Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Our homey cooking and exceptional pasta make us the best Italian restaurant in all of Manhattan. Begin your meal with our mozzarella pomodoro, and then let our signature pasta polpette take the stage. End your meal on a sweet note with our delectable tiramisu, and you’ll have yourself an authentic meal you won’t forget.
Neighborhood trattoria with traditional Italian fare that’s popular before Lincoln Center shows.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 229 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023
Phone: (212) 721-3009
Website: http://www.pomodororossonyc.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: spotapps.co
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pomodoro Rosso – Upper West Side, New York, NY
Delicious neighborhood Italian restaurant with an excellent wine selection. We had the eggplant, fish stew and fresh pasta… Everything was outstanding.
Pomodoro Rosso Restaurant – New York, NY | OpenTable
Pomodoro, at 229 Columbus Avenue has been a neighborhood favorite for years. The beautifully prepared Italian classics and excellent service has earned this …
Pomodoro Rosso | New York NY – Facebook
Pomodoro Rosso has been serving authentic Italian fare on the Upper West Side of Manhattan since 1993.
Reviews
Daniel Lee
In honesty, we had a reservation elsewhere, but we decided to come here because we were running on a time crunch.
Huge mistake. I don’t think they season their food. The starter bread was fine, but it was a bit odd because they were like crispy naan sticks? The olive oil with garlic and rosemary(maybe oregano?) was flavorless and just didn’t taste like good quality
The rigatoni alla vodka was NOT alla vodka. It tasted just OK, but not enough peas to quality and simply too overpriced. You’d expect a $30 pasta to be “lick-the-plate” good, but we didn’t even think twice of finishing the plate – let alone take it home.
I got the spaghetti with meatballs and sausage… i don’t think I’ve had a less flavored meatball (sausage too). Honestly, the entire pasta dish lacked any semblance of flavor.
Absolutely not coming back here. If you’re looking to pay $30 for tasteless dishes, you found the place. Don’t wait for a table, don’t reserve a table, don’t even think of coming in.
I’d say you could eat here if you were desperately hungry, but at the price point they’re offered for the quality – you can definitely find 10000 better options just walking down the block
… moreHuge mistake. I don’t think they season their food. The starter bread was fine, but it was a bit odd because they were like crispy naan sticks? The olive oil with garlic and rosemary(maybe oregano?) was flavorless and just didn’t taste like good quality
The rigatoni alla vodka was NOT alla vodka. It tasted just OK, but not enough peas to quality and simply too overpriced. You’d expect a $30 pasta to be “lick-the-plate” good, but we didn’t even think twice of finishing the plate – let alone take it home.
I got the spaghetti with meatballs and sausage… i don’t think I’ve had a less flavored meatball (sausage too). Honestly, the entire pasta dish lacked any semblance of flavor.
Absolutely not coming back here. If you’re looking to pay $30 for tasteless dishes, you found the place. Don’t wait for a table, don’t reserve a table, don’t even think of coming in.
I’d say you could eat here if you were desperately hungry, but at the price point they’re offered for the quality – you can definitely find 10000 better options just walking down the block
Sharon
I truly enjoyed the mussels, stuffed shrimp and shrimp parmesan. The service was welcoming and attentive.
… moreNat T.
Had high expectation for this place but was disappointed. Despite restaurant half full, service was not attentive with server forgetting request or walking away as soon as they ask what we wanted to order. Food was just ok and not justify especially when you look at the price. Ambiance was ok and the restaurant is a mix of locals and tourists. Would not come back again – lots of better other option nearby.
… moreLM H. (BigRedd)
This is my most favorite restaurant ever!! I have been going here for about 30+ years. My whole family loves this place. The owner Peter and his staff are the best. You always feel seen.
… moreChristopher Fiscus
Excellent Italian restaurant with wonderful service and memorable dishes like the chicken parm and shrimp and spinach over pasta. Espresso and tiramisu closed it out nicely.
… moreSANDY Sanchez
Well we weren’t exactly dressed for it , so we sat outside. Inside look a bit like u should be dressed right. . I ordered the short rib with mash potatoes. Omg was it good. It was sooooo good. The portion was big enough.Not cheap. Came here with my uncle , mom , aunt. They eat like they on a diet . Not me . I loved my food. Would def eat here again next time. Price is not low but not too high. Parking is street parking. . . Ladies bring a sweater inside the A. C was great. Felt it as I went to bathroom. All the waiters were all very nice. . Thank u all u made dinner very very nice. I didn’t get a picture of my food. But I did get these 2 pictures. A small video of this beautiful fire place. .I loved it. Not sure if it was real.
… moreIndio Comido
For being an italian place at that zone, i was expecting so much more…
Service was great but we where really dissapointed on the food.
We even found a fetuccine in a spaguetti plate
I mean, i guess everything was well cooked, but the lack of flavor even from the calammari starter was kinda dissapointing
Bread was nice tho!
… moreService was great but we where really dissapointed on the food.
We even found a fetuccine in a spaguetti plate
I mean, i guess everything was well cooked, but the lack of flavor even from the calammari starter was kinda dissapointing
Bread was nice tho!
Lythia ROUSSEAS
Delicious neighborhood Italian restaurant with an excellent wine selection. We had the eggplant, fish stew and fresh pasta… Everything was outstanding. The cannoli and cappuccino were best we’ve had! The servers were so personable and attentive…We will be back!
… moreEui Sun Chung
This restaurant has established itself as a great spot for homemade Italian cuisine in the Upper West Side, and I prefer it even more because it’s open for lunch. The 12-3 menu is a fantastic daily lunch option. You can select from four different pastas, with a choice of Caesar or house salad, and for dessert, tiramisu or cannoli, all for a reasonable price of $26.
The salad is fresh, and the pasta is truly authentic.
… moreThe salad is fresh, and the pasta is truly authentic.
Jose Almejo
Absolutely amazing gem right by Central Park. I had a group of 7 and we all had a craving for Italian food. We stopped by for a late lunch and were quickly seated. The wait staff was super friendly, always had our water glasses filled and answered all our questions about the menu. Even offered us a few off menu items that were great. Pictured are the antipasto salad, burrata, calamari, tri color salad, chicken parm, chicken francese, seafood pasta, & the spaghetti and meatballs. Fun fact, chicken francese was not on the menu but the chef made it and it was absolutely delicious and came paired with spaghetti made in the francese sauce. After about an hour, we cleared our plates and we were on our way enjoying the great weather in the park. Stop by Pomodoro Rosso for a great meal.
… more