Social Profile: ![]()
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Welcome to Plus 1 Pizza, your go-to pizza restaurant located at 26 Olive Street! We specialize in delicious takeout pizza, prompt pizza delivery, and convenient pizza online ordering to satisfy your cravings anytime. At Plus 1 Pizza, we pride ourselves on offering irresistible pizza specials and exclusive pizza coupons to deliver the best value to our customers. Whether you’re looking for pizza near me or planning a pizza night at home, our freshly prepared pizzas are always crafted with the finest ingredients to ensure exceptional taste in every bite. Discover your favorite pizza today at Plus 1 Pizza, where quality meets convenience!
Hours
| Monday | 3–9:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 3–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 3–9:30 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 26 Olive St, Caldwell, OH 43724
Phone: (740) 732-1555
Website: http://www.plusonepizza.com/ohio/caldwell/plus-1-pizza-caldwell
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
plusone-caldwell.foodtecsolutions.com
Related Web Results
Caldwell, OH, Pizzeria Near You | Voted Best Pizza – Plus 1 Pizza
Plus 1 Pizza – 26 Olive St., Caldwell, Ohio, 43724. | Fast Delivery. Call 740-732-1555. A Pizzeria near you, with the wide variety of toppings, …
Menu – Plus 1 Pizza Caldwell Ohio
Pizza, Hoagys, Calzones, Pasta, Salads and more. Our menu of over 40 favorites is available for dine in, delivery or carry out.
Pizza Specials Caldwell Ohio – Plus 1 Pizza
Choose any 2 for $9.25 each: Medium 1 Topping Pizza, 8″ Sub, Spaghetti Dinner, Stromboli, Sm Cheesy Bread, Mega Cookie , Boneless Wings, or Large Salad
Last Updates
Reviews
Alice Greene
I am from out of state, I usually only have dominos haha but I wanted to try something different. This is what I chose. I got the New Yorker, it was delicious. Definitely fresh. The crust is different from back home which was cool. The boneless wings tasted way better than they look so don’t let that fool you. Seems like good quality and the Buffalo sauce has a nice kick to it. I have no appreciation for weak Buffalo sauce. The brownie was warm fudgy and gooey but still with a little crunch along the edges. I have no complaints. Nobody asked me but it’s easier to enjoy things when you look on the bright side.
… moreBeth Baker
I have had one bad experience with Plus One in Caldwell Ohio, but I called today and the girl was so sweet and kind. She read my order back to me and all. Very happy.
… moreDan Hennon
Saw a review an they said it was excellent and we were in the area so had to try it being a pizza fanatic. Did not disappoint one but fast delivery and pizza cooked to perfection, and y’all even saw not to use garlic butter on our bread sticks everyone messes that up, thank you for the great food an service!
… moreMeg Moore
Was good! Love that they have several different cheeses. Wouldn’t get the smoked Gouda on it again but it was well made and tasty
… moreTyler Platts
My family and I love coming to Caldwell!!! We stayed at the comfort inn and ordered pizza, stromboli and Greek salad. It was some of the best food we’ve had for delivery!!! Salad was super fresh and pizza and stromboli were delicious!!
… moreAnnie Darby
Excellent service. A little hard to find at night but I would definitely try more varieties of their pizza
… moreMatthew Lallathin
Great pizza, been going here for 35 years.
Service: …
… moreService: …
Michelle Nicoletti
Out of towners trying the local pizza place and the pizza was fantastic!!!! We were only in town for 4 days but debated on ordering it again it was so good! The cheesy bread was the best I’ve ever had!
… morerob bloom
I’m staying in Caldwell because of my job. So I try a lot of different places when I work out town. This is the best pizza I’ve had in a while. Got it for delivery estimated was 65 minutes but it came in 20 minutes. I also got a order of wings, they wasn’t as hot as I like them to be but was very flavorful. Will definitely be ordering from here again.
… moreAngela Buckey
In my opinion this is the best pizza place in town. The people are always polite, they’ve never messed up my order (probably the only place in town that hasn’t), and I’m never waiting too long for my food.
… more