Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hand-made in Milwaukee for since 1956, with a recipe that has never changed, Reynold’s Authentic Northern Pasties are freshly made in our Pasty shop on Burleigh Street. Stop by to get them Fresh N’ Hot, Par-baked, Frozen, or by the Dozen, with your choice of delicious Add-Ons like Hot Cheese, Beef Gravy, or Jalapeños. Pasties were a staple of the southwest England diet that came to Wisconsin when Cornish workers migrated here. They were in search of mining jobs in the 1830s. The pasties would stay warm in their lunch pails and satisfy the hearty workers’ appetite. Reynold’s Pasties are reasonably-priced, and much like their original appeal, they are still portable and filling. That’s why they’re known as a meal in itself.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3525 W Burleigh St, Milwaukee, WI 53210
Phone: (414) 444-4490
Website: https://www.reynoldspasties.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reynold’s Pasty Shop – Milwaukee, Wisconsin – Reynold’s Northern …
Reynold’s Authentic Northern Pasties are freshly made in our Pasty shop on Burleigh Street. Stop by to get them Fresh N’ Hot, Par-baked, Frozen, or by the …
Anyone know what happened to Reynolds Pasty shop? I need some …
Reynolds Pasty Shop 3525 W Burleigh St, Milwaukee, WI 53210 · No photo description available. Kristin Riemersma and 5 others.
Reynold’s Pasty shop closing?? : r/milwaukee – Reddit
I mean no offense to Reynold’s pasties, but they were not a great pasty. I was thrilled to hear mke had a pasty shop when I arrived, but I’m …
Reviews
Robert Penner
Delicious and so sad they are temporarily closed. Inshallah they will open again soon. I always get my hopes up when I drive past on Burleigh. The pasty with sour cream, jalapeños, and ketchup is my usual order and I LOVE shooting the breeze with whoever is at the counter. Nicest folks ever.
… moreFrannie Riedijk-Dean
This has been one of my favorite places to eat when visiting Milwaukee. The fresh savory ingredients in the perfect pastry. Great service fast and friendly. I have enjoyed eating pasties for at least 50 years. I had to buy a bunch taking some back to Georgia. Yum.
… moreErik Smith
The UP of Michigan is known as the home of the Pasty. I’ve had several while visiting up there, all good. Reynold’s brings that flavor, quality and tradition to Milwaukee. I only wish I had found this place sooner! I was in and out in about 4 min with a hot Pasty that was more than enough for lunch! Highly recommend Reynold’s!
… moreJames Guse
Excellent. Know this the Hot-N-Fresh is very hot and real fresh. The pastry outer reminded me of pot pies of years long ago. We had beef gravy and sour cream. Sour cream was best but close 2nd was gravy. Some people park right on the street outside, we have a fat rear end so we squeezed into parking lot across the street. I hope we have time to stop in again before we leave.
… moreNoah “Mr. BERRY” Saulsberry
Haven’t had a pastry since 2008 when I moved to the south. The only place I wanted food from when I got here for a visit. Glad to see they haven’t lost a step. It was worth the 900 miles.
… morelarry Green
I always look forward to the delicious pasties there, sorry the are temporary closed!
… moreBeth Saltzman
The best pasties, great value and outstanding service. No dine in.
… morePrince of Life
This has to be the best restaurant in all of Milwaukee. The foods are so amazing it taste fantastic as paradise. Cone here and eat so you get the most heavenly services.
… moreDean Calin
So, I went to Reynolds Pasty Shop today. The pasty was very good. The woman at the sales counter was very friendly and well spoken. (“It amazes me that this business has been around for over fifty years only selling ONE product!”) The price was very fair. The slice of pecan pie that I bought with the pasty was also very tasty and fairly priced. My two challenges with this food experiment were, 1.) Location. It was 40 minutes from my house and there was really nothing nearby to enhance the visit. 2.) Walk-up business only. For me, going out for food is not just the consumable, but the total dining experience. Because it is located so far from home I had to enjoy the food in the Woodman’s parking lot or the pasty would have grown cold enough to have to reheat, defeating the purpose of going to the destination. If you happen to be in the neighborhood of 35th and Burleigh, you should absolutely stop in to experience their great pasties. They are savory and quite filling!
… morelarisa anderson
This place is amazing. Growing up my next door neighbor was from Superior Wisconsin and she has been making Pasties all her life and I remember they were delicious. These Pasties tasted Just Like Her Homemade. Flaky crust. Lots of meat and onions. They are reasonably priced. Great quick service and very nice people there. Very friendly and sweet. Try them with cheese sauce and sour cream. Me and my husband will be back soon.
… more