Ava McDonnell
Love the pizza here. I also like how I can buy it by the slice from the window instead of needing to go into Dante’s.
Every time I come to the window and see a band playing I feel so tempted to go inside and buy a ticket.
The walk up window usually goes quickly even if there is a line.
Pizza starts at $4.50 a slice and goes up to $6.00. A whole pie is around $30 or more.
… moreDanielle Kinzler
I confidently think it’s the best by the slice that I’ve had. At least in Portland. Maybe ever? I definitely think it’s embarrassingly better than the other “NYC” spots. Greasier, trashier, hotter, cheesier, saucier, tastier. It lives up to its name and location. Pizza you don’t bring home to your momma. Bad news drunk pizza that tastes when sober like you remember pizza tasting like when you’re drunk. I kind of wish it was in a different spot and had a different name, because then I could recommend it with a straight face. As it is, I kinda fall silent of someone asks me to recommend a pizza spot. Don’t want to lie, can’t quite suggest this either. Maybe they should open a sit down annex and show off Sizzle Pie?
… morematthew
Good size slice of pizza. Decent price. It’s literally a hole in the wall. Good chew on the crust, sauce is savory, not sweet. Good amount of toppings. Very limited seating around to enjoy your pizza and drinks. If you’re in the area, it’s worth a taste.
… moreLindsey Franco
Tiny window on the corner of Dante’s. They also have pizza available inside next to the bar. I love ordering from the window when I’m skating downtown. Slice + drink. These slices are huge and can easily be split in half to share with someone else. Highly recommend. Great friendly service every time I come by. I asked if I could take a seat to eat at one of the tables outside of Dantes and they always let me. Just be cautious, it’s also a smoking zone. No trouble.
… moreRomina B.
Quite literally a hole in the wall right at the corner of a main street. Came here for a slice of pizza while browsing the streets during the evening. This city generally feels a bit sketchy at night so this place is no different, but the service interaction was fine and the pizza hit the spot in the moment. It‘ll definitely hit the spot when you‘re there but wouldn‘t consider this a spot worth intentionally going to.
… moreT W
Yes – you need this place. If you doubt it now wait till the later part of a Dante’s show or after you roll out of one of the local bars nearby. Enjoy.
… moreBeverly Landeros
The service and atmosphere almost make up for the (at best) mediocre pizza. We came here last year and it served phenomonal food. Now? The pepperoni wasn’t crisp, the cheese wasn’t melty, and the crust felt stale (even though it was fresh out of the oven.) Come only for a slice and the experience.
… moreKrystal Myth
It’s actually kind of absurd how good the pizza is here. It’s literally a giant New York slice, right here in Portland. I just wish they were on DoorDash and I’d deliver a whole pie every week. They’re incredible.
… moreLisa S
Rude employees. And the nerve to ask for tips. Being rude for no reason is so ugly. Do better. Or maybe don’t work with people. Lame burnt pizza too. Not worth it at all.
… moreJordan Bisenius
A cheekily named hole in the door pizza by the slice (or a while pie, if you’re keen) alongside Dante’s. First ever visit and I found the crew efficient and kind. No wait in line, and I walked away with everything I’d wanted.
… more