Sammy’s Subs is a NY-style deli in Wayne, NJ, serving up the freshest ingredients and highest quality meats. Our homemade bread pairs perfectly with our signature sandwiches or your custom creation. We also offer delicious Italian food and Italian cuisine, bringing authentic flavors to every bite. Whether you’re craving a classic sub or a taste of Italy, Sammy’s Subs delivers the best sandwiches and Italian specialties in town. Our menu features a variety of options, all made fresh to order. Visit Sammy’s Subs today and experience the perfect blend of deli favorites and Italian cuisine—crafted with care and bursting with flavor. Stop by for an unforgettable meal!
Robert Graber
Ordered a Pastrami Sandwich
Served with Swiss, coleslaw, Russian dressing. Got macaroni salad which was a bit dry, instead. Sandwich was definitely hot but little dry. Didn’t seem to be any dressing on it. Mozzarella sticks were hot and little juicy. Came with French fries. Although we’re hot we’re dry and not much flavor.
… moreDan Midkiff
Traveling for work and found this gem! I ate here for lunch two days in a row and ordered both cold subs and wasn’t disappointed. Small business with great owner and amazing food. Please choose this location over chains as the food quality and quantity is far superior.
… moreLive, Learn & Love
Can barely walk from how full I am . Food was good, staff was friendly and place was clean and welcoming. Honestly I went for breakfast and liked it so much I came back for lunch. Portions are huge so I may finish my lunch for dinner
… moremarwan kaid
Great addition to the neighborhood! I had their fried chicken sub and they let me customize my own platter , everything was so fresh and tasty. Highly recommend this spot! The service was also awesome and the staff was very friendly, will definitely come back every time I’m around .
… moreSara Samara
After reading other reviews, I decided to give Sammy subs a try. Through DoorDash we ordered a grilled chicken sandwich with fries. My son had a turkey and cheese sub, he ate his sandwich so fast I didn’t get to take a picture of it!
The sub was huge and made with a generous amount of turkey!
My chicken sandwich was the best I’ve ever had- and I’m a super picky eater!
Just the right amount of lettuce and tomatoes per chicken ratio (see, I told you I was picky).
One thing for sure, Sammy Subs just became my go to for lunch!
Definitely a must try!
… moreMitchell Tomasek
What an abomination of an Italian sub especially for a North Jersey deli. After reading reviews and looking at pics, I had high hopes. Meat is cut about a 1/4 inch thick and looks pre cut. Meat also seems poor quality. Bread is decent. Overall horrible experience and won’t be back. The pic says it all
… moreMike Fire
They have a great potential to be an AWESOME place! But they must ramp up their variety of spreads (more home made unique sauces, rather than store bought) they should offer more toppings and add-ons (vegetables, fruit, etc.) bigger bread (small sandwich is too small, while large is humongous)
Good luck. Will try again next month/year.
… morenehaya deeb
The food is phenomenal. The soups are so healing if you are not feeling well. The subs are definitely comfort food made with love. I’m hooked. I order from them almost everyday. They go above and beyond customer service.
… moreNarzan Abedh
I recently visited Sammy Subs and was thoroughly impressed! The quality of the food is fantastic – the meats are always fresh, and everything tastes incredibly flavorful. The atmosphere inside is outstanding, creating a welcoming and enjoyable environment to enjoy a meal. On top of that, the customer service is excellent. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure you have a great experience. If you’re looking for a great sub spot, Sammy Subs should definitely be at the top of your list!
… moreFrank Congleton
Spent a half hour trying to call in an order! They don’t answer the phone! Why have it? Why is it everyone has a phone Nowadays, yet , more and more you can’t get in touch with who you’re trying to call!? Go figure! If it’s one of these DoorDash junks , you’re not getting my business!
… more