Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 37 NY-25A, Mt Sinai, NY 11766
Phone: (631) 473-8234
Website: http://renzospizzamtsinaili.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Renzo’s Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant Mt. Sinai
Renzo’s Pizzeria & Restaurant serving the finest pizza and Italian food in Mt.Sinai Long Island. Offering our freshest food and desserts for Dine-In, …
Renzo’s Restaurant & Pizzeria – 37 Route 25A, Mt Sinai, NY 11766
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Mt Sinai, NY! Renzo’s Restaurant & Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Renzo’s Pizza and Restaurant (@renzosmtsinai) · Mount Sinai, NY
Home of the pasta bread bowls 37 Route 25A, Mt. Sinai NY 11766 631.473.8234 · Friday nights aren’t just made for pizza If you want more than · Photo by …
Reviews
Wayne C
Visited Renzos today in Mount Sinai. Wow! Appears like any other pizzaria from the parking lot, but do yourself a favor, go in and have a meal. We ordered the Pasta Flight (what a great idea…samples of three pasta meals served in their own bowl on a charcuterie board) and a Bread Bowl of Spaghetti and sausage (traded out the meatballs). Sausage added a whole other layer of flavor. Meals were really tasty, affordable, and more than enough for one person. Enjoy!
… moreChristopher Ciminelli
Ate dinner here for the first time. Perfect spot to get pizza takeout or sit down and eat in the back part of the restaurant which is a beautiful room. The ambiance is perfect and I loved the decor. Had the shrimp alla renzo, apple walnut salad, and a side of spicy rigatoni alla vodka. All were exceptional! Huge portions and cooked to perfection. They also give you a bread basket and a couple garlic knots to start. Split a tiramisu for dessert and it was delicious, a different twist on classic tiramisu but so good! Ophelia our waitress was great and she was always very attentive. Definitely would recommend and can’t wait to come back.
… moreJeffrey Diamond
This is the best chicken roll I’ve ever had plus there vodka slices are top notch , and customer service is one of kind – these men really care and take pride in there pizza
… moreR F
Good pizza with a perfect crispy bottom, good service, friendly workers. Has a nice dim light resturaunt in the back.
… morePb Jelly
Omg the food was absolutely delicious!! The desserts were homemade and incredible!!! This is the only pizza place I will go to by my job. I will even order food and drive it 35 mins to my house after work and it’s still hot!!!
… moreBrandon Bernard
One of the best onions and sausage cheese pizzas and ham and cheese calzone I’ve ever had in a LONG TIME! Garrett was more than accommodating and even the nice young lady ordered from since was my first time ordering from there had patience to answer my questions and I didn’t feel rushed or were trying to “hurry me up” lol… Wish I’ve been ordering from here for years instead other spots in area that just got more expensive and now use less inferior ingredients, truly one of the best spots I’ve been to and looking forward to trying their entrees and salads in the future!
… moreEric Brodman
Trash pizza. Regular pie ordered for delivery. Cheese stuck to the box. No table in box. Amateur hour. Impossible to find a decent pizza spot in port Jeff. Moved from rocky point. Never had an issue. Charged $46.
… moreNick Schiano
Had a great meal last night. Regular and Sicilian pie. Wife ordered the chocolate peanutbutter cake which she loved. After we ordered i watched the chef make a chicken roll that was 3x bigger than I have ever seen anywhere else. Will be back for 1 of those real soon.
… moreTiki B
Normally I check the reviews before eating somewhere new but I was too hungry this time lol. Normally you don’t see a sign out with the new & in with the old thought it was interesting but didn’t think to much of it. Everyone was extremely nice and friendly. I loved the pizza and the wings. I’m extremely picky about pizza but I’m glad I tried here today it’s definitely a go to spot for me. I never experienced the previous owner but the current owner and crew were wonderful.
… moreEmily Klein
First and foremost, I wanted to say how amazing not only was our meal but the next day it tasted that much better!! We ordered two penne ala vodka’s with chicken cutlet bread bowls, and they did not disappoint!! It was everything you could imagine and more the flavor was delicious and I was blown away at how everything tasted! We also ordered more penne ala vodka, fried zucchini sticks which were bomb, pizza slices and cake pops. 100 stars from us! The owners were so kind and it was a pleasure dealing with this establishment!
… more