Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1214 Boardwalk, Ocean City, NJ 08226
Phone: (609) 576-8287
Website: https://www.pizzeriaoceataly.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizzeria Eataly, 1214 Boardwalk, Ocean City, NJ 08226, US
Get more information for Pizzeria Eataly in Ocean City, NJ. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Pizzeria Eataly – Best of OCNJ, News & Events
Location & Contact. Address: 1214 Boardwalk, Ocean City, NJ 08226, United States. Phone: (609) 576-8287.
Order OC Eataly – Ocean City, NJ Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from OC Eataly at 1214 Boardwalk in Ocean City. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Reviews
Olivia Saunders
I wish I had read the reviews instead of just picking a place that “looked good”. Food was overpriced for what you get. Smoked Salmon bagel had barely any salmon on it. Employees looked like they hated their jobs. Based on that probably would have been a 3… but as we were finishing eating we watched the cook scratch her head with her gloves on… and continue making food. Then with the same gloves she started cleaning tables and things in the kitchen. I don’t know if she ever changed her gloves becauase we left.
… moreSandy Lewis
I also wish I had read reviews before going here. We were charged almost $28 for a small meatless Caesar Salad and a Bacon Egg and Cheese Bagel — both mediocre. I understand “resort pricing”, but at least deliver quality if you are going to charge those prices. The bagel sandwich had completely soggy, under-cooked bacon. All the worker would have had to do was pop it in the microwave for a minute to cook it more. When I told her on the way out, the Eastern European worker all of a sudden could not understand English. Also, they had her working alone. Is this a new restaurant? I can’t see it lasting very long.
… moreMichael Espejo
One of the worst meals I’ve ever paid for. An avacado hot dog had some type of avacado paste. Nothing about it was good. A corn dog seemed old and was burnt. Asked for no sour cream on nachos. Came with sour cream and pickles. Who in the world puts pickles on nachos? Stay away! Photos are
Not what they are serving.
… moreNot what they are serving.
Chelsea Ramirez Lopez
I asked this place for cheese fries and the cheese was like a caramel color. Pizza was soggy and the workers were rude. The soda they gave me was also expired even after spending $18 on a burger and a drink. They had an attitude when delivering my food. I definitely won’t be returning and do not recommend this place to anyone!
… moreJoe C
The only reason why we decided to eat here was because my wife’s father had a pizzeria here back in the 80’s to the early 2000’s. She was hoping to feel nostalgic. I think it’ll be safe to say that this place will not return next year. This place should be investigated for taking advantage of its patrons. 4 slices, 2 hot dogs and a couple drinks for $70? Food was not good at all, and I can’t even explain how disgusting the hot dogs looked. My daughter took one bite and pushed the plate away. Don’t waste your time, money and taste buds. Pathetic.
BTW, the reviews went from 1.2 stars to 3.1 in a matter of a couple hours. A bunch of 5 star reviews came pouring in….. can’t be the owner or his family, right? Dude, your place is garbage.
… moreBTW, the reviews went from 1.2 stars to 3.1 in a matter of a couple hours. A bunch of 5 star reviews came pouring in….. can’t be the owner or his family, right? Dude, your place is garbage.
Rich Gehring
The food is lousy, which is completely obvious to everyone because there is never a line at this restaurant. The food stinks, but it’s actually not as bad as the service. I actually asked for one napkin because my son has spilled sauce all over himself, I was informed that because I was not a patron (I had wisely already eaten at Manco and Manco) That I was not allowed to have one napkin. I was immediately given one by the gelato place next-door, this place is a joke and will probably be out of business in the next two years. Save your money stay away from it.
… moreGrace Malone
The attendant was off putting and rude to my girlfriend. She tried to order a grilled cheese and was told they were only making hot dogs, despite there being an entire menu section of “lunch time” foods. He was very curt and short with her, which rubbed me the wrong way. You can treat me rudely but she is where I cross the line. The food was fine, but the man’s behavior was not acceptable in my opinion.
… moreDeanna Tallo
Popped in here with family one night. We ordered chicken sandwiches which looked like cheap little patties from a school cafeteria, hot dog, which was awful. Def not picky when it comes to hot dogs, but this was offensive. The cheese on it was tasteless and the chili was beans in thick slime. The sweet potato fries tasted like chemicals. For what the quality was it was very over priced. I’m not one to complain about a business, but no way should a person pay that much for junk. Do better.
… moreJeffrey Barbagallo
STAY AWAY!! FAR AWAY!! You are greeted by a menu that has no prices on it, just menu items. How much could a foot long hotdog with cheese be? I understand this is the boardwalk, but what $6? MAYBE? That’s right you guessed it $12, a dollar an inch.
When I placed my order it was to a young man that was on his personal phone the entire time I was ordering – continuing his conversation – beyond rude.
As said – ordered one “Say Cheese” which was a footlong with nacho cheese and one “Aloha Dog” which stated grilled pineapple, teriyaki sauce, and something else. This “hot dog” was beyond APPALLING. The pineapple wasn’t grilled. We watched as he opened a can of Dole diced pineapple and scoop a few tablespoons right onto the dog. I can’t quite tell you what their “teriyaki sauce” is, but I can tell you it was frigid. It was also lumpy and had some soft of mystery meat in it. I genuinely have no idea what it was, other than revolting.
We did order a small fry, which is totally serviceable. The highlight of the show. We then asked for two fountain drinks, they said they didn’t have any, only bottled. We went to the fridge in the back and the drinks were not cold – awesome. The group after us asked for fountain drinks, and then magically it was working.
This was honestly the worst “meal” I have had at a “restaurant” (if it can even call itself that) in a very long time. I don’t write reviews often, but I was compelled after my experience. STAY AWAY!!
… moreWhen I placed my order it was to a young man that was on his personal phone the entire time I was ordering – continuing his conversation – beyond rude.
As said – ordered one “Say Cheese” which was a footlong with nacho cheese and one “Aloha Dog” which stated grilled pineapple, teriyaki sauce, and something else. This “hot dog” was beyond APPALLING. The pineapple wasn’t grilled. We watched as he opened a can of Dole diced pineapple and scoop a few tablespoons right onto the dog. I can’t quite tell you what their “teriyaki sauce” is, but I can tell you it was frigid. It was also lumpy and had some soft of mystery meat in it. I genuinely have no idea what it was, other than revolting.
We did order a small fry, which is totally serviceable. The highlight of the show. We then asked for two fountain drinks, they said they didn’t have any, only bottled. We went to the fridge in the back and the drinks were not cold – awesome. The group after us asked for fountain drinks, and then magically it was working.
This was honestly the worst “meal” I have had at a “restaurant” (if it can even call itself that) in a very long time. I don’t write reviews often, but I was compelled after my experience. STAY AWAY!!
Костадин Каръков
Thank you for the slice of pizza, the Margarita was amazing!! All the pizzas looked perfect and very appetizing, if you want to eat a nice pizza, the place is Pizzeria Eatly!!!
… more