Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Plum Tomato Pizzeria is an authentic Italian restaurant fresh all made to order. New York hand-tossed pizzas, authentic pasta dishes, chicken wings, calzones, desserts, salads, appetizers, and more. Fresh bread made daily: we offer Beer and Wine, delivery is available.Our menu is rooted in classic Italian cooking, with a focus on balance and flavor rather than shortcuts. We believe good food does not need to be complicated when quality ingredients and proper technique come first. Each dish is prepared with care, whether it is something light or a full, satisfying meal. That consistency allows you to order with confidence, knowing your food will be prepared the same way every time. This approach is what defines Plum Tomato Pizzeria in Tarpon
Gourmet pies, hoagies, calzones & classic Italian fare served in a relaxed setting.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1988 Pinellas Ave, Tarpon Springs, FL 34689
Phone: (727) 944-3330
Website: http://www.plumpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Italian Cuisine Pizzeria & Catering
At Plum Tomato Pizzeria, we pride ourselves on serving authentic Italian … Visit Us. 1988 S PINELLAS AVE, TARPON SPGS, FL 34689, US. Phone: (727) 944 …
Plum Tomato Pizzeria | Tarpon Springs FL – Facebook
Come taste the authentic flavors of Italy right here in Tarpon Springs! Dine in. Carry out . Delivery plumpizza.com 727.944.3330 #pizzza##italianfood #tampa …
Plum Tomato Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria – View Menu … – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Tarpon Springs, FL! Plum Tomato Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite.
Reviews
Gina Dimitriou
Plum has been my go to place for pizza wings and Italian food in general. They serve family size portions for the fraction of the price of major corporations. Their chicken à la vodka is a must and their garlic parm wings are soooooo good . Service is great and atmosphere is so New York . If you’re in the area it’s a must try you’ll thank me later !!!
… morealexgaroff
We ordered 3 pizzas and two types of wings. All three pizzas were excellent—thin crust, generous sauce, and well-topped. The wings were decent, not outstanding, but still enjoyable. Overall, we were very happy with the food. The only downside is the restaurant itself—it could use a deep clean and some updates, as it looks a bit worn. I’d recommend tidying up the space to match the quality of the food.
… moreDeadpool Righteous Evil
Quality of food can vary, IMHO, greatly. Sometimes fantastic, sometimes o.k., a few times horrible, i.e., moldy tiramisu, burnt marinara. The irony of the moldy tiramisu was, I asked specifically how it was that night, and told good.
… moreLaynie Hiriart
A terrible experience. We weren’t even going to dine in, we just wanted to order takeout, and still the lady —blonde, short in height— rudely shouted at us: “Kitchen closed!”. This happened 30 minutes before the posted closing time, which is completely unacceptable. Very unprofessional, unfriendly, and with no respect for customers. If they advertise a schedule, they should stick to it instead of making excuses and treating people poorly. I will definitely not be coming back or recommending this place.
… moreChina Lynn
The pizza is good and all but I live straight down and the only turn is to get into my neighborhood so maybe do less of this because slices on top
Of other slices because of careless driving and the cheese falling off I paid $36 for thing pizza just for it to arrive like this
Edited because I needed to say that I got this delivered
… moreOf other slices because of careless driving and the cheese falling off I paid $36 for thing pizza just for it to arrive like this
Edited because I needed to say that I got this delivered
Kim Anastasi
Worst pizza I have ever had. Ordered extra cheese n pepperoni. Didn’t see any of that. Crust was very over cooked and horrible. Other food there looked good. Wine and waitress were great.
… moreDalton Dahmer
Absolutely amazing, I love non traditional pizzas and if you do too, try the plum pizza! Delicious in every way and I’m in the food business and let me tell you, this was incredible! Thank you Dawn and Melissa for great service . Also the owner Andy is a wonderful guy! Keep it up! I’m from out of town but was blown away! Look forward to being back in town to eat here again!
… moreAlexandra Paunovich
We ordered two entrees and steak quesadillas for dinner (over $60 in food). First, they forgot the soup that came with one of the dinners, so we had to make a second trip to the restaurant. Once we finally got to eat, the chicken marsala was literally so dry and just covered in oil. It had absolutely no flavor. The chicken in the chicken parmesan was so chewy and rubbery, I’m almost certain it was bad. The steak quesadilla and the soup were the only decent food from the whole meal. When I called to speak with a manager, she said they’re unable to do any sort of refund because they use a third party company for their online orders (even though I ordered from their website), meanwhile that information is not advertised anywhere. Sad to say we will never go back.
… moreAngela
First time having plum pizza and it was outstanding! The food was great! The staff was wonderful and everything was delicious. Definitely a new favorite spot! Thank you
… moreTangela Moore
The pizza bake has been inconsistent. It can go from a lovely baked cracker crust with great tasting sauce to an over baked dried up pizza. **They do charge an additional fee for credit card purchases.
… more