Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Stalwart pizza parlor serving whole pies & specialty slices along with wings, subs & calzones.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 141 S Keystone Ave, Sayre, PA 18840
Phone: (570) 888-6659
Website: http://www.pudgiespizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Sayre – Pudgies Pizza
Pudgies Sayre. 141 S Keystone Ave Sayre, PA 18840. Working Hours. Sun-Sat: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM. Order Online. Call Us Now. 570-888-6659 …
Pudgies Pizza – Southern Tier’s King of Pizzas Since 1963
Pennsylvania (PA) State. 1164 S. Main Street, Mansfield, PA 16933 · 141 S Keystone Ave, Sayre, PA 18840. What Our Customers Say. Leave a Review. “LOVE Pudgie’s …
Pudgie’s Pizza Sayre | Sayre PA – Facebook
Pudgie’s Pizza Sayre, Sayre. 1403 likes · 11 talking about this · 139 were here. Pudgie’s Pizza, Pasta, and Subs.
Reviews
Lauren Jones
Placed a pickup order for a small pizza and garlic sticks. had to wait an extra 10 minutes, and I was given a personal pizza with mozzarella sticks. not what I ordered. when I asked about the garlic sticks I was told I’d have to wait 5 more minutes. waited 15 more minutes before asking about them again, and was told to again wait 3-4 more minutes. I never used to have a problem at this location, but they screwed up my entire order this time and was never even given a “sorry”.
… moreShelly Hostetler
Who else would be ‘fried’ for paying $20 for a piece of burnt fish?! These photos are what I’m going to *try* to eat, later. The worst of it had already gone into the garbage. The shift manager, Trevor, didn’t say a WORD, not anything even approaching an apology when he put this excuse of a fish-fry in front of me. Utterly *insulting!*
Before this, the manager (Trevor again) was going to charge my sister $2.50 for water. I thought it must surely have been a mistake! I explained she was getting water, not a fountain drink; to which he replied, “Yes, I know. But my boss told me I have to start charging for cups.” Unbe-flippin-lievable!!
So! If you’re “Okay” w/ shelling out $20 precious dollars, to be insulted w/ burnt, dried-out fish and be charged $2.50 for a STINKIN’ CUP, Pudgies of Sayre, PA is the place for you!!
… moreBefore this, the manager (Trevor again) was going to charge my sister $2.50 for water. I thought it must surely have been a mistake! I explained she was getting water, not a fountain drink; to which he replied, “Yes, I know. But my boss told me I have to start charging for cups.” Unbe-flippin-lievable!!
So! If you’re “Okay” w/ shelling out $20 precious dollars, to be insulted w/ burnt, dried-out fish and be charged $2.50 for a STINKIN’ CUP, Pudgies of Sayre, PA is the place for you!!
DCOM 20
I was in the Valley and walked in. Brand new customer. I am now saying that this is the best pizza anywhere. I bought one slice. Perfect. It is impossible to have a better slice than what I bought. Great restaurant. Will try the other Pudgie locations also. Update: went back. Still excellent.
… moreShannon B
The dough was good , however there was very little cheese almost like not having any and same goes for the sauce. The service was very friendly and restaurant was peaceful and relaxing.
… moreGordo Alexander
Stromboli was under cooked inside and almost burnt outside, asked for a different slice than was given as well. Asked for marinara sauce and the helper walked off. Ended up with poor service and feeling sick.
… moreAdam
Tried to order a salad and wings. Came to $55 bucks. That’s insane pricing for a pizza place
… moreSean Sims
Good, I like the sauce. My topping were pepperoni with onions. Prefer slivered though. Overall I think you would be satisfied with the overall quality of the pizza.
… moreJt Ryan
Good pizza, including a gluten free pizza option with rice flower crust. Pretty good food, though the upcharge for gluten free is fairly high for the size. That said, it is very good. Mostly a take out place.
… moreMaryAnne Sadecki
Stopped in for a couple of slices of pizza and all of the ones they had to choose from were all over done with hard dark crust.
… moreJoshua Stout
This is our favorite pizza place in town. Once a week we stop in to get some slices for the kids and every time the people and manager are amazing. I feel like it’s rare to find good customer service but this place doesn’t have just one good employee, every single one of them are great! Good work.
… more