Michael Mason
First time trying Pizza Shop and was not disappointed. We had the Magic Dragon and a Bill The Butcher. Both were outstanding. The sauces and toppings were really good. Big fan of the crust with their nice crispy chew. Also good to know that they will sell you individual uncooked pizza crust for do it yourself pizza at home. Looking forward to giving it a try in my Ooni Pizza oven.
… moreLynn Lee
They brought their New York prices with them. Limited menu, the Butcher Shop pizza was good, though the crust was a bit tough and burned in the edges. The wings were baked not fried. Bathroom was disgusting.
… moreMark Johnson
Great pizza! Excellent attentive service. Before the door could shut after entering we were greeted and made to feel welcome. The pizza was made with Fresh, Quality ingredients that were evident in the taste of the pizza. Hand tossed crust was very good. Will go back again when in town!
… moreMadyson Brooks
10/10 all around. Great good, great service, cute building and great prices. Me and my husband got the lunch deal, 2 slices of pizza and a drink for $8 and that’s hard to beat. Some of the best pizza we’ve had in Oxford. We will definitely be back
… moreEliska Brown
My husband and I went to Pizzashop because they were one of few places open past 9pm in Oxford. We bought a Margarita Pizza on their gluten free crust. The service was great, the employees were friendly and helpful. Unfortunately, gluten free pizzas are charged by the topping, and the per topping price for BYO pizzas is a little steep for a two topping, 12-inch pizza, which totaled over $18.00.
Point blank, that gluten free pizza is nothing short of vile. We both tried to eat one slice before just throwing the pizza away entirely and went to Marco’s instead*.
Gluten free crust is never great, as someone allergic to gluten I’d know, but they aren’t disgusting either- unless of course, it’s whatever they used here. The sauce was incredibly salty, and I don’t think I’ve had Mozzarella cheese taste more like wet plastic before.
*Second Photo is the Marco’s Pizza replacement
… moreGreg Hoyt64
For a little NY Pizza Shop, they have a great menu, and wonderful pizza! Slice special with drink is a great deal!
… morePaula Clemons
Pizza was good other than it was burnt. I ate the topping off because I live in Water Valley to far to bring it back. If it hadn’t been burnt probably be the best pizza I have had in Oxford.
… moreJonathan Gay
I pick up pizzas from here almost every weekend. It’s my family’s favorite pizza in Oxford. My pizza is always ready when they say it will be. It’s very consistent and always delicious.
… moreMargaret Holland
The pizza was absolutely delicious. Staff and service was excellent. Will be going back again.
… moreBubba Logan
Stopped in for lunch and wanted to try the pizza shop and the guys were super nice and friendly plus the service was really quick the pizza was also great for a quick lunch will definitely stop in again
… more