Pony Island Restaurant

by

  4.7 – 787 reviews   • Breakfast restaurant

Social Profile:

✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out Pony Island Restaurant 27960

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Pony Island Restaurant | Ocracoke NC – Facebook

Pony Island Restaurant. Ocracoke Island’s Oldest Eatery. Serving fresh local seafood and a big southern breakfast. American Restaurant · $$. . Follow …

Pony Island Restaurant – Visit Ocracoke NC

Pony-Island-Restaurant-2.jpg. 51 Ocean View Road, Ocracoke, NC 27960; 252-928-5701 · facebook.com. Sign Up for Our Newsletter. Get insider tips, updates, …

Pony Island Restaurant | Outer Banks, NC – Ocracoke

The island’s oldest eating establishment. It is casual, family-friendly and serves breakfast daily except Tuesday starting at 7 am.

Reviews

Amber Chase
Well made eggs, tasty hash browns, sausage was very well balanced, and the hotcake was delicious! Coffee mugs never ran low. Waiter was pleasant to talk to and made sure we had everything we needed for a perfect breakfast. Found a wonderful breakfast spot for our next visit!

2X order of the Big Pony Breakfast
… more
Amber Mullis
After reading the reviews this was our first stop after getting off the ferry. And, honestly, I would have loved to give this place a five star rating but…. I ordered the morning special of a crab and Swiss omelette. There were so many shells I had to spit out every other bite. The flavor was great but because I could only eat half of it, it definitely wasn’t worth the $25 we had to pay for it. However, my husband loved his breakfast tacos, our kids loved their breakfast: banana pancakes, eggs, bacon. I just wouldn’t recommend the crab and Swiss omelette.
… more
Jesse Jaye
Best breakfast on the island! All the classic breakfast foods done right.

Our party of four was seated without a wait at 9am Saturday morning in October. Don’t try that during the warm months though. This place is popular and gets pretty busy. But definitely worth it.

The omelets are a favorite with us and don’t skip those big, plate sized pancakes.

Pay at the hostess stand when your done and grab a t shirt on your way out.
… more
William Stanley
We came back over to the island just to eat here!… well worth it! Breakfast was awesome! We had the pancakes, French toast, and strawberries, link sausage, breakfast taters, and biscuits. Fast and great service. Reasonably priced.
… more
Jim Harrell (LarderRoom)
LarderRoom…Brunch at the Pony Island Restaurant in Ocracoke, NC wouldn’t be complete with a huge slice of Country Ham! The picture does not justice. That is a slab of delicious salty ham. Now bring on the French Toast, Pancakes and that thick Black Coffee! Nothing better than a big southern breakfast before a day in the SUN with the family!
… more
Leslie Tetterton
Our group of 5 had quick friendly service. Our waiter was very attentive. The food was tasty, with average to small portions so you don’t overdo it and you have plenty of energy for vacation fun.
… more
Bill Sawdey
Always a multi-stop during our week on Ocracoke. Kathy (Cathy?) is one of our favorite waitresses. She always has a smile and treats us like her best customer. Highly recommend enjoying a breakfast here.
… more
Auguste
Wonderful breakfast. The locals and the staff really make this restaurant. Everyone here is so friendly and cheerful. The coffee is excellent and the conversation ideal. You must checkout this local place of heaven.
… more
Timbo LeClerc
This is the one stop breakfast place. To go to any other place if you could only go to one place would be missing out! WOW! I had the crab omelette and it was perfect and the service was the fastest we have ever been served for breakfast. Make it a point to come here you won’t regret it!
… more
Alyssa Bennett
Great breakfast, super quick in and out despite there being a bunch of people on the wait. Visited September 2025, would definitely go again !
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment

© 2026 Marketer • Built with GeneratePress

Privacy Policy

Terms

Contact