Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 219 E Cumberland St, Lewisburg, OH 45338
Phone: (937) 962-2621
Website: https://eatsarahs.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sarah’s Pizza
Order ONLINE from the Eaton, West Alexandria or Lewisburg stores! Eaton,OH -(937)456-6871 | Lewisburg,OH – (937)962-2621 | West Alexandria,OH …
Sarah’s Pizza Lewisburg – Facebook
Sarah’s Pizza Lewisburg. Serving Lewisburg and surrounding areas for 29 years. Try one of our specialty pizzas today.
Sarah’s Pizza – Lewisburg – Visit Preble County
219 East Cumberland, Street Lewisburg, Ohio 45338. (937) 962-2621. Visit website. Important. Contact information is reviewed annually with the release of …
Reviews
Melissa Cleary, Realtor
Sarah’s pizza is always a crowd pleaser for our crew! We love the crust, the sauce and the toppings are generously portioned.
The staff is always pleasant.
If you are looking for some great pizza you must give them a try.
… moreThe staff is always pleasant.
If you are looking for some great pizza you must give them a try.
Chez jones
I had a small extra pepperoni pizza and a Pepsi. I think it was around 13 bucks. The pizza was really good and hot. Customer service wasn’t friendly but not mean just blah. Atmosphere was clean, but not a place to take a nice date. It looks like its the only place in town to eat. I would eat there again if I pass through town again.
… moreWulf R
I haven’t eaten their pizza for over 5 years, took a road trip to feed my Dad a treat. I’ve been in the pizza industry for over 30 years, and as a Manager I was COMPLETELY SATISIFIED and utterly ASTOUNDED by their product quality. Further, I was at the location when it opened in 1990. Something else I like is the in store remodeling. The Crew of this spot needs to be rewarded. Suggestion for development – outside the store, it will increase sales volume from us 40.
… moreHeatman16 Justis
Should not have to pay for credit card charge a delivery fee while having to microwave the food again when you get it. Lucky I didn’t call the cops for being robbed. Come on big bearded guy like ,,, you should be charged with theft or at least false advertising. Not reasonable any more food is blan service is horrible. You definitely can do better but seems your to greedy to change it.
… moreBrayden Bacher
Seniors for Sarah’s. I have went to Papa John’s, Pizza Hut, Casano’s. You name the place and I’ve been there. No other pizza place compares to the pizza at Sarah’s. Absolutely delicious. My favorite dish is the Pepperoni pizza.
… moreD K
Our 1st time ordering here from TA truck stop. Experience was great but food was even better, definitely satisfied especially when you deal with good people! Order over phone was pleasantly quick & precise, so was the delivery Keep up the good work, thank you from a fellow driver.
… moreDave Burton
reading reviews from the last month or so explains why I got what i got tonight. it isn’t a bad night or even just busy last few weeks last couple pizzas we have ordered showed well after an hour wait I live 1 mile down the road by the way I asked for extra sauce and chees I don’t see it. the wife’s onion rings were soft and cold her sub was soggy and gross. spending 50 dollars and this is what we get last time I order from sarahs
… moreNicole Pachin
Prices have gone up but the quality of your service has gone WAY down! My family orders from here a lot. For at least the past 6 months, this place can’t seem to get a simple order right, which is frustrating when you’re paying extra to have things added, or order extra of an ingredient, and don’t receive it! Time after time after time! Do you people even READ the specifics of an order??? People are paying a LOT of $ to support you, and every single time, I’m paying extra for things i do not receive! You need some competition in this town to make you pay attention to orders, i suppose.
… morechris kerns
I would give service a 5,but the 2 employees, seemed,had a limited customer service window,other than that,food great,neat little place
… morePatrick Ripberger
One of the best pizza places around. They have cauliflower crust pizza for those with Gluten sensetivity and it’s amazing!
… more