Scott McCallum
First time visiting Preston’s and I got their Spicy Boi Burger w/ fries. It was tasty, but nothing remarkable nor memorable. The fries were fries and the portion size was on the small side. The staff was friendly and happy to help. Overall 4 stars is generous but 3 stars would be too low. Good for a burger fix, but can’t say I need to go back anytime soon.
… moreAlec H
Tough review for first time visit. The staff is friendly, but looks to be understaffed as it did take a while for our food for what seemed to be a less-than-busy day.
Food was not what I was hoping for. $9 classic burger was a pretty thin patty without much for toppings. Veggie burger was rough. The spicy chicken sandwich was not bad. $3 side fries were pretty good but small portion. The Mac n Cheese was pretty average size and okay tasting.
Had to go ask for things that were forgotten.
Hard to want to come back, but hoping it was just a big day with the nice weather leaving the staff rushed. There is a bar next door, and the venue does have drinks and a couple outdoor tables. Parking can be tough and is tight.
… moreJoe Cox
First time there. The burgers were good, the bacon was a little under cooked. The fries were delicious. The gluten free chicken tenders and chunks were a little over cooked but good. We will go back for another taste. The mushroom burger was the best on the menu. Big, juicy and great taste.
… moreScott Tabor
Scott was extremely helpful. Food was Delicious. Mac & cheese was bomb. Highly recommend. will be back.
… moreMercury Sun
The best Burger place in Columbus Oh bar none….every ounce of this incredible burger is blessed with love and the finest fresh ingredients….There is a wait because receiving a piece of delectable art that can be eaten is worth the wait and effort…..
Highly recommended and absolutely delicious!!! Wow im coming back
… moreKristen Landry
I have to eat gluten free and this place hands down has the best GF burger bun in town. Most places it’s almost better to order without the bun because it tends to have a grainy dry texture or disinigrates before you can take a bite. I feel like I finally got to experience a burger again! The bun was soft and not at all dry. I ordered a double and it absolutely hit the spot. Beef was juicy, crispy at the edges and well seasoned. Sauce was amazing. I will definitely be back!!!
… morechantal harris
I got food to go. Burger, fries and Chicken tenders. Its a cool place. My burger was mid and my fries were super hard. They felt like and tasted like they had been re-dropped in the grease. The chicken tenders were not good to me at all. They tasted like they put Cumin in their batter. I was soo confused. Not a great flavor. Maybe my burger would have tasted better if I ate inside instead of to-go.
… moreNeil H.
Preston’s takes the time to check that the food that goes out is checked for quality. The fries are neatly served vertically in paper bags, are never greasy and have enough salt to please. We took my father-in-law there for a birthday lunch, and he commented that it reminded him of how burgers used to be in the 1950s. Preston’s is not the cheapest, but it is definitely worth the price.
… moreMatthew Anthony
This place made my whole day! I was suspicious if it was gluten free because that’s how good it was. The whole family ate for a nice price (especially for gluten free). I couldn’t stop eating if I tried. The hotdog was so thick and juicy just the way I like it and the chicken was perfectly crafted with honey for extra flavor. It certainly made up for a terrible morning experience at the Good Cafe. Will definitely be coming back!
… moreCathleen BP
We ordered two burgers, a coney dog, and cheese fries. Everything came out hot and fresh. The burgers were perfectly cooked. I don’t know if they make their own pickles buts they were fantastic. The fries were crisp even with the cheese sauce. My husband had the coney dog and said it was the best he ever had. Our server, Scott, was attentive and very friendly. We had a great experience and are looking forward to going back.
… more