Shakti Tripathy
Ordered 2 large pizzas and they were nice. First time I have experienced cheese filled Pizzas. We were there during afternoon so it was almost empty but the music was good. Seating capacity both inside and outside was enough for a large gathering. Wait time was about 15 minutes as was told before hand. I felt pizza options were not much and toppings were not enough. On a Chicken pizza, we struggled to find a piece of the same. Other toppings were also not much visible. The taste though was good and I think that was due to the cheese. They also have a bar attached and a gelato section with limited options. Overall it was not bad but more toppings would have made the experience better.
… moreMichael Bruce
It’s a chain, but still a food place for pizza while you’re at the beach. Some good speciality selections, but can choose your own toppings if you prefer. Crust is a little thicker than a lot of places and has good chew. Large dining room at it stays busy during beach season. Even so the staff is efficient. A good choice for pizza at the beach.
… moreJudy Scurlock
On vacation and this place is across from hotel. Overall rating on google was a 4.1. But we feel it deserves a higher rating. We really enjoyed our pizza. We ordered pepperoni with green peppers. We love trying pizza joints and this rates a 9 out of 10. The tomato sauce was good and the crust was well cooked through out not soggy. Only wished it had more green pepper on it. The waitress was very friendly and attentive, however when we went to pay the check it took her 10 minutes to return. She was swamped with orders coming out of the kitchen. We don’t get upset that easily. All good. A busy restaurant is a good restaurant.
… moreKatana Motors
That was a nice cheat day. I am going to have to run 20 miles to get all this food out of my system. You can never go wrong with Pizza, specially the Maui Wowi Jumbo Pizza and 16 piece chicken wings. Nice one!
… moreCheryl
My family went around 6:00 p.m. on a Saturday. We were immediately seated. Luke was our server and he was very attentive, though it seemed the others were as well. There was a long line for those picking up their orders. Food was great and came out relatively fast. It was a nice change from the seafood we ate most of the week.
… moreSteven and Shelly
First visit to Rotolo Pizzeria was fantastic! Our server, Jamie, recommended the lasagna and she was spot on—it was incredible. We’re already planning our next trip back to try the calzones. Also, a huge Happy 30th Anniversary to the Rotolo Pizzeria! Great food and service.
… moreKevin B
Really great experience here tonight. We started out with the Parmesan knots for the table. Crisp on the outside but fluffy on the inside. Everyone enjoyed their dinner tonight. My husband got a pizza with gluten free crust and it did not taste gluten free at all. It was delicious. I had a salad and our son had the butter noodles. Both were tasty. The Philly cheesesteak sandwich was really yummy. I would highly recommend this place for a nice casual meal.
… moreMary Alice Murphy
Lunch on a weekday.
Party of 4 ages 6-72.
18″ Pizza: plenty of pepperoni. Crust was good. Cooked perfectly. Good flavor. Needed more marinara.
Lasanga: 7 out of 10. Good flavor. Could use more sauce. A bit of a kick sometimes from the cut up meatballs. Noodles on edge dried out. Maybe it was an edge piece from the pan.
Meatball sub: 4 out of 5. Nice size roll – not oversized. Plenty of meatballs. They were cut in half, making it more manageable to eat. Could use more sauce. Good flavor throughout.
Atmosphere: TVs around the room were showing sports programs. Bar in the corner of the room. Nice atmosphere.
Staff: Friendly, patient, attentive.
… morewes wilkins
Came for dinner, party of four; there was no wait. Nice greeting from the hostess. Server over promptly and got appetizer and drink orders. Out pretty quickly and then dinner orders taken. Server made a mistake and had kitchen make a “garden alfredo” pizza instead of the “chicken alfredo” – he apologized and made it right. All in all pretty good pizza, nice thin crust.
… moreThomas Morton
Our waitress was very friendly and attentive. We had to leave early and get our food to go, but she made sure we were taken care of. The pizza and cheese sticks were amazing. I haven’t had pizza this good in a long time. Awesome job by everyone.
… more