Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Gourmet wood-fired pizzas, wine & espresso served in a snug, rustic space with sidewalk seating.
Hours
| Friday | 12–11 PM |
| Saturday | 12–11 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 4–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1559 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028
Phone: (212) 861-2434
Website: https://www.sanmatteonyc.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina – New York City, NY
Since 2010, Pizzeria San Matteo has been successfully offering the best Italian, Campania and Salerno products to the city of New York.
San Matteo Pizza & Espresso Bar – New York, NY
Since 2010, Pizzeria San Matteo has been successfully offering the best Italian, Campania, and Salerno products to the city of New York.
San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina (@sanmatteocucina) – Instagram
48K followers · 1.1K+ following · 2600 posts · @sanmatteocucina: “ Authentic Neapolitan Pizza | Housemade Pasta Events & Catering 1559 2nd Ave NYC …
Last Updates
Reviews
Leon Lin
Tried the San matteo burger to go and it was tasty!
The caramelised onions add more depth of flavour to balance the beef flavour. Note that they use a different type of bun though.
The wedges were good too.
Would personally have liked more cheese in the burger.
Would come again to check out the pizza
… moreThe caramelised onions add more depth of flavour to balance the beef flavour. Note that they use a different type of bun though.
The wedges were good too.
Would personally have liked more cheese in the burger.
Would come again to check out the pizza
Daniel Lee
Service was quick! Pizza was deeeelicious!
Arrinicini was a bit too big and I find the larger size makes it too easy to be dry
However, the MEATBALLS? I could do 2 orders of that. Plus the sauce was soooo tasty.
If I had to go again, definitely to try more of the pizzas and get the meatballs. Especially because you can save the meatballs and sauce for pasta that you can make at home!
… moreArrinicini was a bit too big and I find the larger size makes it too easy to be dry
However, the MEATBALLS? I could do 2 orders of that. Plus the sauce was soooo tasty.
If I had to go again, definitely to try more of the pizzas and get the meatballs. Especially because you can save the meatballs and sauce for pasta that you can make at home!
Rachel Lubin
My husband and I moved out of the neighborhood a year and a half ago, and always dream of having San Matteo when other pizzas fall short. The gold standard of brick oven margarita pizzas on the UES is definitely San Matteo. Thank you for the delicious pizzas and excellent service .
… moreEddie Zhang
Never had a worse delivery pizza. Arrived cold fresh from the fridge. Didn’t give me the topping I asked. So clearly they didn’t even bother to throw my toppings onto the cold pizza. Maybe they ran out of sausages from last week to pair their one week old leftover cold pizza.
… moreConnie Kwok
Always a 5 start experience here at the bar or seated in the restaurant, alone, on a date or with a group. We celebrated a ladies night reunion here, and had exceptional, attentive service to make sure we left on time for our show. It was early so we enjoyed a spot to the right of the restaurant enjoying plenty of windows. Lots of space, a welcoming and rustic atmosphere.
There is a broad menu of cocktails, legit Italian pizza and food, esp with the specials! It was very hard to choose! For 6 people, we enjoyed 4 pizzas, a pasta, a couple of salads. We also had the brussel sprouts (decent, but we didn’t realize they were roasted!). Food was served hot the waitstaff is fast with requests. Make a reservation, enjoy the authentic Italian pizza! We’ll be back!!
… moreThere is a broad menu of cocktails, legit Italian pizza and food, esp with the specials! It was very hard to choose! For 6 people, we enjoyed 4 pizzas, a pasta, a couple of salads. We also had the brussel sprouts (decent, but we didn’t realize they were roasted!). Food was served hot the waitstaff is fast with requests. Make a reservation, enjoy the authentic Italian pizza! We’ll be back!!
Maria Gutierrez
Great place to unwind after a workday, specially for happy hour. Chill vibe, friendly staff, able to talk, enjoying a nice night out.
… moreTracy Forzaglia
We love this place! We always sit at the bar where the fantastic server helps ensure that everything about our meal is perfect, delicious and fun. From happy hour Montepulciano to pizza to calzone to broccoli arab – we feast and drink and laugh. Tonight we even got special Amaro de capo. Salud! And thank you! We will return!
… moreEmma Nelson
The start of our meal here wasn’t great because we had a reservation but the restaurant overbooked by a ton. Waited a full half hour to be seated for our reservation, which was disappointing but the hostess was working hard to make things work for everyone!
The food was incredible, we had the Ravioli (so good), the margarita pizza, and the Burrata & Prosciutto. The absolute best part of our experience here though was our sweet and fun waitress, Carmella! She was amazing!!
… moreThe food was incredible, we had the Ravioli (so good), the margarita pizza, and the Burrata & Prosciutto. The absolute best part of our experience here though was our sweet and fun waitress, Carmella! She was amazing!!
Jerry
Went to visit our son in NYC and do all the tourist stuff, tree, Bryant Park, etc and figured he would know of a good place to grab a bite. Well he sure did! We went back up to near his apartment on the upper east side where he made a reservation at San Matteo. Atmosphere was great, hostess was very accommodating as we arrived 15 minutes early to catch some of the Eagles football game at the bar, waitress was personable, sweet and quick to answer questions. I ended up ordering the San Matteo burger, yea at an Italian restaurant i ordered a burger but my son said it was well worth it. He was right! Besides, I stole a taste of the Chicken Parm from my daughter and it too was equally delicious. The apps were equally as good. In the end, all 6 of us had a great experience. Definitely a place we will go to on our next visit with my son.
… moreAmir Rajabi
We tried the margarita pizza and fried burrata special and they were great. Carmela is a very welcoming host.
… more