Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Always fresh, never frozen. Freshly sourced, Handmade specialties just a quick drive from Gainesville. Dough, Breads & Deserts made fresh daily. Hand crafted recipes handed down for generations from International Award Winning Master Pizzaiolos. Voted Best Pizza in Fl 2024 & 2025
Address and Contact Information
Address: 18559 NW 237th St, High Springs, FL 32643
Phone: (386) 433-1900
Website: http://www.prohibitionpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Prohibition Pizza | Handcrafted New York-Style Pizzas in High …
HIGH SPRINGS, FL, UNITED STATES, October 11, 2025 /EINPresswire.com/ — Prohibition Pizza, a family-owned restaurant known for its handcrafted New York–style …
Prohibition Pizza | High Springs FL – Facebook
Prohibition Pizza, High Springs. 3719 likes · 29 talking about this · 467 were here. Voted Best Pizza in Fl 2024 & 2025, Voted Best Lunch 2024 – Across…
Prohibition Pizza, LLC Online Ordering
18559 NW 237th St High Springs, FL Appetizers Garlic Bread… Our classic dough baked deep dish with our garlic oil and house herb ga…… $6.00
Last Updates
Reviews
Rudy Houghton
We spent Thanksgiving week with friends in Ft White, Florida. One afternoon they took us to Prohibition Pizza. It was quite a drive, but certainly worth the trip. The establishment is neet, very clean, with seating inside and out. We opted for inside which is small but serviceable. We ordered two pizzas that were incredibly delicious. I honestly wish we had a location in our area.
If you’re anywhere near them, make a point to stop in and treat your taste buds to an amazing pizza!
… moreIf you’re anywhere near them, make a point to stop in and treat your taste buds to an amazing pizza!
Crayollla
GREAT MEATBALLS BUT OKAY PIZZA
Really nice atmosphere, we came here Halloween time so the place was decorated nicely and they were playing Halloween music! Meatball dish was great. However, the pizza was not as good as expected. The cheese did not taste as well as other local pizza restaurants. Would definitely come back for the appetizers and maybe try out the desserts. But not so sure about the pizza…
… moreReally nice atmosphere, we came here Halloween time so the place was decorated nicely and they were playing Halloween music! Meatball dish was great. However, the pizza was not as good as expected. The cheese did not taste as well as other local pizza restaurants. Would definitely come back for the appetizers and maybe try out the desserts. But not so sure about the pizza…
Travis Smith
I recently had the pleasure of visiting Prohibition Pizza, and let me tell you, it’s a five-star gem in every sense. The place really leans into that Prohibition-era vibe, from the cozy, old-school decor to the whole atmosphere that makes you feel like you’ve stepped back in time.
They’ve got both indoor and outdoor seating, and the outdoor area is covered and just charming—perfect for a laid-back evening. Plus, it’s right next to the historic Priest Theater in High Springs, so you’re basically surrounded by that local charm. And if you’re in the mood for a drink, there’s a brewery right next door—so you can grab a pizza and then stroll over for a brew. Everything’s super walkable and convenient.
In short, the food was amazing, the service was top-notch, and the whole experience was just fantastic. Five stars all around!
… moreThey’ve got both indoor and outdoor seating, and the outdoor area is covered and just charming—perfect for a laid-back evening. Plus, it’s right next to the historic Priest Theater in High Springs, so you’re basically surrounded by that local charm. And if you’re in the mood for a drink, there’s a brewery right next door—so you can grab a pizza and then stroll over for a brew. Everything’s super walkable and convenient.
In short, the food was amazing, the service was top-notch, and the whole experience was just fantastic. Five stars all around!
Jimmie Crews
Looking around for Pizza places and this place popped up. It’s just little more than an hour from my home, but let me tell you it was worth the drive!! I will be going back. There’s seating in side, it’s just a little small and there’s outside seating as well. The food, service,and the atmosphere was fantastic!! The cheese bread was fluffy with a good portion of cheese on it! We got the Blind Hog Pizza, we started to add extra cheese and boy I’m glad we didn’t, there was cheese galore on it!! I’m so glad we took the drive to get them a try!! Wonderful service and AWESOME pizza!!!
… moreAdrianne Pauline
Actually in LOVE with the pizza here! I know it’s cliched but I’m going to say it; I grew up in New York and it’s hard to find genuinely good pizza down here.
Prohibition Pizza servers D E L I C I O U S pizza. It’s SO good I would honestly consider driving two and a half hours just to get said pizza.
Tried one of their specialty pizzas, The Underground, and it was fantastic. Fresh arugula to top off and a balsamic drizzle. The next day, on my way back from my camping trip, made sure to get another pizza for the way home. Built my own and still so happy with the turn out.
I swear, it’s their dough or something. I can’t stop thinking about how good it is, haha.
They have regular, large, and extra large portions. A great variety of options plus desserts as well. They’re right across a brewery too so you could order the pizza to go then grab a brewski.
… moreProhibition Pizza servers D E L I C I O U S pizza. It’s SO good I would honestly consider driving two and a half hours just to get said pizza.
Tried one of their specialty pizzas, The Underground, and it was fantastic. Fresh arugula to top off and a balsamic drizzle. The next day, on my way back from my camping trip, made sure to get another pizza for the way home. Built my own and still so happy with the turn out.
I swear, it’s their dough or something. I can’t stop thinking about how good it is, haha.
They have regular, large, and extra large portions. A great variety of options plus desserts as well. They’re right across a brewery too so you could order the pizza to go then grab a brewski.
David C
Good pizza and service! Mostly has outdoor seating though there are some indoor tables. Plenty of parking and within easy walking distance of the rest of downtown High Springs.
… morefrances astrologo
We ordered pizza to go from here. The staff were really quick and they were very friendly so we got two pizzas and also some garlic bread with marinara sauce and then I got two orders of rice crispy treats for my boys. The food was absolutely delicious. This place definitely deserves 10. Stars really great pizza. I’d recommend anybody to this Little gem
… moreStephanie Cristina
We were in the area for a group vacation and I had this place saved in my “MUST TRY” list. It certainly lived up to the hype the decor was so cool, the staff up front were so friendly (especially the guy with the beard net), and everything we ate was DELICIOUS!! I wish I didn’t actually live 5 hours away ): come to palm beach please lol me and all my friends were satisfied. Would recommend!!
… moreDaniel Wollam
Im a fat boy. Im also super picky when it comes to pizza! Fold test tells me everything I need to know about how good a pizza is going to be. This place has knocked the Old Fashion pizza out of the park! Fantastic food! Amazing atmosphere! Reasonably priced!
… moreJack Sells Autos
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
**Worth the trip from Gainesville every time!**
We made the drive out to Prohibition Pizza and it was beyond worth it. The food is incredibly fresh—you can tell they use high-quality ingredients, and the flavors are spot on. The crust was perfectly crisp, and every topping tasted like it was prepared just for us. You don’t always expect this level of quality at a pizza place, but Prohibition absolutely delivers. We’ll definitely be back again soon!
… more**Worth the trip from Gainesville every time!**
We made the drive out to Prohibition Pizza and it was beyond worth it. The food is incredibly fresh—you can tell they use high-quality ingredients, and the flavors are spot on. The crust was perfectly crisp, and every topping tasted like it was prepared just for us. You don’t always expect this level of quality at a pizza place, but Prohibition absolutely delivers. We’ll definitely be back again soon!