Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria is a beloved multi-location pizzeria headquartered in Rochester, NY since 1978! We serve up delicious pizzas that are crafted with the finest ingredients. Our diverse menu includes classic and gourmet pizzas, mouth-watering wings, subs, salads, pasta dishes, and more. Whether you’re dining in, taking out, or enjoying our efficient delivery service, you’ll experience the same high quality and exceptional taste that has made us a local favorite. Catering services are also available for events of any size. Visit one of our convenient locations to taste Rochester’s Favorite Pizza!
Area chain restaurant offering creative pies, tons of toppings, wings & Italian subs.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4820 W Deer Lake Dr Suite 11, Jacksonville, FL 32246
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria closes in Jacksonville
Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria at 4820 Deer Lake W. in Tapestry Park has closed. The Rochester, New York-based chain has 37 restaurants …
Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria permanently closes in Jacksonville
‘With great sadness’: Jacksonville restaurant serving Rochester-style pizza abruptly closes · Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria in Jacksonville has closed after …
Salvatore’s announced that they are closing:( – Facebook
Salvatore’s announced that they are closing:( The discussion is about a pizza place in Tapestry Park that has closed down, with customers …
Reviews
Mrs. S C.
Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria is an outstanding restaurant. Having seen the excellent reviews, I decided to visit and was not disappointed. The staff are friendly and welcoming, creating a pleasant dining atmosphere. The food is superb, with generous portions and excellent prices. I highly recommend the chicken bacon ranch pizza. It was absolutely delicious!
… moreAntoinette Bushey
After a long anticipated wait. We were disappointed. After living up North for 45+ years and knowing what good pizza should be…this was not it. To make it worse the cannolis were soggy and frozen. Who sells pre-made frozen cannolis????
We ordered a medium Alfredo pizza with no olives, a 12 inch cauliflower pizza with pepperoni, 5 mild wings, 5 bbq boneless/nuggets, drinks and 2 orders of cannolis.
The Alfredo pizza had a good taste, but wasn’t hot enough. The cauliflower pizza wasn’t any better than an $8 frozen one from the grocery store. Both wings were rubbery andtasteless. The drinks were room temperature, out of the cooler. They have no cups or ice. Both pizzas came to us uncut and we had to wait several minutes for plates, and a plastic pizza cutter. The most disappointing item were the cannolis. I even asked if they were made fresh and filled to order. Only to be told, yes and it will take about 15 minutes. What they meant to say it will take about 15 minutes to thawl out. They were the worse cannolis ever. Cold, soggy, plain filling with no chocolate chips…just frozen pasty filling and chewy shell.
Tony D’s has been our go to and will remain our favorite spot for great pizza, wonderful staff and, not the best but good/fresh cannolis.
… moreWe ordered a medium Alfredo pizza with no olives, a 12 inch cauliflower pizza with pepperoni, 5 mild wings, 5 bbq boneless/nuggets, drinks and 2 orders of cannolis.
The Alfredo pizza had a good taste, but wasn’t hot enough. The cauliflower pizza wasn’t any better than an $8 frozen one from the grocery store. Both wings were rubbery andtasteless. The drinks were room temperature, out of the cooler. They have no cups or ice. Both pizzas came to us uncut and we had to wait several minutes for plates, and a plastic pizza cutter. The most disappointing item were the cannolis. I even asked if they were made fresh and filled to order. Only to be told, yes and it will take about 15 minutes. What they meant to say it will take about 15 minutes to thawl out. They were the worse cannolis ever. Cold, soggy, plain filling with no chocolate chips…just frozen pasty filling and chewy shell.
Tony D’s has been our go to and will remain our favorite spot for great pizza, wonderful staff and, not the best but good/fresh cannolis.
Jazzlyn Sorensen
This was absolutely phenomenal!! 10/10 🙂
Definitely a place we are going to be coming back to!! The beautiful lady that put in are order I can’t quite remember but I think her name was Eliza sorry if it’s wrong, but she was absolutely amazing her and her beautiful family!! Definitely inspiring to see family working together:)
We got the Salvatore’s pizza, and a 5 piece bone-in hot sauce wings. It was all hot, fresh, and delicious!! Go get your self some Salvatore’s pizza you won’t be sorry!!:)
Much blessings to this beautiful family who made are night so very special!! ❤️
Ps we eat some of the wings and then realized that we needed to take a picture..lol
… moreDefinitely a place we are going to be coming back to!! The beautiful lady that put in are order I can’t quite remember but I think her name was Eliza sorry if it’s wrong, but she was absolutely amazing her and her beautiful family!! Definitely inspiring to see family working together:)
We got the Salvatore’s pizza, and a 5 piece bone-in hot sauce wings. It was all hot, fresh, and delicious!! Go get your self some Salvatore’s pizza you won’t be sorry!!:)
Much blessings to this beautiful family who made are night so very special!! ❤️
Ps we eat some of the wings and then realized that we needed to take a picture..lol
Karley Williams
PIZZA WAS GOOD . Better than your regular chain pizza. is it authentic up north pizza ? Close but not quite . I originally wanted to do delivery BUT I was told the store uses doordash drivers I don’t trust them so I picked it up but they do add a handy void sticker which put me at ease everything was HOT . Reasonable price ( not pictured but I also got $10 pepperoni daily special ) 38.00 for everything ( 2 two medium pizza , drink , chips or cookie and super slice *two slices* ) will definitely be back . Also had beef pepperoni for the none porkers & complimentary garlic , red pepper and parm cheese which is always a plus
… moreSteffen Robitzsch
Absolutely some of the best Pizza in town. Very good and was not expecting this. Very clean resteraunt and friendly staff. The combo is the best lunch for pizza I’ve had in a while.
Thicker slices. 1/4 of a pie is equal to a single slice then cut in half for two individual slices.
… moreThicker slices. 1/4 of a pie is equal to a single slice then cut in half for two individual slices.
Ne’kea
I’m not going to lie, I h8ed my pizza. ☹️
They do offer a pretty cool deal with a slice of pizza, drink & cookie or chips for $10 you can’t beat that.
I ended up not finishing it.
I also didn’t like the fact that they didn’t have “slices “ & u had to choose from what was in the case.
I had the cheese pizza & the Charlie or something- both were “ok”
Ehh, I don’t foresee myself ever returning honestly.
… moreThey do offer a pretty cool deal with a slice of pizza, drink & cookie or chips for $10 you can’t beat that.
I ended up not finishing it.
I also didn’t like the fact that they didn’t have “slices “ & u had to choose from what was in the case.
I had the cheese pizza & the Charlie or something- both were “ok”
Ehh, I don’t foresee myself ever returning honestly.
Seth Hebert
Worked in the area for disaster relief last year for nearly 3 month, and I forgot to ever leave a review. But hands down, best pizza, best service. Super friendly. I never left without giving a tip or in a bad mood from the experience.
I wish they would open one in louisiana.
Everything there is amazing.
… moreI wish they would open one in louisiana.
Everything there is amazing.
Craig Turner
Our pizza was delicious. The bottom of our pizza was just as crispy as the crust. The wings were big , and delicious. Both dishes came out piping hot. Had to wait a few minutes to eat. Which was fine by us. Our service was excellent. They definitely use great quality products. Hope you like them as much as we did. Great job!!
… moreadamnerd182
First time having Salvatore’s. I’m impressed. The crust was phenomenal and the pepperonis were calling my name. I feel like you can tell a pizza is gonna be good just by looking at its color, and was not disappointed. The slices came out piping hot, so be careful you don’t burn your face off. Staff were friendly and music was on point. I got the combo, so it came with a cookie. Cookie was good, but a little dry. Next time I’ll try a cannoli.
Definitely stop in for a slice.
… moreDefinitely stop in for a slice.
Joshua Tam
Any of the negative reviews you see are from people who can’t comprehend there is a learning curve when a restaurant opens.
I was born and raised in Rochester and was instantly transported back when I took a bite of the Pepperoni Pizza today.
The wings are bigger than most places you’d find in the south as a whole, I prefer mine slightly crispier but I didn’t specify and they still tasted great.
Anyone saying it isn’t good pizza, doesn’t know good pizza is and has been in Florida too long. The staff were fantastic and attentive
This place is fantastic and I will be returning with friends, family and anyone else I can get in the door
Comment for the restaurant- the country sweet sauce seems a bit thinner than usual but the flavor is still 100%
… moreI was born and raised in Rochester and was instantly transported back when I took a bite of the Pepperoni Pizza today.
The wings are bigger than most places you’d find in the south as a whole, I prefer mine slightly crispier but I didn’t specify and they still tasted great.
Anyone saying it isn’t good pizza, doesn’t know good pizza is and has been in Florida too long. The staff were fantastic and attentive
This place is fantastic and I will be returning with friends, family and anyone else I can get in the door
Comment for the restaurant- the country sweet sauce seems a bit thinner than usual but the flavor is still 100%