Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 260 Main St, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Phone: (716) 692-0100
Website: http://www.plazapizza.biz/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Plaza Pizzeria On Main – Tonawanda, NY
Welcome to Plaza Pizzeria On Main. Serving up delicious pizza, subs, wings and other delights to the Tonawanda Community for over 20 years.
Plaza Pizzeria on Main | Tonawanda NY – Facebook
Great food at affordable process. Proudly serving the City of Tonawanda for 20+ years. Locally own
Plaza Pizzeria, 260 Main St, Tonawanda, NY 14150, US – MapQuest
Plaza Pizzeria On Main has been serving the Tonawanda Community for many years, offering a delectable selection of pizza, subs, wings, and other delightful …
Reviews
Kyle Matesic
Cash only. No online ordering option. Called ahead. Pizza was ready at the desired time. Overall the pizza was good. $25 large cheese pepperoni. Standard Buffalo pizza. Lots of cheese. Lots of cup and char the crust was nice and crispy. The only thing I was neutral on was the sauce, it just was ever so lightly sweet, didn’t taste like a traditional pizza sauce. It was ok. I’d order it again. Thank you
… moreSidney Horne
Out of town-ers from South Carolina craving pizza after the Bills game. Ran across this place for delivery. Pizza deliverer was very nice and personable! We accidentally overpaid by quite a lot (handed an extra bill) and she returned to give us back what we had overpaid once she realized. Pizza was great. Sauce was AMAZING! Truly homemade and delicious!
… morePreo Tonix
Ordered Takeout large pizza (7 toppings $3per) & large fries with delivery $54(yes I did to paid $67)
As you can see from the photos plenty of toppings, but not fully cooked (check the pepperoni’s)! Crust was brown and black but bottom was super soft too where all topping slid off as it flipped over…. (Expected if cheese not mixed in with toppings to hold and bottom crust not given time to fully firm)
I just stuck it in the oven to harden bottom and cook toppings and it was fine!
Fries were good!
Would recommend cutting or chopping toppings then putting half the amount on and charging 1.50 for Xtra toppings instead of 3.00 per…. think would make for easier prep to fully cook and a better slightly more affordable pizza! Overall can’t complain! Will order again to just try a basic double pep! For a better opinion on review.
… moreAs you can see from the photos plenty of toppings, but not fully cooked (check the pepperoni’s)! Crust was brown and black but bottom was super soft too where all topping slid off as it flipped over…. (Expected if cheese not mixed in with toppings to hold and bottom crust not given time to fully firm)
I just stuck it in the oven to harden bottom and cook toppings and it was fine!
Fries were good!
Would recommend cutting or chopping toppings then putting half the amount on and charging 1.50 for Xtra toppings instead of 3.00 per…. think would make for easier prep to fully cook and a better slightly more affordable pizza! Overall can’t complain! Will order again to just try a basic double pep! For a better opinion on review.
Toby Byrnes
Cheese and pepp was decent. Not necessarily true buffalo pizza in my opinion. Crust was good but wasnt thick enough Cheese was a little too sloppy. Overall okay.
… moreNoah R (Noe)
First time ordering here and the subs were fantastic will definitely order again just make sure to bring cash they don’t take card!
… moreDeborah Ryan
The place is small with only a counter top & a few chairs but the pizza was great. Tasty sauce, lots of cheese & plenty of pepperoni
… moreDiana W
After my son’s basketball game we called and order a large cheese and pepperoni pizza and 7 chicken fingers. The woman who took my order was very friendly. She explained that it was a cash only business which was helpful to know. We liked the pizza and the fingers.
… moreBenjamin Pritchard
The pizza place I went to for 20 got sold and the new owner changed ingredients. The pizza was not up to par. Someone recommended Plaza Pizza making my quest for a new pizza place short. I will be a regular customer as long as they stay around. Great Pizza. Thanks ❤️
… moreJackie Kwiatkowski
Excellent pizza and wings. We order for all the kids birthdays. Highly recommended!
… moreTanisha Brooks
I guess when I went in it was around closing time. The chairs were up and someone was sweeping, so I waited in my car for my slices. The slices were warm and hard as if they were from hours ago. I’m not sure how long pizza can be held for but this pizza was held for too long or overcooked to begin with. Definitely not a great experience, won’t be repeating it. Also becareful with your reviews as the owner will respond with a nasty attitude and based on his attitude in his response it is clear to see why this place doesn’t meet simple standards. If you want good pizza try- just pizza, imperial, Bocces on Bailey, Picasso, Grasso or La Nova, you wont regret it…tons of better pizza spots
… more