was not even enough for 2 people. The container wasn’t even half full. Usually, when I order from an Italian restaurant, I can split the pasta dish with someone else and theres still leftovers because the container is full. Pasta is so cheap And easy to make. I think they should consider making their portions a little bit bigger.
… moreLuke Gaddis
Big fan of their speciality slices. I’d prefer regular pizza elsewhere. But always had solid speciality slices.
… more