Loren Oyer
Terrific! Gave my mom and I two FREE cannolis since we’d never been there! I had the pumpkin filled and wow! Delicious. The Little Italy sandwich was so good as was everything else we had. Can’t wait to come back. Tiramisu! Reuben! Prosciutto oh my! The potato salad was light but creamy. Everything was so fresh and delicious.
… moreJeremy Clark
Excellent customer service!
We have passed by several times and discussed stopping in. Today, we glanced at the menu and found they focus on Gluten Free items!
My GF has a soy and gluten allergy and she rated this place as amazing. She had a Ruben on GF bread and she loved it. She went on how she rated this the best Ruben she has had, even when she could have regular bread.
I chose the turkey, honey turkey and chicken sub. I planned to only ear half but the sub was so amazing, I ended up eating both. Every bite was delicious!
From the moment we walked in to the moment we left, we had great customer service. When you walk in, you can order online for faster service or wait till the owner was free with building orders for others. We chose to order online so ensure allergy info was noted. The subscription were made in a timely manner with the owner checking in on us frequently on us. The subs were had delivered to our seats. While we were talking, we mentioned that it was our first time in and the owner share a little with us about his place and without asking, offered a cannoli for me to try. It was also delicious!
We live 35 minutes away and for us, it would be worth the drive down from Columbus just for these subs. They only use Boar’s Head products.
I cannot wait to go back again.
… moreKathy Kincaid
Stop thru on our way south for work. Richie himself is amazing and wonderful person. His sandwiches are so good! Super fresh and super tasty! Reasonable prices for the amount of meat you get on your sub! OMG the cannolis are absolutely delectable. Crispy shells, super creamy And smooth filling. Not super sweet or bland. I’d love to return. If you’re on your way thru circleville you must stop here. One note, need to park on the main street, the parking lot belongs to the spa and other place and they have signs posted to not park there. Don’t park there because you’ll be asked to move. Even if you are picking just picking up. Stop you. You will not be disappointed!!!
… moreGeri repass
We were in town driving threw and just randomly chose this place. So glad we did. I got a gf sandwich that was amazing my bf got the meatball sub. Definitely worth it to make a pit stop. Owner was very friendly. NY style food and accent lol
… moreJo Jo
Love love love found my new deli !!
Stopped in here for the first time and after the first bite fell in love ❤️ the guy who took our order was great and knew his stuff also love that you can make your own sandwiches they have tons of options and sides,
best part to top it off is they also sell Jeni’s ice cream
Will definitely be back.
… moreChuck
Very clean. Fast service. Quiet. I just had to come back and update this review. I got the Supreme which is a roast beef sub with sliced red onions horseradish and fresh mozzarella. For the record, me personally. This is the first sub shop I have been to that actually use real sliced mozzarella cheese. One of the best subs I have ever had! If your ever in Circleville Ohio. You absolutely have to stop and get a sub. It will be one of the best decisions you’ll ever make!
… morenoah martin
First time eating here and I’m absolutely disappointed I drove by so many times and ate at jersey mikes or jimmy johns. Richie’s blows those places out of the water. Richie was shocked when he heard me and my family had never tried cannolis and brought us out some fresh ones on him and my goodness they were delicious. All around great food and service highly recommend
… moreRochelle Stapp
Very Celiac friendly! This place came highly recommended and it’s no surprise why. They were very knowledgeable about gluten free foods but the staff knew everyone which was such a fun experience.
… moreJeff Davis
I stopped in for my first time today on my way to deer camp. The food was awesome, I ordered the poultry explosion. Made to order, fresh food. I loved the hometown feel with the “regulars” coming in for lunch. I will be stopping everytime I pass through Circleville.
… moreÆyrton A
Wow.. unique New York gem in an Ohio farm community. Absolute, fantastic service. The vernacular, pace and tempo of service staff transports you to Manhatten. Staff is quick with suggestions and recommendations, and they are spot on to enhance your food selection. The Prosciutto with fresh mozz was perfect. I will stop again when my travels bring me back through.
… more