Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Long-running standby for traditional thin-crust & deep-dish pies, plus casual Italian favorites.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 9022 W Oklahoma Ave, West Allis, WI 53227
Phone: (414) 543-1300
Website: http://pizzeriascotty.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizzeria Scotty | West Allis WI – Facebook
Pizzeria Scotty, West Allis. 2588 likes · 696 were here. 9022 W. OKLAHOMA AVE, WEST ALLIS, WISCONSIN TO ORDER, CALL 414-543-1300.
Pizzeria Scotty
PIZZA MAKER VISION This is an up close view of us making one of your pizzas! We hope you enjoy. Be sure to check out our socials to stay up to date with …
Pizzeria Scotty: Your Go-To Destination for Delicious Pizza in West …
Nestled in West Allis, Wisconsin, this casual eatery is renowned for its delicious pizza, including standout options like the BBQ Chicken Deluxe, crafted with …
Reviews
Joe Brown
Ordered from Pizzeria Scotty through Uber Eats. Just to be clear, Uber Eats simply picks up the food, they don’t make the pizza and they don’t print the kitchen ticket.
We ordered a 16 inch pizza. When it arrived, it was clearly a 14 inch pizza. The kicker, the ticket on the box literally said 16 inches.
So the order was taken correctly, the ticket was printed correctly, but the pizza in the box was still a 14 inch. That’s not an Uber Eats problem, that’s a kitchen mistake.
When I called Pizzeria Scotty, they tried to say it was Uber Eats’ issue. I genuinely don’t understand how that makes sense. Uber Eats didn’t make the pizza, they just picked it up.
I’ve worked at a few pizzerias myself, and mistakes happen. No big deal. What’s frustrating is refusing to own the mistake when the ticket clearly shows the order was for a 16 inch pizza and the restaurant put a 14 inch in the box.
Good pizza, but this kind of response makes it feel like they’re hoping people won’t notice when they get shorted. Just own the mistake and make it right.
… moreWe ordered a 16 inch pizza. When it arrived, it was clearly a 14 inch pizza. The kicker, the ticket on the box literally said 16 inches.
So the order was taken correctly, the ticket was printed correctly, but the pizza in the box was still a 14 inch. That’s not an Uber Eats problem, that’s a kitchen mistake.
When I called Pizzeria Scotty, they tried to say it was Uber Eats’ issue. I genuinely don’t understand how that makes sense. Uber Eats didn’t make the pizza, they just picked it up.
I’ve worked at a few pizzerias myself, and mistakes happen. No big deal. What’s frustrating is refusing to own the mistake when the ticket clearly shows the order was for a 16 inch pizza and the restaurant put a 14 inch in the box.
Good pizza, but this kind of response makes it feel like they’re hoping people won’t notice when they get shorted. Just own the mistake and make it right.
Biianca Orttiz
I USED TO LOVE THIS PLACE THAT’S WHAT I HAD A BAD DELIVERY ONE DAY AND THEY STARTED TREATING ME VERY WRONGLY.. I CALLED AND COMPLAINED ABOUT THE ORDER I HAD A PIZZA SLICE THAT WAS MISSING THE DRIVER SAID YES SHE FORGOT IT ON THE COUNTER SHE WENT BACK TO GET IT I CALLED THE STORE AND LET THEM KNOW WHAT WAS GOING ON THEY GAVE ME A $15 CREDIT WHEN I WENT TO GO USE MY $15 CREDIT JUST THE OTHER DAY WHOEVER PICKED UP THE PHONE WAS ANGRY ABOUT IT DIDN’T WANT TO USE MY CREDIT DIDN’T EVEN WANT TO LET ME ORDER AND HUNG UP THE PHONE ON ME I’LL NEVER BE ORDERING FROM HERE AGAIN I COMPLAINED TO THE OWNER TRAVIS A FEW TIMES AND THIS IS STILL GOING ON THE FOOD WAS COLD IT WAS UNDERCOOKED AND WHEN IT WAS GROSS I DON’T KNOW IF IT WAS JUST ME THAT THEY WERE TARGETING OR IF THE FOOD WAS LIKE THAT THE WHOLE DAY BUT NOW EVERY TIME I ORDER FROM THERE THE FOOD IS VERY GROSS AND I’M DEALT WITH IN THE DISRESPECTFUL MANNER
… moreJoshua Kozlowski
We live close by and walked over to place our order for the fun of it instead of calling. The staff was super helpful and nice; we ordered the Wednesday special and got a stuffed cheese pizza with breadsticks. Honestly, both were so delicious!
We will certainly be returning! What an awesome pizzeria.
… moreWe will certainly be returning! What an awesome pizzeria.
Luck Lucky
I have to say that the service was wonderful. The bathroom was very clean and that’s something that tells a lot about a place. The pizza was very good eight out of 10.
… moreSamantha Repati
this is the first time I have had their gluten-free pizza since I was diagnosed with celiac desiese a year ago. I would not get it agian. It was over cooked so the cheese made a hard layer and the crust was so crispy it scratched my throat. I give them props for trying but it is not worth it. I’ll take a frozen gluten free pizza over this.
… moreAngela Hackbarth
We ordered the stuffed cheese pizza and the BBQ Chicken pizza, omg it was amazing. I highly recommend this place! The stuffed cheese pizza was like eating a giant mozzarella stick, it was the best thing! I’m still dreaming about it. The BBQ Chicken pizza had thin crust and was delicious as well. Perfect balance of bbq sauce and toppings.
… moreTravis (Doughboy_Food_Reviews)
Pizzeria Scotty Stuffed Cheese Pizza: My favorite style of pizza is pan pizza, but a close second is stuffed pizza. Pizzeria Scotty serves Chicago style stuffed pies but is located in Milwaukee. Their stuffed pizza contains a sweet and flavorful tomato sauce on top of a thin layer of crust (so for you other pizza aficionados out there, yes I realize it’s not technically Chicago style). Below this first layer of crust is stuffed double portions of cheese (along with any other desired toppings) and then the base layer of crust. I’m a huge fan of cheese and usually order extra cheese, but their pizza has had generous amounts of cheese every time I’ve visited. The crust is simply superb. It’s a soft doughy crust with a hint of butter and just the right amount of chewiness. Honestly, it’s the best stuffed pizza I’ve had, and I’ve visited all the big players in Chicago. For those of you that are not into stuffed pizza, they also offer thin crust, double dough, and pan style. Doughboy approved!
doughboy_food_reviews
*I think the crust could potentially be even better if they offered a version brushed in garlic butter
My favorite stuffed pizza parlors:
1.Pizzeria Scotty
2.Gino’s East
3.Giordano’s
… moredoughboy_food_reviews
*I think the crust could potentially be even better if they offered a version brushed in garlic butter
My favorite stuffed pizza parlors:
1.Pizzeria Scotty
2.Gino’s East
3.Giordano’s
Angela Malinowski
Food was okay, but in my opinion not worth the price and certainly not worth the wait.
It’s been a few years since we’ve had pizzeria scotty and decided to give it another chance. The pizza was average, not bad nor amazing; but for how long we waited, I guess the expectation was higher. It took 1 hour and 22 mins for our food (thin crust pizzas) to be delivered (we only live 9 mins away), on a slow Monday night. Would rather pay less for an equally average pizza from Pizza Hut and actually have it delivered within the expected time frame.
… moreIt’s been a few years since we’ve had pizzeria scotty and decided to give it another chance. The pizza was average, not bad nor amazing; but for how long we waited, I guess the expectation was higher. It took 1 hour and 22 mins for our food (thin crust pizzas) to be delivered (we only live 9 mins away), on a slow Monday night. Would rather pay less for an equally average pizza from Pizza Hut and actually have it delivered within the expected time frame.
Juliasworldofbricks
I’ve been ordering stuff pizza from this place for many years and never disappointed, but I ordered 2 stuffed the other day for a bday party figuring it would be enough based on all prior experiences and I was disappointed. The stuffed pizza were so thinly made. It was like having a frozen pizza with another layer of dough. Was this a recent change? Had I would’ve known I would’ve ordered somewhere else.
… moreJesica (ThaLovelyMissJ)
I recently tried their stuffed pizza. We got a small and after one piece I was stuffed myself lol. It’s a cute little place and I’m guessing it was the owner who helped me, but whoever the older gentleman was that helped me was awesome. He was super friendly and polite. It’s on the pricier side but the food is delicious and will feed u for 2 days so it’s worth it.
… more