P&P New York Style Pizza (Willoughby and Eastlake)

  4.2 – 25 reviews   • Pizza restaurant

✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out P&P New York Style Pizza (Willoughby and Eastlake) 44094

Address and Contact Information

Address: 36944 Vine St, Willoughby, OH 44094

Phone: (440) 571-4020

Website: http://www.swingneat.com/

Menu Photos

swingneat.com

Related Web Results

P & P’s Pizzeria – Willoughby, OH – 36944 Vine St – Hours, Menu …

View the menu, hours, address, and photos for P & P’s Pizzeria in Willoughby, OH. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.

P & P’s Pizzeria – 36944 Vine St, Willoughby, OH 44094 – Slice

Order online at one of the best restaurants in Willoughby, OH! P & P’s Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …

P & P’s Pizzeria New York Style – DoorDash

Get delivery or takeout from P & P’s Pizzeria New York Style at 36944 Vine St in Willoughby. Order online and track your order live.

Reviews

Rachel Hannon
Concept is confusing. Virtual golf, Sunoco, Bombay food, pizza, maybe even more! Who knows!
Pizza is really average. Tastes like literally nothing? Sauce wasn’t sweet, tangy, seasoned…. Anything? They some how managed to completely neutralize the flavor. Cheese is ok quality but also didn’t add much overall flavor.
The slices are kept out without any type of heating element, which is an interesting choice, as the health department will then require these to be replaced on the hour every hour- you can tell this is not happening. The person behind me even commented on their poor appearance and asked if a fresh one would be made soon- they employee nonchalantly said no, are these ok? And pointed helplessly to the aforementioned sad slices. Dude walked out, and I don’t really blame him.
My pizza was fresh, and had a gorgeous physical appearance, but…. It really just didn’t have any flavor. Not the same P&P’s my husband and I remember from Concord years back. And that one’s gone this same way, so I guess it’s done now. RIP
… more
Pumking Pie
Fist time there and let me tell you the pizza took me back home exactly how New York makes there pizza I was in heaven and for the gentleman that answer the phone thank you for helping me out even call me back when we lost connection the ladies were very nice and helpful they just gain a new customer. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
… more
Raymond Palermo
The pizza at this place is below Little Caesars hot N nasty level.

Very little flavor, crust is tasteless and rough. House dressing is balsamic and not great.

Service was good.
… more
Bob the Raptor & Joe
Located inside the same building as Bombay Burrito P&P Pizzeria gave a very positive first impression. In addition to ready to serve New York Style Pizza P&P also offers sheet Pizzas and whole New York Style Pizzas. Additionally they sell calzones and canoli
… more
Charlie Perry
Stopped in for lunch to grab two slices of pepperoni and a pop. First of all, New York style is my favorite and all the boxes were checked on this place. A lot of taste, greasy and big. The only issue I had, that once I got home which is about roughly 5 minutes away my slices were cold. If you’re getting it to go, best that you recommend to have it thrown in the oven to warm it up. Definitely enjoyed my and I will be stopping in for the same thing.
… more
theKMFDM machine
Whoever’s working tonight you made some hella good pie’s, 5 star normal night, 10 stars tonight. Thanks
… more
paul delaney
The problem is they don’t know how to slice a pizza. Every pizza is a party cut like 32 slices instead of six or eight. That’s fine if you having a party call up ask for a party cut
Normal pizza is not sliced that way it’s very good pizza just sliced very weird. Would have been five stars if they knew how to slice a pizza. And I’m from New York.. update apparently they’ll cut a pizza anyway you want except they don’t give you that option on DoorDash. My point is the default slicing of a pizza should be six or eight if you want it party cut then you should have to call and ask. Party cut should not be default
… more
John
We got the deluxe pizza and it was super tasty New York style. The place was 4 different resutrants in one, with a small seating area off to the side with a few large screen TVs.

No alcohol from what I saw, but soda was available.
… more
Jennifer Angelo
Update***I went to this location for lunch. A young kid waited on me. He was very rude. I had to ask someone else for my drink. My food was also made incorrectly. This is the 2nd time I asked for cheese on my garlic bread, amd did not get it. He was too worried about watching the Guardians game. The food however is amazing
… more
Nina Denton
I have been looking for a good pizza place since I’ve moved here and I found one. I’m from Boston and love the pizza and small Italian places with great food. Keep it up and I will always be a customer here
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment