See No Evil Pizza

  4.6 – 354 reviews   • Pizza restaurant

Social Profile:

✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery See No Evil Pizza 10019

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Reservations: resy.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

See No Evil Pizza – Times Square, New York City, NY

See No Evil Pizza on West 50th Street serves bold thin-crust pizza, small plates, and soft serve in an NYC subway-level spot with an 80s punk vibe.

(@seenoevilpizza) – Instagram

A modern NY pizzeria in the belly of Times Square.

Food Menu – See No Evil Pizza

Discover See No Evil Pizza’s menu with pizzas like the hell pie and funghi. You can also choose from antipasti or different kinds of insalata.

Reviews

Kimberly Rodriguez
This is pizza done right I wanted to try the Johnny Peppers since it seems like it would be the most packed flavor pie. And I was right. Bell peppers, hot cherry peppers, onions, garlic, sausage all incorporated with gooey cheese and tomatoey sauce. Dispite all those toppings this pizza manages to taste light. I didn’t feel heavy after eating. The location is on the smaller size and the day that owner it was a little too warm inside the restaurant. Staff wasn’t that great. But definitely go for the pizza
… more
Jean Ng
Nothing scream more New York than a hidden pizza shop in a subway entrance.

Have being passing this little hidden spot every time we are taking the 1 train home on 50th street after a show nearby and we finally sat foot in.

One pie is good for sharing. The pie came out fast, love the doughy crust although a little sloppy just be careful not to burn your tongue because you just want to gaucho it down once you start.

The space reminds me of a 80’ vibe, a little small but they have many tables and can be joined together to sit a large group. For those big group who wants to get a late night snack after a show all together, head there asap it gets filled up quickly as many others are thinking of the same.
… more
Emma Davis
What a cool experience! This is more of a casual pizza spot in downtown 1 subway at 50th Street. It’s a retro kind of feel, the place was popping! It was definitely a mix of tourists and locals. It felt like a unique but authentic experience in NYC, which is rare, usually ‘unique’ experiences can end up being kitschy/overpriced.

The pizza was SO delicious- Neapolitan style. We were actually struggling with all of the choices, because everything sounded so good. We went to their bar next door afterwards, Nothing Really Matters, and it was super lively at around 10 pm, and was actually going to get even livelier, according to the host. Oh! And there was an awesome dj.
… more
Isabelle McGee
The staff was super kind and very prompt. The food was amazing, and the vibes were vibing. I loved having the smaller dining area, makes NYC feel a little less crowded
… more
Claire Kegel
Had an incredible experience at See No Evil Pizza. The pizza, appetizers, and desserts were absolutely delicious. Service was excellent. Definitely will be back.
… more
Darryl Green
Place was nice in a great location. Service was great, didnt have great luck with our pizzas. 1 was really good, the pineapple wasn’t great tasting. The crust was awesome, just didnt love the toppings on the pinapple. Felt like the Pinapple pieces themselves were not cooked at all and very hard.
… more
E “Eddie”
Noisy, crowded and bursting with atmosphere this restaurant exemplifies the best of Manhattan. The food was incredibly good. We had a Swimming in cheese and a La Adriana. Very good ingredients but the crust is also a big part of what makes the pizzas delicious. The employees were very friendly and welcoming
… more
Susan Gilliland
Pizza Pie was delicious. We tried “Hells Pie” and it was great! Pricing was thirty bucks – a tiny coke glass bootle was six bucks. Our young server looked like he COULD’VE been a pleasant server- but, maybe he was having a bad day- I hope God consoles him. Odd location but fun. Try it, it’s yummy.
… more
Mr Spiffy
I was told about this place by a friend who said it had great reviews so we met there. I was suprised that it was located going down the Subway entrance on the 1 line. Also suprised that they have reservations but we were lucky to get a spot for an hour. All in all, this is a great place. The personal size margherita pizza was was great along with the service. It tends to get a bit warm and packed in there given the seating and cooking area is close. I was pleased with our pizza and service provided. Definitely a good spot to bring someone or a group.
… more
Alina Dorina
Great place to eat before a Broadway show. It’s a little hidden since it’s inside the subway entrance, but just look for the big souvenir shop on the corner and you’ll find it downstairs.

The food and drinks are really good for the price. The pizza was amazing, and we also tried the tomato and watermelon salad, which I’d definitely recommend. We ordered non-alcoholic cocktails, and they were actually made well – properly shaken, not just soda in a glass like some places do.

There are plenty of tables, service was fast, and the music was at a nice level – not too loud. The location by the subway adds to the whole New York vibe. Perfect spot to grab something tasty before heading to a show!
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment