Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 7950 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
Phone: (614) 868-3870
Website: http://pizzerianewyork.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizzeria New York
Columbus OH’s Original and Authentic New York Style Pizza.
Pizzeria New York – Reynoldsburg 7950 E Broad St
Authentic New York Style Pizza! Owner from NYC with same family recipe since 1969! Location. 7950 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068.
Pizzeria New York, 7950 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43004, US
When I moved from Philadelphia, Pizzeria NY was like a taste of home. Authentic NY-style thin-crust pizza. Pepperoni Pinwheels are a meal in themselves. True …
Reviews
haley duke
If you’re looking for some good pizza then this is definitely the spot! Me and my boyfriend love ordering from here and trying new pizzas. Tonight we got the pepperoni and chicken Alfredo pizza along with hot wings, pepperoni rolls, and cannolis for dessert and everything was just phenomenal. Definitely a must try if you haven’t or have been considering ordering. Also love how the staff is very friendly! Will definitely be back soon.
… moreAmy Burke
Really good pizza!
We ordered pepperoni on all but two slices (for the kiddos) which they seemed to accommodate but then cut it wrong so the cheese slices ended up being half pepperoni half cheese anyway. But not a huge deal, I just re cut those slices when I got home. The pizza itself was really good. My husband and I both really liked the crust and taste. Huge slices and very Floppy – reminded me of Mikey’s Late Night Slice. Good price.
We also ordered Garlic Knots which were really good as well!
… moreWe ordered pepperoni on all but two slices (for the kiddos) which they seemed to accommodate but then cut it wrong so the cheese slices ended up being half pepperoni half cheese anyway. But not a huge deal, I just re cut those slices when I got home. The pizza itself was really good. My husband and I both really liked the crust and taste. Huge slices and very Floppy – reminded me of Mikey’s Late Night Slice. Good price.
We also ordered Garlic Knots which were really good as well!
Leah Ledbetter
We decided to give New York Pizzeria a try at the last minute, even though we had never been there before. The friendly lady at the counter recommended some delicious dishes to us. I highly recommend this place. The young lady who took our order, went from running around the kitchen to being friendly and taking our order. When I asked about the difference in some of their food items, she explained them to me and recommended some great dishes. Thank you, Britney for being so kind. The world needs more people like you. I absolutely loved my chicken salad and the sauce you recommended for my wings, which I believe were Nashville hot mixed with pepper. We will definitely be returning customers.
… moreTasja Marie
First time here ! the wait experience was good nice people who provided updates to me while awaiting my food ordered a veggie pizzza with a Cajun bourbon chicken sub haven’t tried it yet, smelled great though and looked delicious coming out ! Bout to go in when I get home
… moreJasmin Lawson
BEST PIZZA IN OHIO !
Man I found out About this place while giving birth to my twins , I’m from New Jersey so it’s just a different kind of pizza I like ! The one cut into 8 slices
The food was great prices was more than affordable! My new weekly pizza place ‘ COME GRAB YOU A PIE OF PIZZA THE CHEESE CAKE WAS AMAZING ILL BE BACK !
… moreMan I found out About this place while giving birth to my twins , I’m from New Jersey so it’s just a different kind of pizza I like ! The one cut into 8 slices
The food was great prices was more than affordable! My new weekly pizza place ‘ COME GRAB YOU A PIE OF PIZZA THE CHEESE CAKE WAS AMAZING ILL BE BACK !
Justhumbleme Clarke
It may take a little longer than estimated but, it’s worth the few extra minutes. Pizza is good nice crust plenty of cheese and not extremely expensive. Unfortunately, my child didn’t care for it but don’t mind her she loves Little Caesar and Domino’s.
… moreSamantha Cullen
This is the closest you’ll get to east coast pizza. I grew up in ohio but spent the last 17 years amongst the east coast and have been trying to find a pie comparable. This checks all the boxes. A thinner non cornmeal crust, delicious cheese and sauce. Almost better than a few places back home. Also I ordered at around 7:40 tonight and my food was delivered around 8:15. Talk about service!
… moreDaniel Banks
We were looking for something new, did some research and decided to give PNY a try. We loved it! The selection was awesome, there were several fun options to try with the kids (pinwheels, knots, rolls). We made our own mini smorgasbord! The quality was great, everything was fresh and delicious. The dipping sauce and ranch were delicious and home made! The gentleman working was solo and was very busy, but he still took the time to make sure our order was perfect and had excellent presentation. We truly enjoyed everything we purchased and will be back again!
… moreKimberly Coaxico
So, I ordered online and there was an issue with it coming through to the store. This team got my pizza ready in like less than 10 minutes! They were already kind and apologetic, but they’re fast too!
Then I got home and we ate the pizza. WOW. It wasn’t like a “okay this is okay, I’d order again”. This was like “DANG I think my favorite pizza place has changed” type of good. 10/10 because of the staff, AND the food.
… moreThen I got home and we ate the pizza. WOW. It wasn’t like a “okay this is okay, I’d order again”. This was like “DANG I think my favorite pizza place has changed” type of good. 10/10 because of the staff, AND the food.
Des Minnick
Normally, my ratings for this pizzeria would be higher, but not this time. I’d normally just order the XL cheese pizza, but this time I decided to get steak on one side and spinach on the other. Well let’s just say the steak was more like chewing pieces of fat and there was only a few pieces of spinach on the pizza. Considering what they charge for toppings, I’d expect toppings and not it to be topless.
… more