Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sabatino’s – Maplewood, NJ – 513 Valley St – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-8:00 PM; Shop address is 513 Valley St, Maplewood, NJ 07040513 Valley St, Maplewood, NJ 07040; (973) 314-1531.
Sabatino’s Maplewood – Facebook
Sabatino’s Maplewood is in Maplewood, NJ. Jan 24, 2021 . . I’m all about tradition and quality Fam!! Thanks for your understanding ♥️ Let’s Go Bills …
Sabatino’s – 513 Valley St, Maplewood, NJ 07040 – Slice
Sabatino’s · House Favorites · Traditional Pizza · Italian Pan Pizza · Cauliflower Crust Pizza · Specialty Pizzas · Specialty Slice · Bites & Sides · Insalate.
Last Updates
Reviews
Jennifer Andreottola
Maplewood is lucky to have this gem and I wish I still lived there. Glad some of my family still does so we can grab a couple of pies when we visit. Sabatinos is serving up some great pizza with perfect dough/crust base and fresh and interesting flavor ideas. We look forward to trying them all!
… moreMonica Johnson
I recently went gluten-free and decided to give one of my favorite local pizza spots a try for their Cauliflower crust pizza (several others raved about it on social) and it DID NOT disappoint. Honestly, hands down, one of the absolute best Cauliflower crust pizzas that was thin crust and jam-packed with flavor. Above anything else, it truly hit in all the right places. Will definitely be purchasing again in the future.
… moreFrancisco Alves
Great place to try… The staff here are great…. Very pleasant and helpful. I enjoyed the pizza and mozzarella sticks and definitely would have them again. The garlic knots were not good they were stale and I did not enjoy them at all. I also tried the saba-roni fries…. They were good but I would say maybe the chili sauce should be on the side… My fries got super soggy from the sauce pooling at the bottom I guess some people may like that. Overall I would go again besides those 2 problems
… moreIgnacio Rosales
Sabatino is a talented chef, and the quality/taste of his pies is a testament to his skills. He greatly cares about the customer experience – ingredients quality, service, and taste are all considered. Sabatino’s is the place to go for the best pizza around – basta cosi!
… moreChuck Mound
This came up as a highly rated Pizzeria so I figured I would give it a go for the Pizza Hunters App. Parking is tough. You have to find a spot on a very busy street that has many trucks coming through at a high rate of speed. The service was excellent and the inside and outdoor areas were good to grab a slice and eat. The slice itself was not very good. The cheese was very chewy and no sauce. The slice in the bag was very greasy and it changed form in 5 min. 2 pie Yas.. Will give them another try at some point.
… moreNatasha Rivera
This is the first place I’ve ever seen a Chicken Alfredo slice. And it did not disappoint. The plain slices were delicious. And the pepperoni sausage slice was great. It had a slight spice which made it stand out from other places I’ve had that from. I think maybe they use hot Italian sausage? Want to go back to try more of their food. This being the first time here I would definitely go back again.
… moreRobert Fagan
Solid slice. Great neighborhood pizza if you live in the area. Nice thin slice with a great taste. No need to add any seasoning. Only critique is that it is super greasy. My plain slice had enough oil/grease on the plate, you’d think I had a pepperoni slice. However, that’s not deterring me from going back for more pizza. 7.7 out of 10.
… moreAl Mulk
I usually don’t write bad reviews, but I feel like I have to this time because it’s a serious safety issue. The person making the pizzas went to the bathroom and came right back to roll the dough and make pizzas without washing his hands. You could clearly see his hands were dry when he came out, and he immediately started handling food again. Maybe it was a busy day, but that’s not an excuse when it comes to hygiene. On top of that, the staff were rude and unprofessional. I’m really disappointed food safety should always come first
… moreErik Maiwaldt
Fries on pizza ?!?!?!?!? Never seen that before, not a fan. Margarita slice was amazing , just wish it was a little crispier. Great flavor though 7.6 pizza.
… moreVictoria Jenkins
DONT EAT HERE! I ATE/ CHEWED A LONG PIECE OF HAIR! I then called and complained and the guy tonight 12/10/23 at 7:07 told me: no one has 16” blond hair there. I said wow. I’m a black woman with 8” hair at the longest! I even suggest that I’ll take another pizza or a refund and he said there’s nothing he can do for me. This is the First time ordering from here . So I first called 5:54 to see if since it’s Sunday, they were still accepting orders. They said yes so I ordered from door dash. I got a personal size pizza with sausage for 33 bucks before Door dash charges including delivery and too it was 20 bucks. Horrible experience and I will upload pictures of me and the hair! Customer service and product 0 out of 10! I took one with it sprea out and one bunched up where it had more of a red tint at that point.
… more