Address and Contact Information
Address: 734 NY-25A, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733
Phone: (631) 941-4200
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Pumpernickles Deli & Market: Home
Contact Form. Pumpernickles Deli & Market. Cuisines. American. 734 NEW YORK 25A SETAUKET, NY 11733 · (631) 941-4200. Business Hours. Mon – Fri: 8:00 AM – 4:00 …
SETAUKET, NY 11733 (Menu & Order Online)
Online ordering menu for Pumpernickles Deli & Market.
Pumpernickles Deli and Market – East Setauket – Seamless
Order with Seamless to support your local restaurants! View menu and reviews for Pumpernickles Deli and Market in Setauket- East Setauket, plus popular …
Reviews
Samantha Haley
I love coming here. I work in Port Jeff and it’s a decent drive to go in the middle of work to pick up lunch. I ended up picking up a larger order than I normally do this week and a sandwich was forgotten. I called and they said there was nothing they could do. However, they quickly called me back saying they do not deliver, but they went out of their way to come drop off the missing sandwich. It was extremely appreciated. We don’t see good service and good people often, but this place had excellent service. I truly appreciated the delivery. – A very satisfied and appreciative healthcare worker!
… moreJ. Apollo
What a delightful little local deli! We were visiting from out of town and filled up on all types of New York staples – Drake’s cakes, Wise potato chips, pumpernickel bread, all the staples that make New York iconic for certain foods. The staff was very helpful and it was overall a great experience
… moreJohn Corbett
This place is like REALLY REALLY like hitting the JACKPOT of food and service, from the staff, the food, prices and I could just go on and on. I have them do all of my catering that I send up to the State Veterans Home, where my brother resides. The choices here are endless and when I tell you that the staffing is FANTASTIC, I absolutely mean it. How lucky am I to have found this place
… moreAlison Weidner
Ordered a chicken sandwich from DoorDash I got zero condiments….just Kaiser roll with chicken on it no condiments nothing in the bag. when I called. I was told that I needed to order that through DoorDash. There’s no option on the DoorDash menu that says mayo and all it says is extra lettuce extra whatever. (See screenshot) … The chicken itself was pretty good roll so that’s why I even gave any stars but with zero condiments, I didn’t enjoy my $10 sandwich … I would suggest updating the website or adding condiments on the side in the bag…
… moreErnst Georges
This a great amazing spot to grab something to eat on the go. But today as I had meeting with real estate investors friends who were stock on an heavy traffic due to construction on 495 Long Island expressway. I stop this Amazing Delicatessen store for a authentic coffee. The service is so amazing and I change my mind to order a hero eggs sandwich with jalapeños sauté onion toasted with butter.. The sandwich taste wow amazing… I enjoy this delightful mean and wait for my friend patiently… I highly recommend this place.. P.S: I love the country architecture style of building… As well…
… moreLisa Lichelle
⚡Lisa – 10⭐Best deli cases• packed superbly • all excellent quality food • Absolutely the Bestest I have ever seen in my life✨ Bravo Bravo And BRAVO ✨
… moreHeather R
Pumpernickels Deli is an absolute gem—a small, cute spot that’s impressively clean with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The staff, mostly younger folks, are delightful, efficient, and incredibly organized. They’re also so sweet when answering questions, making the experience feel personal and inviting.
On this visit, I ordered a simple bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich, and it was perfect. Sometimes it’s the basics that say the most, and Pumpernickels delivered. I’m also seriously considering trying their catering next because everything I saw looked so fresh, delicious, and thoughtfully prepared.
This place easily outshines Bagel Express down the street. If you’re in the area, I highly recommend stopping by—you won’t be disappointed!
… moreOn this visit, I ordered a simple bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich, and it was perfect. Sometimes it’s the basics that say the most, and Pumpernickels delivered. I’m also seriously considering trying their catering next because everything I saw looked so fresh, delicious, and thoughtfully prepared.
This place easily outshines Bagel Express down the street. If you’re in the area, I highly recommend stopping by—you won’t be disappointed!
Carolyn Levey
Thank you Tina for the outstanding service for our catered event! The sandwich platters were a hit!! We will be sure to used them again!! Thank you!!
… moreErmias O Franco
The chicken cutlet overload is one my favorite sandwich if you haven’t try it yet go try it u would love it!! Amazing staff super friendly
… moreLuke Figliozzi
Delicious food. Very clean. Chicken cutlets are absolutely phenomenal. I don’t eat mac and cheese anywhere else but when I come to this deli I always get some and it is amazing as well. Can’t say good enough things about this place.
… more