Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Welcome to Real New York Pizza, where we bring authentic New York-style pizza to Orlando! Located at 11199 S Orange Blossom Trail, our menu features a variety of delicious pizzas, calzones, and Italian specialties made from fresh ingredients. Enjoy our convenient delivery service up to 5 miles or choose pickup for a quick bite. With a friendly atmosphere and a commitment to quality, we’re dedicated to providing a taste of New York right in your neighborhood. Order directly from our website and support local!
Pizzas, calzones, subs, wings & more offered in a straightforward setting.
Hours
| Sunday | 2–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 11199 S Orange Blossom Trl, Orlando, FL 32837
Phone: (407) 856-9662
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Real New York Pizza (Orlando): Home
Online ordering menu for Real New York Pizza (Orlando).
Real New York Pizza – Orlando, FL – 11199 S Orange Blossom Trl …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Real New York Pizza in Orlando, FL. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Real New York Pizza ORL | Orlando FL – Facebook
Real New York Pizza ORL, Orlando. 312 likes · 119 were here. The Best Pizza in Orlando.
Reviews
Pete
Okay is the New Yorker myself you always search the city for something that reminds you of home. This of course is easier said than done because a lot of your favorite pizza shops that open up in about 2 years end up with different ownership and a downgrading quality while they uptick the price.
Is this top tier New York style pizza? No. For that I recommend Papa Ds over in Dr Phillips. But is it still good pizza for your local neighborhood that is better than Papa John’s or Pizza Hut, absolutely.
I got the comically large jumbo xl pepperoni and the garlic knots this is a massive pizza, you can see by the picture what I’m talking about. It was good, I will warn you because the slices are so big you do lose a lot of that crispiness of the crust. The garlic knots were terrible though, the only flavor you got was from the limited garlic butter on top, but the bread itself had no flavor, none. They also upcharge for dipping sauce on the garlic knots which is not common in proper pizzerias.
When you call over the phone they’re going to say it’s ready in 15 minutes, the reality is more like 30, the location is terrible, it’s an absolutely filthy gas station lot, it’s not well taken care of, but hey sometimes the best food is not in the prettiest of places. But I do recommend it over the chain pizzerias in the area. And it’s nice to see that it’s been there for a very long time.
… moreIs this top tier New York style pizza? No. For that I recommend Papa Ds over in Dr Phillips. But is it still good pizza for your local neighborhood that is better than Papa John’s or Pizza Hut, absolutely.
I got the comically large jumbo xl pepperoni and the garlic knots this is a massive pizza, you can see by the picture what I’m talking about. It was good, I will warn you because the slices are so big you do lose a lot of that crispiness of the crust. The garlic knots were terrible though, the only flavor you got was from the limited garlic butter on top, but the bread itself had no flavor, none. They also upcharge for dipping sauce on the garlic knots which is not common in proper pizzerias.
When you call over the phone they’re going to say it’s ready in 15 minutes, the reality is more like 30, the location is terrible, it’s an absolutely filthy gas station lot, it’s not well taken care of, but hey sometimes the best food is not in the prettiest of places. But I do recommend it over the chain pizzerias in the area. And it’s nice to see that it’s been there for a very long time.
Kim Julian
We love ordering their x large pizza! Feeds the whole family and there’s snacks for the next day. The sauce is delicious. Even my picky one loves it. 🙂
… moreThe Taterman731
I delivered down the street and wanted to try this place out. It was easy to get a bobtail in the parking lot. The food was really good, the people were nice and friendly. I also got to try something I’ve never tried before, it called “cachapa” it was good and cool to get to try since I’ve never heard of it before. The pizza was freshly made in front of me, nice and hot out of the oven. This is a good place to grab a pizza and take home since there is limmited seating but over all it was a good experience and I’ll be comming back again. I would recommend it.
… morePeter Schreiber
I ordered the 18 inch new York style pizza, OMG this is the best pizza I ever had since I moved here to Florida from New York it made me cry. Thank you you guys are awesome. If I could give back thousand stars I would. I will buy a lot more, you have a customer for life. I’m a chef you guys are awesome.
… moreOmar Cruz
I frequent Real New York Pizza at least once a week. I love this place and feel right at home here. The owner and staff are super friendly. I always order their gigantic 28″ Extra Jumbo Sized Pizza. The quality and taste is just like back in NY.
… morealex muniz
I finally found a place in Orlando that i love as much as the gems i find on outta town trips. This pizza is awesome and ranks on my top 5 pizza places for sure. This is now my go to pizza in Orlando
… moreTaylor Adams
the wings are so dry no flavor at all kinda gross. the pizza was ok ish it was good definitely not new York pizza only thing new York about the pizza is the size
… moreEfrain Cuadrado
The worse customer service I have ever had. I ordered two 28 inch pepperoni pizza. Got home they were both cheese. I live 45 mins away in poinciana but because my first time eating there the food was good I figured I would drive almost 2 hours round trip for the pizza. I called them and they just kept saying you were only charged for cheese over and over again. I told them I understand what you charged me for but that’s not what I ordered. I have no issue with the money but the fact that I was very clear on what I ordered cause I repeated myself 3 times cause they kept asking cheese too? And I said yes pepperoni and cheese. They didnt even give me a receipt. And they refused to fix order or give refund. Very rude will never go back. Also tried calling back and they kept hanging up on me 5 times in a row
… moreDavid “Pengwin God” Haenggi
The first time I ate at Real New York Pizza the food was absolutely fantastic, I raved to all my freinds. The last time 3 weeks ago. The cheese super salty, was kinda disappointing
… moreJ R
RUN! DON’T WALK! This place is LEGIT! Born in Brooklyn and raised in NJ…I KNOW MY PIZZA! This place left me speechless! Thank you,Mr. Giovanni! We will be back! ✨️
… more