Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros

About Us Selden Pizzeria specializes in Greek and Italian cuisine. Open 7 days a week for lunch & dinner with delivery also available, we cater any event no …

Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros – View Menu & Order Online – Slice

Order online at one of the best restaurants in Selden, NY! Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …

Last Updates

Reviews

Gregory DaSilva

Not going here anymore. We went there a lot but tonight was the straw. Called at 5:33pm, they told me 20 minutes for my order. My wife gets there by 6pm and they told her another 10 minutes. The food wasn’t ready until around 6:20pm. We told them that we ordered early because we were having people over and had an ice cream cake in the car. The girl behind the counter proceeded to eat her food and say “they’re working on it”. No apologies for our order taking an hour. As we are about to walk through the door to leave, they yell over and said they forgot part of our order. They clearly forgot about our food after we ordered. We ordered zeppoles, and they were disgusting. They basically ripped out the white part from a loaf of Italian bread, rolled it into a ball, and fried it up. It was the absolute worst zeppole I’ve ever tasted. The Sicilian pie we ordered was doughy and undercooked. There’s plenty of places to get decent to good pizza/food around here. They have my business now.

… more

Honda Dirt-Bike Matty

Okay I love the pizza there , & the Christmas decorations doing Christmas ! , but the thing is tables are dirty sometimes , in general. Then sometiems tho once I got meatball hero it was horrible. The the delivery drivers drive 10000 miles per hours through the parking lot. But everything else was good pizzia was good & staff is okay!

… more

Pavan Sharma

I walked in woth my family at prime lunch time.
Not a single customer inside.
The girl taking the order had a very pissy attitude. Giving my family and myself very unwelcoming stare.
No smile on her face and nasty one word answers.
No wonder no one goes to this joint.
We felt very uncomfortable and walked out without ordering.

… more

Joanna Murphy

I ordered a gyro a BLT and white slice. Sauce came in the side and they said it was for the BLT. It was delivered. So I called the store. The gyro was dry as a dessert. No sauce. I called and spoke with someone who said he was ONE of the owners. He kept over talking me and saying the sauce comes on it unless you ask for it on the side. Very rude. Would not even listen to me. He said he didn’t make it. EXACTLY! But are you not part owner?? I said I can send you a picture gyros come WITH SAUCE there was NO SAUCE AT ALL! I have pictures of the entire sandwich. He tells me take it up with Uber eats. Really? They didn’t make the mistake the pizza place did. and instead of just apologizing he says call Uber eats then. I always order from this place. After that conversation I will never again. Rude very very rude. I have many pictures PROVING there was no sauce. The sauce is white. The only thing partly white on the sandwich was the lettuce because I ordered no onions not no sauce. Never again. Very rude to customers and that was an owner. Very bad business tactics… SHOW ME THE SAUCE PLEASE? SO DONT TELL ME THERE IS ALWAYS SAUCE!! AND IT WAS NOT ORDERED ON THE SIDE HE SAID YOU DIDN’T ORDER ON THE SIDE IT CAME ON IT! REALLY? PLEASE SHOW ME!!! I WILL NOW GET MY GYROS THAT DONT TASTE AS GOOD COST MORE AND LESS QUALITY JUST BECAUSE OF THE WAY A PART OWNER REACTED TO ME. IF YOU CAN BE SO RUDE TO CUSTOMERS YOU NEED A NEW CAREER. AND IM THE ONLY ONE WHO’S COMPLAINED? LOOK AT YOUR OTHER REVIEWS. WHY WOULD YOU APOLOGIZE TO PEOPLE IF IM THE ONLY ONE. AMD OFCOURSE THEY WILL APOLOGIZE ON THE REVIEW FOR EVERYONE TO SEE IT. BUT WHEN ITS JUST YOU AND THEM THEY DONT CARE. JUST REMEMBER WHAT’S HIDDEN IN THE DARK COMES TO LIGHT!! YOU HIDE YOUR TRUE SELF AND APOLOGIZE ON YOUR REVIEWS?! BUT YOU COULDN’T CARE LESS ON THE PHONE. YOUR CHOICE. WHAT YOU TRIED TO HIDE IN THE DARK IS COMING TO LIGHT!

… more

Rashmi Sharma

Horrible customer service. Never left a place that fast. Disgusting attitude from the young girl. The other man had nothing to say about her attitude. Disgusting. Never coming back. Didn’t even end up getting food, just walked out. They don’t deserve to be called a business.

… more

James C

When only the best will do, Selden pizza delivers. The pizza along with all of the meals this restaurant makes have always been hot and delicious.
Our childen and grandchildren love when we order takeout out from this restaurant.

… more

Catherine Caroline

Walked in, was greeted horribly by young lady at register. Gave the most horrible attitude when asked simple questions about menu and items. By that alone made me leave, lost my appetite by her disgusting demeanor. I don’t know what her problem is either racist or just a horrible personality. Either way i came in with a smile to get a slice of pizza and left with nothing but a bad interaction. Shame on her.

… more

Quinn

The address is easy to find. The parking lot is huge with a lot of parking . There is fleet USPS here duck donuts and Chinese restaurant and a supermarket and Burlington Coat Factory . You walk in and it looks like your pizza store design just like the rest of the pizza store in long island and it looks a little old and dirty too!! Start off with the cashier ordering food. She had a runny nose and clean her runny nose with her palm of her hand good thing only ordering food and I realize she was bringing out the food to us lol I have tried many dishes here the pizza, the garlic bread, the Charro salad. The hero is all good here.

… more

James Kryger

Very consistent and great quality food! This is our go to spot and everyone always loves the food!

… more

Brian Baugh

Shockingly dirty. It looked like the entire days floor droppings were left to sweep up at the end of the night. I usually get food to go but for some reason my wife wanted to stay. I could eat by forcing myself not to look around . I frequently get delivery from here but now that I see where it comes from, not anymore.

… more

… View more

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results