Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Poppy Seed Bagels, we’re dedicated to preserving the timeless tradition of authentic, hand-rolled, and kettle-boiled bagels. Our mission is to bring the taste of New York-style bagels to our local community and beyond, using only the finest ingredients and time-tested techniques. We believe that a great bagel should be crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and packed with delicious flavor. That’s why we take pride in baking our bagels fresh every day, and offering a wide variety of flavors and Cream Cheeses to satisfy every taste. Whether you’re a bagel connoisseur or a first-time customer, we welcome you to our store and invite you to savor the authentic taste With a Twist.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2220 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10303
Phone: (718) 233-8656
Website: https://nypoppyseed.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fresh Local Hand Rolled Bagels in Staten Island
At Poppy Seed Bagels, we believe in starting your day right with fresh, handcrafted bagels baked daily, delicious breakfast sandwiches, and premium coffee.
Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering – Staten Island – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering at 2220 Forest Ave in Staten Island. Order online and track your order live.
Reviews
Desiree Lopez
Hands down the best bagel place I’ve been to. We drove from DC and felt like family when we walked through the door. It smelled amazing and was very clean. Everyone greeted us with a friendly smile and a hello. Joe the owner goes out of his way to make everyone feel welcome and even gave us a complimentary French toast bagel as we waited for our order. It was delicious! We ordered a variety of bagel sandwiches and decided to go back the next morning for 6 more sandwiches and 1 dozen plus 2 bagels to take home, just so we can share with friends and family. We could tell this place was a town favorite as it was busy, but the service was very fast. Hands down will make the trip back to experience this place again.
… morefiby saad
I ordered catering from Poppy Seed for a work breakfast at my school, and it was an amazing experience from start to finish. The ordering process was incredibly easy and straightforward, which made planning the event so much less stressful.
The food arrived right on time, and everything was hot, fresh, and beautifully prepared. Everyone at the breakfast loved the food, and we received so many compliments from staff. It was the perfect way to start our morning.
I highly recommend Poppy Seed for catering. Great food, reliable delivery, and a very smooth ordering process. We will definitely be ordering again!
… moreThe food arrived right on time, and everything was hot, fresh, and beautifully prepared. Everyone at the breakfast loved the food, and we received so many compliments from staff. It was the perfect way to start our morning.
I highly recommend Poppy Seed for catering. Great food, reliable delivery, and a very smooth ordering process. We will definitely be ordering again!
D N Keem Eatz
So we saw all the hype about Poppy Seed Bagels and we left unimpressed. The owners and workers were great, greeted us when we walked in, easy to order. Just to start we asked for both our bagels toasted and they weren’t and to me that makes a big difference with a bagel ( to each their own). I ordered Salt bagels toasted with Cream Cheese and Bacon my wife ordered Egg Bagel toasted with egg and bacon with butter and jelly. The Cream Cheese was nice and cold which I love and the bacon tasted great and was crispy, but the amount of butter dripping off the egg bagel could have caused a flash flood in a small town. The bagel I would give a 5.5 but again if they were toasted we might have appreciated them more. If we are shopping at Lowes or Kohls we may stop by to try them again
… moreZulmarie Perez
Bagels were amazing! So many cream cheese options that were very tasty. We loved the varieties with the bacon and hot honey drizzle.
… moreMarco Ruiz
I’m from our of town and was recommended this place. OMG!! This place is amazing. The ladies are super nice. The bagels and cream cheese were perfect.
… moreJasmin Rodriguez
Great spot!!! Hidden, but if you know, you know!! The cook got my sandwich right!!! The coffee set is self serve which I appreciate!! Pray you guys grow!!! And the complimentary dessert was delicious!!!
… moreJeff Lopez
Came to the area for some time in NYC- coming from DC. Can honestly say it was 5/5 for food, service and atmosphere. Coming up from DC, that same morning we walked in to grab some authentic NY bagels and my goodness were we all blown away. The taste, the effect of the food- all was worth the drive. We waited a little for our food but it was awesome to see not a moment passed where there wasn’t someone walking through that door. I ordered The Sriracha and every piece of the sandwich was amazing. Coming from the DC area this place tops every bagel joint in the DMV I’ve been to, hands down!
If you’re coming to NYC and Staten Island- you MUST stop here and grab a custom bagel. SO. DAMN. GOOD.
… moreIf you’re coming to NYC and Staten Island- you MUST stop here and grab a custom bagel. SO. DAMN. GOOD.
Donna F
Amazing place!! The most friendly, kind and fantastic staff – so helpful!! Best bagels we’ve ever had (whole wheat toasted with cinnamon walnut raisin & pictured: everything bagel toasted, with bacon & scallion) SOOOOOOO good!
… moreEmily McCormick
The best bagel combination ALERT‼️The French toast bagel with plain cream cheese might be one of the greatest creations I’ve ever had the pleasure of enjoying. Thank you to all the staff for making this magic happen.
… moreRichard Leonard
We stopped in earlier this week during a visit to Wagner College and I wish I could give it 6 stars out of 5. Joe, the owner, and his family took great care of us. If you didn’t know any better, you would think Joe was a longtime family friend even though we met him that morning. He was friendly, genuine, and generous and the food was great. The entire staff was happy, polite, and friendly in a way that you can tell they love working there. That kind of thing comes from the top down and Joe is doing an amazing, dedicated job with his bagel shop. While we were there we witnessed him treating everyone else the same way. He knew we were visiting from out-of-town and were probably one-time customers, but he treated us like someone whose regular business he wanted to win over. Great place. Great people. Great food.
… more