Gary Ross
OMG! Do yourself a favor and try this place. Amazing staff, food, and a quiet atmosphere. We will most certainly be back (most likely tomorrow). The food was stellar. We started with Happy Hour drinks and an order of Venetian Bruschetta. Main course was Blackened Chicken Fettucine Alfredo, Chicken Piccata, and 2 of us split the 16″ Three Little Pigs with added onions. Portion sizes were huge. Should have done a 10″ pizza to split between the two of us.
I can’t stress enough how amazing this place was. I would drive here (4+ hours) just for the pizza it was that impressive.
… moreTibbs’s Mama
Glad we skipped the other pizza place and came here. This was a good find and obviously very popular!
We sat at the bar top since the wait for a table was about 45 minutes. Glad when we checked there were 2 spots just open!!
Pizza was delicious, hot and fresh! We had cannolis, which have been by far some of the best we’ve had! And only $5!! Sorry, no pictures, we were so happy with our food, we forgot to get any of the food itself.
… morejill symmonds
Out pig and fig was amazing omg The pizza crust and dough so subtly garlicky wow. Absolute love – so crispy yet tender
… moreBill Hutchins
Just ate here. Great pizza. It was a pepperoni with ricotta fresh basil and a little hot honey and light sauce. It was fantastic and a nice change from standard pizza. All the flavors compliment each other. Greeted at door quickly, seated in under 5 minutes despite being nearly packed. Server was quick to the table and orders were quick. Perfect on service topping off a great meal.
… moreCat Courtney
Server made great drinks and was attentive. Lobster ravioli and 7/10 needed salt and more flavor. Pizza 7/10 good pizza. I would fire sure stop in and try it and would go again
… moreKim Litzkow
They were giving away samples of their cheese pizza on the main street in old St. Augustine and let me tell you, it was out of this world good. My son, his girlfriend, and I were blown away as to how good it was. We kept walking around site seeing and decided to find the restaurant and eat our dinner there. We ordered cokes, side salads and a large cheese pizza. The salad was fresh and the dressings (honey mustard for me and ranch for my son and his girlfriend) were homemade and delicious. The pizza was so good, not quite as good as the sample but still absolutely delicious. It also was affordable. Under $35 which to me was a great price for everything we got. Next time I’m in St. Augustine, I will definitely be back.
… moreNoni
We stopped in for lunch last weekend and the food was insanely delicious! We ordered the skin on fries, tossed in Parmesan and two 10 inch pizzas. Best pizza in the historic district hands down. The bartender was a sweetheart as well and super friendly & attentive. The bar is beautiful & Frank Sinatra mix playing throughout the restaurant was awesome. Will definitely be back!
… moreAmanda Fernandez
Kaleb was an amazing bartender/server!! My boyfriend and I sat at the bar and he was super attentive and charismatic. Gave us some great suggestions and the recommendations were absolutely delicious. After walking around in the cold on New Year’s Eve, this was the best treat!!! Kaleb’s friendliness and overall great service made this a memorable experience for us. Will be coming back next time I visit St. Augustine.
… moreMatthew Bailey
Great restaurant! Some of the best pizza I’ve had outside of New York City. You can’t go wrong highly recommended!! Great service and atmosphere
… moreAmy Jilk
Lunch at Pizzalley’s Chianti Room was a win! The pizza was amazing, and the specialty options were so good. Our waitress was absolutely wonderful — friendly, attentive, and made the whole experience even better. Can’t wait to come back!
… more