Amanda Beeler
We’ve now been to P’s Pizza House twice, and it definitely lives up to the hype!
This time around, the burger was absolutely fantastic. Nice and juicy, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The pizza and flatbread were also incredibly tasty, with fresh ingredients and great flavor combinations. I had thr clice of the day which was Buffalo chicken and it was really fresh with great flavor. It’s one of those menus where everyone at the table can find something they’ll love.
The atmosphere is a huge plus. It strikes a really nice balance. Totally family-friendly, but also a great spot for a casual date night. It doesn’t feel too loud or chaotic, yet still has a fun, lively vibe.
We went on a Saturday afternoon and didn’t have to wait at all, even though they were pretty busy, which was impressive. It’s also easy to find with convenient access. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive.
Overall, it’s consistently a great spot, and we’ll definitely be back again!
… moreAshley Prince
I don’t typically write reviews, but this had to be one of the most disappointing experiences I’ve had in Sioux City. We were sat very quickly, however our waitress took forever to first visit our table. Was told the ice machine wasn’t working so were served lukewarm water. Put in appetizers during happy hour but waitress did not ring it up until after 6:03pm so it was charged full price. All of our food came out 15 minutes later than a table who came in and ordered later than us. Crab dip was good and hot, but tasted like fishy tuna and was THE greasiest! Wings came out cold and dry. My son enjoyed the chicken alfredo however my Greek chicken salad was the worst combination of flavors. Nothing about it was Greek except feta cheese. We were served no silverware and our waitress was in no rush to gather them for us. She finally came out with dripping wet silverware with paper napkins stuck to them. Assuming silverware still needed to be rolled, we watched 3 servers stand around and stare at the filled dining area, no pre-bussing, no hustle, just pure lazy vibes. So disappointed in the $85 visit for 3 people.
… moreShelby Rae Christian
Basing review off the appetizers alone, which were fairly decent. Waitress was wonderful but hostess was less than ideal and made this experience a bit uncomfortable. The crab dip was served piping hot, it was nearly delicious but missing something. The same can be said for the smothered fries, good flavor but very dry and lackluster.
… moreRyan Stutson
Greeted by host right away. Sat on patio as requested. Nice facility, indoors and out. Ordered the Chislic for $14 which was a plentiful portion and very tastfuly flavorful, served with a sirracha dip. Also tried 18 inch stone fire cooked pepperoni and cream cheese with banana peppers. Dipped in some house made ranch…yum!!
… moreMikel Wolf
Best wings ever and the sauce was out if this world. Ceasars salad was incredible . I had a fantastic experience! The staff provided exceptional service, always attentive and friendly. The quality of the products was top-notch, making my visit truly memorable. Highly recommend!
… moreStortz Wellness Intentional Living
We had cheese curds, California veggie, margarita pizza and Greek salad. It was fine. Veggie was mostly olives. The pizza was good and everything tasted fine and service was fine slightly on the slow side but nothing was amazing. For South Dakota it’s about what I would expect. ♀️
… moreMichele L
My husband and I were traveling through Sioux Falls. This restaurant was close to our hotel. I went online to check it out and it said pick up only. I called in our order and went to pick it up. When we got there it clearly wasn’t pickup only. It was a very nice large sport bar/restaurant. We got there earlier than the pick up time so I asked if we could eat our pizza in the restaurant. The girl at the front said she had check with her manager??? Then she came back and said – you can pay now???? We wanted to go in have something to drink with our pizza. I said can’t we pay after??? She said okay and follow me. We sat down and she came and threw the pizza box on our table! I said umm can you put it on a pizza stand? She said this is what we use (a large empty tomato can that was already on the table). I then said – do you mind putting our pizza on a pan then bring it to us. She took it away then came back with it on the pizza pan. She left. Never asked what we wanted to drink. I saw someone so I tried to run over to get some water – she ducked out. Finally my husband saw the manager and ask if we could get water. She brought it over and put on table like she was doing us a favour. Never said one word to us. The service is 0/5.
The pizza is 1/5. We ordered the coal fired pizza. We wanted pepperoni, house sausage and onion. They were out of pepperoni???? We subbed meatballs. The crust wasn’t cooked through and the cheese was liquidy – gross. Like it wasn’t real cheese or not cooked! The crust was not cooked all the way through. There was zero char that you would expect from a coal fired pizza. I normally would send it back but we were totally ignored. The topping ratio was WAY off. It was completely covered in the house sausage that tasted like plain ground beef – terrible, approximately 6 – 8 slices of meatballs and maybe a 1/4 c of onions sprinkled over.
… moreMegan Scott
2025 Update: Still our favorite stop on our trip through the area! Today we had one of the coal fired pizzas. It was delicious!
We love stopping here on our way through. We’ve been here 4 times now and had exceptional service today from Beau. The Americano pizza was delicious! We had the Philly Cheesesteak our last time here and it was a great debate to get that again or to get pizza!
… moreGabriela Martin
Got the beer battered cod (lent menu) with a salad, twice on a row. IT IS THE ABSOLUTE BEST, SO Crunchy. PS KEEP THIS ALL TEAR LONG PLSSS. Also, we are regulars at Big Daddy’s Trivia (wolverines are the best team, just saying ) and we love to come here and get the Iowan on a cauliflower crust, it is so good and creamy. Plus, the server Malik was really funny and fast. Redhead is always amazing as well.
… moreSteve Bixby
Friendly staff, modern atmosphere and excellent food. Coal Fired pizzas are excellent as are the smashburgers. Look forward to trying several more menu items as well as more of the beer selections on tap.
… more