Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Poppa Mia’s Ice House | West Sayville NY – Facebook
Poppa Mia’s Ice House, West Sayville. 986 likes · 2 talking about this · 130 were here. King of Corona Italian ice, soft serve ice cream and coffee! A…
PoppaMia’s IceHouse (@poppamiasicehouse) · West Sayville, NY
1,125 followers. 520 following. Real Italian ice. Delicious soft serve. A family tradition for 50+ years. Photo by PoppaMia’s IceHouse on September 14, 2025.
Poppa Mias Ice House, 423 Main St, # 473, West Sayville, NY 11796 …
Papa Mia’s Ice House is a cozy establishment in West Sayville, NY that offers a variety of frozen treats to satisfy your cravings.
Reviews
Michele Stokes
Been coming here since I was a kid!!! Favorite ice place, there is no place better!!
Try the chocolate icy
… moreTry the chocolate icy
Nicole G
Everything was melted…I orded the toasted almond it was all syrup…ordered the iced tea with the lemon ice in it…melted instantly bc the tea was hot. Sad I love to support small business(plus I hate ralphs) but I wouldn’t go back.
… moreBrandon Simons
Great variety, and a nice treat to cool you down, on a warm summer day! Great prices as well!
… moreEdward Hahn
I have been coming to this place since I was a child. I highly recommend their ices!!! Best in the tri stste area!!!!
… moreElena Rodriguez
Best Italian ices! Been going over 40 years and I’ve never had any better. Now, they accept cards payments in addition to cash. Always start and end the summer with them!
… moreViktoria “Drummermomof2”
Very tasty ices, fun flavours, definitely NOT naturally flavoured, however, these ices were WAY better tasting than big chain places . The LICORICE flavour was AWESOME with tiny bits of black licorice in it. The building facade has a fun energy to it; the garbage can looks like a massive ice cream cone.
… moreMike Dunne
Great place to grab a yummy ice! Staff are awesome and always make my lil daughter feel special! A ton of flavors!
I just wish they had some more seats/tables.
… moreI just wish they had some more seats/tables.
Skylar Bachisin
I’ve been here many times- delicious Italian ices! I’ve enjoyed every flavor I’ve tried. Personal favorite is the cherry vanilla!
… moreBrad Ev
This is a quaint little ice cream shoppe. The Ice cream is tasty. The servers were very pleasant and there is a warm atmosphere about the place. We will definitely be back.
… moreLily Alma
Great ices and soft serve with very reasonable prices!
… more